Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Deshaun Watson: Trade an entire draft class for him?


Recommended Posts

 

ESPN NFL Insider Jeremy Fowler believes that if Watson is going to be moved this year, it’s more likely to come right before the draft and even laid out a scenario where an NFL team could not only offer one entire draft class, but they might even offer two entire draft classes:

Quote

“I don’t expect free agency to move anything here,” Fowler said. “Speaking to several people around the league, it’s more the NFL Draft in late April that could move the Texans. I spoke to one GM that said he expects the team to throw its entire draft or two entire drafts at Houston in the late hours of the draft saying ‘here, you can have it all if I can have your quarterback.’ Perhaps that will finally move the Texans to do something.”

 

https://dailysnark.com/2021/03/01/report-one-nfl-team-might-offer-two-entire-drafts-to-texans-for-deshaun-watson/

 

:edit: Mod edit to make clear this is a 'what if' scenario

 

 

  • Haha 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

...I just can't see a team willing to do something like that. Sure, they'd get Watson, but they'd have nothing else. One step forward, ten steps back. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, RollerColt said:

...I just can't see a team willing to do something like that. Sure, they'd get Watson, but they'd have nothing else. One step forward, ten steps back. 

Texans would be smart to take a deal like that especially if it was from Jets or Dolphins and get your new franchise QB to build around

Link to post
Share on other sites
54 minutes ago, RollerColt said:

...I just can't see a team willing to do something like that. Sure, they'd get Watson, but they'd have nothing else. One step forward, ten steps back. 

 

You might be too young to remember when Mike Ditka traded all the his team's draft picks for RB Ricky Williams. Back in those days RBs had a lot of value. 

 

https://sports.nbcsports.com/2019/04/15/revisiting-saints-trading-entire-draft-for-ricky-williams-and-the-deals-that-almost-happened/

 

Two decades ago Wednesday, the New Orleans Saints made one of the craziest trades in NFL history. They traded all six 1999 draft choices and their first-round and third-round picks in 2000—eight draft choices in all—to Washington to move up seven spots in the first round of the ’99 draft to pick Texas running back Ricky Williams.

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
43 minutes ago, NFLfan said:

 

You might be too young to remember when Mike Ditka traded all the his team's draft picks for RB Ricky Williams. Back in those days RBs had a lot of value. 

 

https://sports.nbcsports.com/2019/04/15/revisiting-saints-trading-entire-draft-for-ricky-williams-and-the-deals-that-almost-happened/

 

Two decades ago Wednesday, the New Orleans Saints made one of the craziest trades in NFL history. They traded all six 1999 draft choices and their first-round and third-round picks in 2000—eight draft choices in all—to Washington to move up seven spots in the first round of the ’99 draft to pick Texas running back Ricky Williams.

Oh I remember, I’m just saying that to trade two entire drafts for one single player is foolish. 

 

1 hour ago, danlhart87 said:

Texans would be smart to take a deal like that especially if it was from Jets or Dolphins and get your new franchise QB to build around

Without a doubt! If someone actually offers that, they’d take it without hesitation. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Nadine changed the title to Deshaun Watson: Trade an entire draft class for him?
8 hours ago, RollerColt said:

I remember, I’m just saying that to trade two entire drafts for one single player is foolish

 

I agree. Giving up even one draft class is ridiculous. That is an example of mortgaging the future. It is foolish, as you said. It takes only one injury to end a player's career. 

 

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, teganslaw said:

Never mind. I just read that it didn't turn out so well.  I hope that this kind of thing doesn't happen again. 

 

Just think, the Texans went 4-12 with Watson. 

How would it turn out for a team to give up two drafts? 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I think two draft classes is too much to trade for anybody.  I would not have done that to get Peyton or Luck.

 

One draft class for Deshaun is steep, but might be worth it if a team felt they were just a QB away.  I don't know who that would be right now

Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, aaron11 said:

I think two draft classes is too much to trade for anybody.  I would not have done that to get Peyton or Luck.

 

One draft class for Deshaun is steep, but might be worth it if a team felt they were just a QB away.  I don't know who that would be right now

Certainly not Luck. He never won anything. No SB, no MVP and he go the ECF once and got wiped out. Peyton would have been a different story. I wouldn't have done it with Peyton because of his age when the Colts became dominant. Brady, on the other hand, twenty years ago might have been worth something like that. But, no, not even the GOAT. I think the Colts overpaid for Wentz (the Eagle had no other offers). I think one second round pick would have been too high. One third or fourth round pick would have been more like it. I am doubtful that Wentz is every the QB he was in 2017-18.

