Should the Colts have contracted with Brady instead of Rivers?

[CR91 6,936]

Rumor has it Brady's had interest in indy. The colts were not interested.

 

Speculation by Peter King was that the colts were interested in a shorter deal than Brady wanted

 

Truth is I'm not really sure, but with the Bucs making the NFC championship, it's an interesting question.

 

https://www.sportingnews.com/us/nfl/news/colts-tom-brady-philip-rivers/ija7iqui6i4n18vvjdppqstb4

 

[PrincetonTiger 8,516]

[chad72 7,391]

If the Colts defense forced 4 turnovers in the playoff game or stopped playing Jekyll and Hyde throughout the year, we might have been just as good as the Bucs in terms of results. 

[AustinnKaine 346]

2 minutes ago, CR91 said:

Rumor has it Brady's first choice was indy, but the colts didn't want to give him a contract over one year. Truth is I'm not really sure, but with the Bucs making the NFC championship, it's an interesting question.

Hopefully we don't make the mistake of resigning Rivers. 

[CR91 6,936]

4 minutes ago, chad72 said:

If the Colts defense forced 4 turnovers in the playoff game or stopped playing Jekyll and Hyde throughout the year, we might have been just as good as the Bucs in terms of results. 

 

Defense did their job. They got a big sack and forced the Bills out of FG range. Offense didn't get the job done.

[RollerColt 2,670]

Indy his first choice? Seems kinda doubtful that’s true... 

[CR91 6,936]

3 minutes ago, RollerColt said:

Indy his first choice? Seems kinda doubtful that’s true... 

 

That was the rumor. 

[luv_pony_express 644]

Just now, CR91 said:

 

That was the rumor. 

If his intent was to flip a big bird to the Pats, I could believe it.  Kraft and Belichick reportedly despise the Colts, which is why they put the hard press on McDaniels to leave us at the altar.

[RollerColt 2,670]

Just now, CR91 said:

 

That was the rumor. 

Very interesting. I mean, the eyeball test of course says Brady is doing a lot better in performance... 

 

Definitely has a stronger arm at this point in the game compared to Rivers. 

[Four2itus 5,030]

Ugg. 

[danlhart87 8,616]

23 minutes ago, AustinnKaine said:

Hopefully we don't make the mistake of resigning Rivers. 

I look forward to your noodle arm 2.0 thread 

[Four2itus 5,030]

Just now, danlhart87 said:

I look forward to your noodle arm 2.0 thread 

Exactly. 

[jvan1973 5,481]

17 minutes ago, CR91 said:

 

That was the rumor. 

I never heard that from anyone

[CR91 6,936]

1 minute ago, danlhart87 said:

I look forward to your noodle arm 2.0 thread 

 

I'm not for nor against signing Rivers back. I just think we can spend the 20+ elsewhere, but the question then becomes do you roll with Eason, do you trade for a vet QB like Carr, Ryan, or Stafford, or do you trade up for say Trey Lance

[CR91 6,936]

1 minute ago, jvan1973 said:

I never heard that from anyone

 

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.sportingnews.com/us/amp/nfl/news/colts-tom-brady-philip-rivers/ija7iqui6i4n18vvjdppqstb4

[danlhart87 8,616]

1 minute ago, CR91 said:

 

I'm not for nor against signing Rivers back. I just think we can spend the 20+ elsewhere, but the question then becomes do you roll with Eason, do you trade for a vet QB like Carr, Ryan, or Stafford, or do you trade up for say Trey Lance

I would be fine going into 21 with this

 

Rivers Lance Eason

Or 

Jones Brissett Eason 

[PrincetonTiger 8,516]

Just now, danlhart87 said:

I would be fine going into 21 with this

 

Rivers Lance Eason

Or 

Jones Brissett Eason 

The latest mock had Lance going to Detroit and Jones falling to Chicago at 32

[CR91 6,936]

2 minutes ago, danlhart87 said:

I would be fine going into 21 with this

 

Rivers Lance Eason

Or 

Jones Brissett Eason 

 

Haven't watched much on Mac Jones, but I heard the Pats are interested at 15

[danlhart87 8,616]

1 minute ago, CR91 said:

 

Haven't watched much on Mac Jones, but I heard the Pats are interested at 15

He's not mobile but is very accurate. He will definitely need a good line to succeed. 

 

We have that. 

[PrincetonTiger 8,516]

Just now, danlhart87 said:

He's not mobile but is very accurate. He will definitely need a good line to succeed. 

 

We have that. 

He was once a Kentucky commit

[danlhart87 8,616]

1 minute ago, PrincetonTiger said:

He was once a Kentucky commit

[CR91 6,936]

8 minutes ago, danlhart87 said:

He's not mobile but is very accurate. He will definitely need a good line to succeed. 

 

We have that. 

