Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

[Rapoport] Malik Hooker is feared to have torn Achilles. MRI tomorrow.


Recommended Posts

Well. Next man up. Odum will do just fine plus you have Blackmon waiting in the wings! 

 

Unfortunately fo Hooker I doubt he'll be healthy prior to the end of training camps next year so he will not be getting a good second contract. Too bad for him.

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

I don’t call guys undone by injuries busts. To me a bust is a player that shows that from a skill standpoint he doesn’t measure up.  I think Hooker measures up skill-wise, but he has been undone by injuries.  It’s a shame because he could’ve been really good.  :(

Well said!

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

I don’t call guys undone by injuries busts. To me a bust is a player that shows that from a skill standpoint he doesn’t measure up.  I think Hooker measures up skill-wise, but he has been undone by injuries.  It’s a shame because he could’ve been really good.  :(

Great Day GIF by memecandy

Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

I don’t call guys undone by injuries busts. To me a bust is a player that shows that from a skill standpoint he doesn’t measure up.  I think Hooker measures up skill-wise, but he has been undone by injuries.  It’s a shame because he could’ve been really good.  :(

I agree, but 

 

Do you consider Greg Oden a bust?

 

He never really got to show the skill set because of injuries.

 

But he was drafted in front of Durant, compounding the bust label.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I’m kinda worried going forward. No preseason has guys dropping like flies, or at least it has to be part of it.

 

Hopefully guy’s bodies adjust or whatever. I know Hooker, Mack, and Parris have dealt with injuries but for all of them to go down like that? Yeah.

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, w87r said:

I agree, but 

 

Do you consider Greg Oden a bust?

 

He never really got to show the skill set because of injuries.

 

But he was drafted in front of Durant, compounding the bust label.

There is a big difference in a top 15 pick and undrafted free agent.  Undrafted free agents can’t really be busts.  

  • Confused 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Fisticuffs111 said:

I’m kinda worried going forward. No preseason has guys dropping like flies, or at least it has to be part of it.

 

Hopefully guy’s bodies adjust or whatever. I know Hooker, Mack, and Parris have dealt with injuries for all of them to go down like that? Yeah.

The amount of injuries league wide is very troubling. 

Big names dropping.

 

3 potential season injuries for the Colts already is very worrisome. Not small names either, prominent role players. Not even to mention Doyle and Burton.

 

Lack of live reps amd preparations have to be playing major role I would think.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, GoColts8818 said:

There is a big difference in a top 15 pick and undrafted free agent.  Undrafted free agents can’t really be busts.  

Well of course...

 

 Not sure what that is referring to though?

 

Rocky said he doesn't consider players bust who get injured, he considers them bust if their talent don't stack up to high expectations.

 

He was referring to Hooker(top 15 pick)

I listed counter Oden(#1 pick, albeit basketball) to get his thoughts in that situation.

 

There is no expectations from undrafted guys or any mention about them.?

Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, w87r said:

I agree, but 

 

Do you consider Greg Oden a bust?

 

He never really got to show the skill set because of injuries.

 

But he was drafted in front of Durant, compounding the bust label.

Even though Oden is labeled a bust he definitely is not. That's a media creation fans have bought into...

 

A bust is a guy like Flowers the LT drafted by NYG who looks like he doesn't belong on this level.

Link to post
Share on other sites
51 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

I don’t call guys undone by injuries busts. To me a bust is a player that shows that from a skill standpoint he doesn’t measure up.  I think Hooker measures up skill-wise, but he has been undone by injuries.  It’s a shame because he could’ve been really good.  :(


If you draft a Safety in the middle of the 1st Rd, I’d expect that Safety to be a top 5 safety.

 

Hooker is not or was not a top 10 Safety.

 

Translation, he’s a bust IMO.

  • Like 4
Link to post
Share on other sites
41 minutes ago, w87r said:

Well of course...

 

 Not sure what that is referring to though?

 

Rocky said he doesn't consider players bust who get injured, he considers them bust if their talent don't stack up to high expectations.

 

He was referring to Hooker(top 15 pick)

I listed counter Oden(#1 pick, albeit basketball) to get his thoughts in that situation.

 

There is no expectations from undrafted guys or any mention about them.?

I missed read I thought you said Odum.

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, MPStack said:


If you draft a Safety in the middle of the 1st Rd, I’d expect that Safety to be a top 5 safety.