  • Like 1
  • Sad 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

That's the thing with Watson, the trade value for him is going to be so high that whatever team he's going to isn't going to be able to draft well to help build the team around him.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Valpo2004 said:

That's the thing with Watson, the trade value for him is going to be so high that whatever team he's going to isn't going to be able to draft well to help build the team around him.  

That is an issue for the Texans as well.  I think they would be smart to set a more reasonable price and move on, his comments are making it hard for him to ever suit up there again.

 

They could fine and charge him a lot of money, but that will not help them on the field.

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, teganslaw said:

How did it turn out for Mike Ditka? Did he regret doing it?

He certainly was not worth it. I remember Ricky Williams more as a Dolphins player than as a Saints player. I don't believe anyone in football is worth that gamble, including the greatest players of all time. 

 

I wonder what Saints fans thought about that. A long time ago, just before I began following football, the Vikings traded a lot to Dallas for Hershel Walker. It is believed that it was that trade that helped Dallas draft key players to help them on their way to winning 4 Super Bowls. Hershel Walker never really did much with the Vikings. He is never mentioned when we talk of the best Vikings RBs. Yet we gave up a lot for him. I would not have been pleased with that trade, as I like building through the draft. 

 

So, no, trading a draft class or two for one player is not smart.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Depends. If it's Seattle, sure. They could get a great exchange for Wilson and their picks would be low in every round. Chicage might as well, thinking Watson would make them a SB contender. Sound like a lot to give up, but low round picks don't have a great deal of value.

Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, ColtJax said:

Depends. If it's Seattle, sure. They could get a great exchange for Wilson and their picks would be low in every round. Chicage might as well, thinking Watson would make them a SB contender. Sound like a lot to give up, but low round picks don't have a great deal of value.

I remember during the draft when Watson came out and Chicago traded up to get the #2 pick, I was like I called it even saying that in here, laughing. Thinking I called it, this was too easy. Then I heard this - with the 2nd pick of the 2017 draft, the Chicago Bears select Mitchell Trubisky. I was like homer falling GIF

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 3/1/2021 at 9:55 PM, NFLfan said:

 

You might be too young to remember when Mike Ditka traded all the his team's draft picks for RB Ricky Williams. Back in those days RBs had a lot of value. 

 

https://sports.nbcsports.com/2019/04/15/revisiting-saints-trading-entire-draft-for-ricky-williams-and-the-deals-that-almost-happened/

 

Two decades ago Wednesday, the New Orleans Saints made one of the craziest trades in NFL history. They traded all six 1999 draft choices and their first-round and third-round picks in 2000—eight draft choices in all—to Washington to move up seven spots in the first round of the ’99 draft to pick Texas running back Ricky Williams.

 

The Colts picked Edge the pick right before Ricky Williams too! 

 

 

WHEW! 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 3/2/2021 at 7:35 AM, NFLfan said:

 

I agree. Giving up even one draft class is ridiculous. That is an example of mortgaging the future. It is foolish, as you said. It takes only one injury to end a player's career. 

 

 

I also think a lot of fans on the team would hate to be told that they'll have to skip the entire NFL draft because their organization is telling them to trust a single player they're bringing over is a good signing.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

After the 4th round the rest are basically fliers, and if you pick low enough the 3rd and 4th might be that as well. With FA's and UDFA's I'd love to be a team like Chicago and make that deal. Now the thing is, why would Houston? They could get the Jet's 2 1st rounders, a second and next years 1st or 2nd rounder. I'll bet the Jags could trade their 1st pick to the Bears for every one of their picks in a second, but the Jag fans would riot..

Link to post
Share on other sites

I still think the Falcons can make a play for him by giving up Matt Ryan and 2 first round picks and call it a day. Texans would be crazy not to take it given how much they can multiply a No.3 pick and a No.4 pick in this current draft to boost the talent on their squad. Watson and Ryan both exchange domes, and if the Texans bring back Fuller and Cooks, they will have the bookend WRs for Ryan and Watson will enjoy Julio Jones and Calvin Ridley plenty. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Or the Jets giving up Darnold, the 2nd pick in the draft and the Sehawlks #1.

Or the Dolphins QB, Tua, the #3 pick and the Phins #1 pick.

 

How about the Raiderrs, Carr, the Raiders #1 and #2 pick and the OT Brown. Another Carr in Houston...

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, ColtJax said:

Or the Jets giving up Darnold, the 2nd pick in the draft and the Sehawlks #1.

Or the Dolphins QB, Tua, the #3 pick and the Phins #1 pick.