 

Take a quick look. Nice touch, but not much of an arm. It does discourage me though that a lot of his throws were either to wide open WRs or Smith making a ridiculous catch.

[danlhart87 8,616]

6 minutes ago, CR91 said:

 

Take a quick look. Nice touch, but not much of an arm. It does discourage me though that a lot of his throws were either to wide open WRs or Smith making a ridiculous catch.

his receivers are elite so he does lose lots of credibility with that. I think his stock now is bottom 1st - definitely day 2 pick

[BillCoslosky87 1,153]

I love my Colts, but I could never cheer for Tom Brady, not even as a member of the Colts.

[PrincetonTiger 8,516]

1 minute ago, danlhart87 said:

his receivers are elite so he does lose lots of credibility with that. I think his stock now is bottom 1st - definitely day 2 pick

He has definitely started to trend in the wrong way 

[danlhart87 8,616]

1 minute ago, BillCoslosky87 said:

I love my Colts, but I could never cheer for Tom Brady, not even as a member of the Colts.

You would definitely cheer for him in a Colts uniform 

[danlhart87 8,616]

Just now, PrincetonTiger said:

He has definitely started to trend in the wrong way 

actually the right way

before this year he was probably mid rounder

 

this season amplified his stock 

[PrincetonTiger 8,516]

Just now, danlhart87 said:

actually the right way

before this year he was probably mid rounder

 

this season amplified his stock 

At Mid season he is a sure fire 1st Rounder

[danlhart87 8,616]

Just now, PrincetonTiger said:

At Mid season he is a sure fire 1st Rounder

he still could be

Just now, danlhart87 said:

he still could be

I have him bottom 1 currently 

[IinD 2,146]

Irsay is definitely big on loyalty, he wouldn't have done that to Peyton IMO, no proof of course. A disrespect type thing.

 

If he were never our rival, he would've definitely been an option for us.

[CR91 6,936]

6 minutes ago, danlhart87 said:

actually the right way

before this year he was probably mid rounder

 

this season amplified his stock 

 

Yea, but both his WRs are going in the first round. That's going to be hard to separate. Look at how much Tua struggled and both his WRs went in the first round.

[The Fish 1,184]

I'm not so sure you're getting wildly different results if you swap Tom unto the Colts this past year.

 

The Colts don't have anything approaching what TB has in terms of WR's and I think that unit is picking up Brady's game at this point. He looks okay, but he's not driving the thing. 

[PrincetonTiger 8,516]

1 minute ago, CR91 said:

 

Yea, but both his WRs are going in the first round. That's going to be hard to separate. Look at how much Tua struggled and both his WRs went in the first round.

[crazycolt1 7,556]

The only mistake the Colts made with Brady is not drafting him in the 5th round in 2000 to back up Manning. 

[Duke_Of_NY_A_Number_1 13]

I think Brady wanted to go to the NFC to avoid all the good AFC teams with good to elite QBs.

[ojsglove 351]

WOW  I thought we were in all in mode??  Truth is we are in some trouble next year.  I think Rivers was Rivers and done what he has done his whole career, Thank you Phillip, you got us to the playoffs, and silenced the mob, for another season.  We have free agents that will want raises if we want them to play for us next season.  Our current system is not going to work.  we payed our current backup QB 10 million this season for being a good  locker room guy?  Frank is not going to coach us to the ring. Chris is great at drafting talent, but doesn't seem to have much say, so on how we retain them.  Jim, I think you are the best owner in the NFL, but your hope of drafting another Peyton, or Andrew, to right the Horse is futile at best.

 

 

I hope I am totally wrong, but  I am a COLTS fan, and this is MHO.

 

[pacolts56 3,910]

No

[tweezy32 373]

2 hours ago, AustinnKaine said:

Hopefully we don't make the mistake of resigning Rivers. 

Wouldn’t be a mistake. 

[Tsarquise 449]

All I know is that the season would have been even more entertaining than it already was if Brady was under center in a Colts uniform. 

[crazycolt1 7,556]

3 hours ago, ojsglove said:

WOW  I thought we were in all in mode??  Truth is we are in some trouble next year.  I think Rivers was Rivers and done what he has done his whole career, Thank you Phillip, you got us to the playoffs, and silenced the mob, for another season.  We have free agents that will want raises if we want them to play for us next season.  Our current system is not going to work.  we payed our current backup QB 10 million this season for being a good  locker room guy?  Frank is not going to coach us to the ring. Chris is great at drafting talent, but doesn't seem to have much say, so on how we retain them.  Jim, I think you are the best owner in the NFL, but your hope of drafting another Peyton, or Andrew, to right the Horse is futile at best.

 

 

I hope I am totally wrong, but  I am a COLTS fan, and this is MHO.

 

Must be sad to have a sky is falling attitude?