 

Hooker is not or was not a top 10 Safety.

 

Translation, he’s a bust IMO.

You ignore the point of my post, that being that he was undone by injuries.  As a rookie he was balling, but then suffered that devastating injury.   His 2nd year was a year of just trying to get back to peak health.   His 3rd year, yes a little bit of a disappointment, though he kept getting nicked up, so again, his progress was set back by little nagging injuries.  This year, finished by injury. 
 

If your definition of “busy” includes for injuries, then go ahead a stand by your assertion, for that’s your prerogative.  For me, though, and many others, “bust” cannot he used on players undone by injuries.  I consider it indisputable that Hooker’s issues aren’t purely due to injuries.  I have no doubt in my mind that, had he not been injured so many times, he would have lived up to the near universal billing of his talent level. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

You ignore the point of my post, that being that he was undone by injuries.  As a rookie he was balling, but then suffered that devastating injury.   His 2nd year was a year of just trying to get back to peak health.   His 3rd year, yes a little bit of a disappointment, though he kept getting nicked up, so again, his progress was set back by little nagging injuries.  This year, finished by injury. 
 

If your definition of “busy” includes for injuries, then go ahead a stand by your assertion, for that’s your prerogative.  For me, though, and many others, “bust” cannot he used on players undone by injuries.  I consider it indisputable that Hooker’s issues aren’t purely due to injuries.  I have no doubt in my mind that, had he not been injured so many times, he would have lived up to the near universal billing of his talent level. 

Trying to recall, wasn’t one of the reasons he dropped in the first round to the Colts because he was nursing an injury? 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, w87r said:

The amount of injuries league wide is very troubling. 

Big names dropping.

 

3 potential season injuries for the Colts already is very worrisome. Not small names either, prominent role players. Not even to mention Doyle and Burton.

 

Lack of live reps amd preparations have to be playing major role I would think.


I think the same happened the last time there was no preseason. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

You ignore the point of my post, that being that he was undone by injuries.  As a rookie he was balling, but then suffered that devastating injury.   His 2nd year was a year of just trying to get back to peak health.   His 3rd year, yes a little bit of a disappointment, though he kept getting nicked up, so again, his progress was set back by little nagging injuries.  This year, finished by injury. 
 

If your definition of “busy” includes for injuries, then go ahead a stand by your assertion, for that’s your prerogative.  For me, though, and many others, “bust” cannot he used on players undone by injuries.  I consider it indisputable that Hooker’s issues aren’t purely due to injuries.  I have no doubt in my mind that, had he not been injured so many times, he would have lived up to the near universal billing of his talent level. 

A "bust" and an "injury bust" are two different things for players. They are not mutually exclusive. Lots of players who are "injury busts" weren't bad players, they were just undone by injuries that destroyed their careers. That is different than a "bust" who is out of the league because of a lack of talent. Again, they are not mutually exclusive and both widely accepted terms.

Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, Jared Cisneros said:

A "bust" and an "injury bust" are two different things for players. They are not mutually exclusive. Lots of players who are "injury busts" weren't bad players, they were just undone by injuries that destroyed their careers. That is different than a "bust" who is out of the league because of a lack of talent. Again, they are not mutually exclusive and both widely accepted terms.

Fair point. For me, though, when I hear a player being called a bust, I equate it to the name caller implying he’s a crap player, talent-wise.  

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
57 minutes ago, csmopar said:

Trying to recall, wasn’t one of the reasons he dropped in the first round to the Colts because he was nursing an injury? 

I cannot say for sure, but I have no recollection of his unexpected drop to us on draft day being because of a sudden injury concern.  I do recall pundit consensus being that the Colts got s steal in having Hooker fall to them.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, w87r said:

The amount of injuries league wide is very troubling. 

Big names dropping.

 

3 potential season injuries for the Colts already is very worrisome. Not small names either, prominent role players. Not even to mention Doyle and Burton.

 

Lack of live reps amd preparations have to be playing major role I would think.

Yes, as someone else said I think this happened the last time there was no pre-season either.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, rockywoj said:

Fair point. For me, though, when I hear a player being called a bust, I equate it to the name caller implying he’s a crap player, talent-wise.  


Sorry, I had know idea there were categories of a bust. That’s a new one to me and probably others.