 

How about the Raiderrs, Carr, the Raiders #1 and #2 pick and the OT Brown. Another Carr in Houston...

David Carr had said Raiders should trade for Russell Wilson recently 

 

Thats messed up 

 

Season 4 Wow GIF by The Office

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, ColtJax said:

Or the Jets giving up Darnold, the 2nd pick in the draft and the Sehawlks #1.

Or the Dolphins QB, Tua, the #3 pick and the Phins #1 pick.

 

How about the Raiderrs, Carr, the Raiders #1 and #2 pick and the OT Brown. Another Carr in Houston...


I heard Colts did inquire about Carr but The Raiders weren’t interested in trading Carr away. 
 

Dolphins are more talented than the Jets or Raiders, IMO and with very good QB play, can get to the AFCCG.

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok I'm going to say it as no one else seems to be....

 

Watson is NOT that good. Let's all get real here. This guy isn't worth near anything that is being mentioned to get him in return.

 

Is he worth a first round pick? YES and that's it.

 

As a reminder, he was on a team that went 4-12... ELITE QB's, as they are treating Watson to be, will elevate their ball clubs at least 3 wins minimum when they are on bad teams, sometimes more... Watson didn't come close to that

 

In the games they LOST, they were beat by an average of 10 points a game... That's two scores worse

 

They beat the 1-16 Jags twice, the 3-7 Lions and the 4-12 Pats... Come on?

 

Watson is NOT elite... He needs premiere talent around him to win... 

 

He is talented and a top 15 QB but he is not Elite and no one should offer elite compensation to retain him

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Indeee said:

Ok I'm going to say it as no one else seems to be....

 

Watson is NOT that good. Let's all get real here. This guy isn't worth near anything that is being mentioned to get him in return.

 

Is he worth a first round pick? YES and that's it.

 

As a reminder, he was on a team that went 4-12... ELITE QB's, as they are treating Watson to be, will elevate their ball clubs at least 3 wins minimum when they are on bad teams, sometimes more... Watson didn't come close to that

 

In the games they LOST, they were beat by an average of 10 points a game... That's two scores worse

 

They beat the 1-16 Jags twice, the 3-7 Lions and the 4-12 Pats... Come on?

 

Watson is NOT elite... He needs premiere talent around him to win... 

 

He is talented and a top 15 QB but he is not Elite and no one should offer elite compensation to retain him

 

 

Watson had an MVP level season last year and he did so without Hopkins. 

 

He deserves the elite treatment he's getting because he is.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, danlhart87 said:

Watson had an MVP level season last year and he did so without Hopkins. 

 

He deserves the elite treatment he's getting because he is.

Thats your opinion. Mine is he is not. Either way,  our opinions don't mean a hill of beans...haha

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Indeee said:

Thats your opinion. Mine is he is not. Either way,  our opinions don't mean a hill of beans...haha

I'm fairly certain most people would agree that Watson is elite but to each their own 

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Indeee said:

Ok I'm going to say it as no one else seems to be....

 

Watson is NOT that good. Let's all get real here. This guy isn't worth near anything that is being mentioned to get him in return.

 

Is he worth a first round pick? YES and that's it.

 

As a reminder, he was on a team that went 4-12... ELITE QB's, as they are treating Watson to be, will elevate their ball clubs at least 3 wins minimum when they are on bad teams, sometimes more... Watson didn't come close to that

 

In the games they LOST, they were beat by an average of 10 points a game... That's two scores worse

 

They beat the 1-16 Jags twice, the 3-7 Lions and the 4-12 Pats... Come on?

 

Watson is NOT elite... He needs premiere talent around him to win... 

 

He is talented and a top 15 QB but he is not Elite and no one should offer elite compensation to retain him

 

 

"Watson is NOT that good" - your words. That comment there may be one of the worst takes I have ever read on here. Whether he is Elite/great or not is debatable I guess, but he is very good. Other than Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady who probably only has a year or 2 left, and maybe Wilson I can't think of another QB I would rather want than Watson. I thought Luck was slightly better but Luck retired. I would take Watson over Jackson, Jackson just has a much better team and coach.

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Indeee said:

Ok I'm going to say it as no one else seems to be....

 

Watson is NOT that good. Let's all get real here. This guy isn't worth near anything that is being mentioned to get him in return.

 

Is he worth a first round pick? YES and that's it.

