Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

The Achilles heel of the colts is the Achilles tendon...


Recommended Posts

Maybe it's been discussed, but it seems we have one critical position (fisher), one very useful position (mack), and one high hopes position (odeyingbo) all hoping to return from Achilles injuries. We had some ties to mack but no reason to pick up the others. These injuries are not all equal presumably, but it seems like only 2/3 of nfl players return. It averages about 11 months, and most never return to form or full playing time. 


Maybe the colts docs and coaches know more than average, but this seems statistically crazy to bank so much on this many key players, especially since it blocks other players from being drafted or paid (I know it's not long contracts). Why do the colts love players with Achilles injuries more than every other team seems to? 

I was referencing this article:


I'd love to be wrong and want to be excited about all of them though! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • nsurg changed the title to The Achilles heel of the colts is the Achilles tendon...

Discussed a lot in many other threads already... 


But, IMO, worth discussing if the topic if it's about Indy's willingness to roll the dice on injuries in general.


Fisher - big gamble on a huge position of need. Early schedule could be ugly if Tevi has to start the first month. Huge gamble.


Dayo - good value in the 2nd. Young and should heal. It's a long term play, one that I'm not sure we should have taken given other needs. Good gamble.


Mack - pretty easy decision IMO. Cheap, and short term. Any production will be great. Good loyalty sign to set him with another team in 2022. If he heals well, he'll be a fantastic RB2. Almost zero risk and lots of upside. No risk gamble. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just like other types of tears, not only does everyone rehab and heal different but each year is different. Does anyone even know the severity of Fishers tear? There is 4 types and if his were a type 2 than the healing process could be much easier and less time versus a type 4. Many things go into these and trust me, the Colts medical staff will know far far more than anyone here. Ballard doesn’t sign a guy (Fisher) not thinking he plays in 2021. 

Dayo is young and could sit this year if need be but the mood has been he will be able to play in ‘21 as well. 

Mack is healed but the question will be, does he still have that explosion through the hole. Does he still have speed. And of course can he stay healthy. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • The Chargers didn't release Michael Badgley after Week 1, the Titans did - Tristan Vizcaino won the Chargers job in training camp and Badgley was among the final cuts. Tennessee signed him as their kicker was hurt, but released him after the 1st game when their starter returned.
    • I disagree to some extent on the bolded part.   I think there are two questions about the Wentz trade, any trade for that matter, that should be answered separately.    1) Are the Colts happy with trading for Wentz? Ultimately this will be answered in how he plays. 2) What price should the Colts have paid to acquire him? This is about his value and demand for him at the time the trade was made.   To put it another way, I might make a purchase and be happy with it but it doesn't mean I didn't overpay for said purchase. Or to put it more in line with football some people are happy the Colts drafted Nelson and Kelly but didn't think it was great value for where they were picked.   When you trade for a veteran a big part of the appeal is you know what you are getting. Even if you think there is some upside/untapped potential you usually are not using 1st round picks on veterans unless they are a sure thing. Coming off the season he had in 2020 Wentz was not a sure thing.    I will say the answer to question 1 is more important than question 2 but I still think what they gave up is a bit much for him considering the situation.                     
    • Because some fans just can’t wrap their heads around the idea that the Colts are going to pay a tone of money to Nelson to play guard.  
    • didn't want to start a thread for this tweet, but sticking it here.... no brainer for me. Herbert, Henry, Pittman, Brown    
    • Sorry brother. Didn't look at your time stamp, and we've known about TY returning for a bit, so assumed...   I do like the thought of Coutee sticking though if TY retires. If he can stay healthy, I think he'd be good with Wentz after a full off season. He and Campbell would make a nice 1-2 speed punch.
  • Members

  • Create New...