Favorite Active Nfl Player (Non Colt)

[hawkeyes]

WHAT? No one has said Tebow?

[BOTT]

todd light

[IcEWoLF]

Offense: Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez, Jimmy Graham, Megratron (Calvin Johnson).

Defense: Ed Reed, JJ Watts, Julius Peppers.

And yes, I am in love with those 3 TE's.

They are probably the best in the business.

[eaglejoe8]

If I'm sticking with the letter of the law (thread) - Shady McCoy.

I'f I'm going with the spirit of the law (thread) - Aaron Rodgers.

[04DarkShadowGT]

Drew Brees, Boiler Up.

[DILLIGAFER]

Lol 3 people have said Peyton Manning even though the OP says never on th Colts. Have I stumbled onto an alternate universe in which we picked Ryan Leaf #1 in 1998?

He said a non colt.. as of today.. Peyton isnt a colt anymore

PEYTON FREAKIN MANNING, BABY!!

[smittywerb]

Hmmm, I would have to go with Pat Willis. Dude is a beast. He's a LB with DB speed and lineman strength.

[Gavin]

Ray Lewis, hes a motivator like no one else

[GGW4Mike]

O- Eli Manning

D-Patrick Willis

[CCH]

He said a non colt.. as of today.. Peyton isnt a colt anymore

PEYTON FREAKIN MANNING, BABY!!

Actually the first sentence says never on the Colts...

[DILLIGAFER]

I read the title non colt. Didnt bother to read the rest.

[LJpalmbeacher2]

You know, I'm trying to think of one But I don't think I have any.

[That Guy]

The more I read on Antonio Garay, the more I liked him. The man is straight up ridiculous. He reminds me of what Pat McAfee would be, if he were a DT.

[Dan]

Arian Foster (fantasy hero), Ed Reed, Ray Lewis, Larry Fitzgerald, Patrick Peterson, Jared Allen, Patrick Willis...

[That Guy]

Offense: Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez, Jimmy Graham, Megratron (Calvin Johnson).

Defense: Ed Reed, JJ Watts, Julius Peppers.

And yes, I am in love with those 3 TE's.

They are probably the best in the business.

Ha! I do love me a tight end...

Kidding aside, Gronk is starting to grow on me with his antics. If he played for any other team, I would probably really like the kid (can I call him a kid, if he's only two years younger than me?). He has accomplished the difficult task of making me dislike the Patriots less.

[IndyTrav]

Larry Fitzgerald.

His playoff run in 2008? Was the most impressed I have ever been by a single player. Barry Sanders included.

[GoColts8818]

Eli Manning and that includes Peyton. I am grateful for Peyton but I've always felt like if peyton wasn't a colt Eli would be my favorite manning. What can I say he saved us from a Tom Brady super bowl twice Peyton only did it once. The last line is ment in fun and not as a shot at Peyton.

[Holden89]

Tim Tebow

I'm not being sarcastic.

No, really....I mean it

[Girlzarefanstoo]

Lol 3 people have said Peyton Manning even though the OP says never on th Colts. Have I stumbled onto an alternate universe in which we picked Ryan Leaf #1 in 1998?

Oh if only you would have, LOL!!!!!!!

[Gramz]

Peyton ~~ always my favorite.

Eli very close 2nd

[coltsfanatic24]

darrelle revis is my favorite non colt. the guy can completely shutdown an entire field that's a luxury to have. hes shut down fitz,andre.wayne,moss,marshall, all the top wr's. if i could have any player to put on the colts roster it would be revis.

[Jules]

todd light

[vinatierifan4]

Thats close, but probably peyton.

[vtcoltsfan802]

O - Andre Johnson, Calvin Johnson, Lesean McCoy, Adrian Peterson,

D - Patrick Peterson, Ed Reed, Charles Woodson, Ray Lewis,

ST - Sebastian Janikowski

gotta love sebass! wasn't he a 1st or 2nd round pick too?

[Poster X]

Calvin Johnson hands down, or up. No matter where they are if you throw it his way chances are he will probably catch it.

[oldunclemark]

Forgetting Peyton and Eli..

...Ray Lewis

a character..........certainly not a saint (although that phrase needs to be redefined) and a violence addict, for sure

..but he admits he is only in it to win it and he tries to carry the whole team from a motivation standpoint

.and he has such a high spirit level

[Moncrief]

gotta love sebass! wasn't he a 1st or 2nd round pick too?

Yes 1st rounder. 17th overall I think

[achcolts]

peyton manning for sure