 

As a reminder, he was on a team that went 4-12... ELITE QB's, as they are treating Watson to be, will elevate their ball clubs at least 3 wins minimum when they are on bad teams, sometimes more... Watson didn't come close to that

 

In the games they LOST, they were beat by an average of 10 points a game... That's two scores worse

 

They beat the 1-16 Jags twice, the 3-7 Lions and the 4-12 Pats... Come on?

 

Watson is NOT elite... He needs premiere talent around him to win... 

 

He is talented and a top 15 QB but he is not Elite and no one should offer elite compensation to retain him

 

 

@Indeeeyou are certainly entitled to your opinion about the abilities of Watson or anyone else.  I'd say that it is in the extremely small minority of most other opinions, however.  Watson is a top 5 QB in the league.  You mentioned elevating a team for 3 or more victories...he did that.  Houston was HORRIBLE last year and only won 4 games because of Watson, IMHO.  Again, you are entitled to your opinion, we all have them.  I'll side with the vast majority of NFL watchers and say Watson is incredible. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

"Watson is NOT that good" - your words. That comment there may be one of the worst takes I have ever read on here. Whether he is Elite/great or not is debatable I guess, but he is very good. Other than Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady who probably only has a year or 2 left, and maybe Wilson I can't think of another QB I would rather want than Watson. I thought Luck was slightly better but Luck retired. I would take Watson over Jackson, Jackson just has a much better team and coach.

FTR the only current QB I would take over Watson is Mahomes. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Indeee said:

Thats your opinion. Mine is he is not. Either way,  our opinions don't mean a hill of beans...haha

You're on an island all alone with your opinion

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

You're on an island all alone with your opinion

Ok even though I don't feel the need to defend my position, I will anyway.

 

I will backtrack a bit as Watson is a good QB. He is not Elite though and I stand by that. Could he eventually be? Sure, I guess, however anyone who would be giving up an entire draft class as the original post stated is banking on him one day becoming elite and that to me is just plain stupid unless he goes to a team that has stacked talent already like the Cowboys or the Niners. 

 

That is really what my response truly is about. I would not give up more than a first as I don't believe that Watson is elite at this stage of his career, right or wrong

Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, Indeee said:

Ok even though I don't feel the need to defend my position, I will anyway.

 

I will backtrack a bit as Watson is a good QB. He is not Elite though and I stand by that. Could he eventually be? Sure, I guess, however anyone who would be giving up an entire draft class as the original post stated is banking on him one day becoming elite and that to me is just plain stupid unless he goes to a team that has stacked talent already like the Cowboys or the Niners. 

 

That is really what my response truly is about. I would not give up more than a first as I don't believe that Watson is elite at this stage of his career, right or wrong

Not that you probably care about what I say but this post is a lot better. I wouldn't give up an entire draft class for Watson either. He is very good but giving up an entire draft class for him would be silly. I would shell out 2 1st round picks = this year (2021) and next year's (2022), and this year's 2nd round pick (2021) as well. After that I would have to see where the negotiations take me.

 

Stafford went for 2 1st round picks and a 3rd round pick but the 2 1st round picks are in 2022 and 2023. The Lions did get Goff though.

Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

Not that you probably care about what I say but this post is a lot better. I wouldn't give up an entire draft class for Watson either. He is very good but giving up an entire draft class for him would be silly. I would shell out 2 1st round picks = this year and next year's, and this year's 2nd as well. After that I would have to see where the negotiations take me.

I'm never opposed to entertaining anyone's opinions or takes on any subject pro or con vs. my own. Sometimes my head knows what I'm writing but my fingers don't translate properly on first attempt... Ha!! 

  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Indeee said:

I'm never opposed to entertaining anyone's opinions or takes on any subject pro or con vs. my own. Sometimes my head knows what I'm writing but my fingers don't translate properly on first attempt... Ha!! 

I actually added to my post above. Yeah I respect everyone's opinion, I was just shocked when you said Watson was not good. You clarified what you meant today though. It is all good. Looks like you just meant he is not Elite.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Watson will not suit up for the Texans this year if they don't trade him. The closer the draft gets it would make sense the Texans will move on him or dump a bunch of the clowns in the front office. Since they have been incompetents since the franchise started I feel certain they will screw this up as well. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Considering how he's being talked about, he's overrated. He's worth multiple first round picks for sure, but I'm reading things like the Jets giving up both their 1st round picks, their second round picks and next years 1st and 2nd round picks. That's just flat out stupid! If I'm the Jets I'm offering their 1st (2nd pick in the draft), the Seahawk's #1 pick and maybe the Jets 3rd rounder and that's it. This isn't Payton Manning we're talking about. He's a good to very good quarterback, but he's not THAT good..

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • One of the biggest benefits of this defense is the ability to play it with middle of the road CBs.... If of course, you have a pass rush   You invest in pass rush DL vs CBs   If you play a lot of Man to man, you need 1 or 2 - 12-16M players   CBs are some of the most expensive position to fill   Jalen Ramsey's cap hit is 21 million this year.......     People keep calling on us to spend big FA money and early draft capitol on CBs, just like other teams   IMHO, keep bringing 2nd, 3rd, and 4th round CBs that are 6ft or bigger, and might run a 4.5 forty but can tackle   You do need a safety that can play to cover the deep ball when the DL doenst get home, but you cant have both          
    • In a way it doesn’t even matter if the cap goes way up. All that means is your stats are going to get paid more.
    • The reality of the situation is that you try to keep your 4-5 stars, rotate out your aging or expensive middle of the roster and hope that you keep up with a robust inexpensive rookie haul each year   I see these "middle guys" getting traded for draft picks, or being allowed to leave via FA (Which creates comp picks)    
    • I was having similar thoughts a while ago - how can we have so much money tied in the OL and isn't this detrimental to the team? The more I've been thinking about it the more I feel like... it's all about allocation of resources. Every team has limited resources and if you allocate too much resources to one area you might be hitting the point of diminishing returns. For example... would you rather pay 40% of your cap on the no. 1 OL in the league or 30% on the no. 5 OL in the league? And where is the cut off where it all becomes excessive spending that can be used better elsewhere on the roster? But also... we have to account for draft picks in our considerations, too.   This is really the main couple of resources for acquiring talent - cap space and draft picks . It's interesting that they are almost completely decoupled, too ... meaning - for huge majority of draft picks, the cap spent is minuscule and doesn't impact the cap space much and at the same time for the biggest of our cap spendings we don't spend draft resources(Buckner and Q being the exceptions here). It's also important to not count it twice once the draft picks enter their second contract. At least I don't ... so... in essence it becomes - cap space + RECENT draft picks(still on rookie contracts)....   In essence my position has been ammended to something along the lines of - I don't care what % of the money we spend on specific position group as long as there is enough resources (this might include draft picks) spent on most other important positions. Example -   - QB - we spent 1st, 3d and 25M a year for QB. This is plenty IMO. People seem to consider it cheap but it is NOT cheap when you account for BOTH the picks and the money. If Wentz gets back to his previous form with us, I am good with it. I think it's worth it having that type of QB. - EDGE group - no big money spent, but pretty big draft resources - currently 1st round pick, 3 second round picks.. - Interior pass-rush - big money, big resources (22M a year for Buckner, 10M a year for Grover, 1st for Buckner). - OL - good mix of money and draft resources (Fisher 10M, Kelly 12M, Glowinski 6M + 1st + 2nd on Q and Braden)... now if you have to replace the 1st and 2nd from Braden with big money you will need to spend some picks rather than money on other positions and this is exactly what we did with EDGE - shuffled around the resources spent from money(Autry, Houston) to draft picks - Paye, Odeyingbo - CB - this IMO is the group that is in a holding pattern... I don't know where we will go with it, because we have some pick investments, but they are to a huge degree question marks and Kenny is our only CB with somewhat big(still not huge though) contract past this year. IMO Ballard is waiting on them(Rock, Tell, Rodgers) to show him something either way and we are very likely to address it next year. BTW I have not watched next year's CBs, but the PFF guys seem to think next year's CB class is very good... probably too ealry to tell at this point but worth keeping in mind. I wonder if Ballard looks ahead to future drafts...  - WR - good, not great resources spent - 2 2nd round pick + short term deal for TY... another position in holding pattern.    So I guess my general position is - As long as the roster overall has good talent at other positions be it through bargain FA contracts that hit or through draft picks, I'm good with us splurging a bit on a specific area of the team that we consider important. In general I feel like our resources have been spent relatively well, with some minor gripes here and there, but even for them there IMO is a good reason.   
    • I hadn't though about it much, but the LB position isn't robust beyond Darrius.  It'll be a thing at some point, bank on it.
  • Members

    • The Fish

      The Fish 1,199

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • shasta519

      shasta519 3,089

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • BillCoslosky87

      BillCoslosky87 1,154

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • cdgacoltsfan

      cdgacoltsfan 705

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Wentzszn

      Wentzszn 10,549

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • rock8591

      rock8591 562

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Douzer

      Douzer 519

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • DoubleE Colt

      DoubleE Colt 70

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • dw49

      dw49 747

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • RollerColt

      RollerColt 2,802

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...