 

Talent-wise, Hooker has not delivered where he was drafted. A rookie 3rd Rd pick (Blackmon) shined today in his placed.


Ballard did not pickup his 5th year option.  

 

There were rumors he was being shopped before the draft. 
 

For where he was drafted, I‘d call Hooker a bust.  
 

Sorry

 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Jared Cisneros said:

Well... If we weren't re-signing him before, we definitely aren't now. The 2017 class in their final year are dropping like flies. Luckily we have Blackmon and Taylor.

Actually most dropped before final year.

Link to post
Share on other sites
50 minutes ago, MPStack said:


Sorry, I had know idea there were categories of a bust. That’s a new one to me and probably others.

 

Talent-wise, Hooker has not delivered where he was drafted. A rookie 3rd Rd pick (Blackmon) shined today in his placed.


Ballard did not pickup his 5th year option.  

 

There were rumors he was being shopped before the draft. 
 

For where he was drafted, I‘d call Hooker a bust.  
 

Sorry

Not sure I'd call him a bust. More than anything, and injuries aside, I'd call him a bad fit for our scheme.

 

He was a single high C1 lurker in college. Going two high C2, or three high Tampa 2 turned him to a half field or third field hand off manager.

 

If you look at it that way, we kind of wasted a 1st round talent trying to fit him into a C2/T2 zone D. That assumes he would have been a good C1 single high FS of course. He was definitely good at OSU in that role though.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I hate to see anyone get injured and unfortunately that's part of the NFL.  M.Hooker, is a class act, never heard anything negative about him off the field. I know he's not going to get resigned by the Colts by end of the season, so good luck to Hooker on his NFL career.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Thunderbolt said:

I hate to see anyone get injured and unfortunately that's part of the NFL.  M.Hooker, is a class act, never heard anything negative about him off the field. I know he's not going to get resigned by the Colts by end of the season, so good luck to Hooker on his NFL career.

If he doesn't come back, hope he goes to a team that plays a decent amount of C1. I'd love to see what happens.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Just what makes you think Jerry Jones is interested in Brissett?  Fitz or Taylor seem more like it IMO.
    • Minshew completing 19 of his 20 passes was a   huge part of it.   I'd say 45% Reich play-calling would be 25% responsible for the loss.    Rivers INT's were 20% responsible for the loss. 10% would be others (missed field goal, Hilton drops ect.).
    • I hate to see any player get hurt in the NFL.  But I figured if a team got desperate at QB, it would be the perfect time to dump Jacoby Brissett for a draft pick.  The Cowboys are in trouble likely and it would be a perfect time to move Brissett.  He is gone at the end of the year anyways so might as well get something out of him, since they likely won't get a comp pick if he signs somewhere else since we will sign free agents ourselves.  
    • but he is on another team, didn’t get developed here. Anderson and Jerry Hughes would be other examples of guys who developed away from us.  yeah I get it, I’m very stubborn once irritated and just what the league did at the beginning of the season has really frustrated me. They went with the wind of what voice screamed loudest and alienated many of the supporters who actually spent money on the games. Won’t be me anymore for along time most likely. Heck, Sears ticked me off once, never went back. That was 18 years ago lol.  just reading, it sounds like a lot of those pressures from AQM and Autry cane in the first few games and them died off? Could be they are or have just been used more than their bodies are capable of performing at that same high level? I suppose Houston is suffering from the same individual stat lines as Buckner has. Gets good push and pressure but isn’t getting home to make the big impact play. That is what I’ve heard on the Kevin Bowen podcast for Buckner. While he is doing what others hadn’t been able to do and he is opening up opportunities for others, he hasn’t hit the sack totals and individual stat lines that all pro players will get. Are we getting those seal plays from the edges from our Lb’ers or DE’s that we were getting with Sheard or are these QB’s and Rb’s slipping out?  agree. Didn’t we get lots more pressure from Leonard last season? I think the defense planned on Turay and Lewis being involved in this defense. Along with the addition of Buckner, having Turay and Lewis at rush end could have been the game plan but injuries and whatever is going on with Lewis so far happens. I see that Lewis is getting more reps and more praise so hopefully that’s not just coaching motivation and he is actually flashing on the field now. Would be nice to get production from him. 
    • you are making the assumption that they would not score there, so who are you to say im the one assuming the wrong thing?  you said it didnt change the game when both picks could have been points for us instead   we had more than double their yardage. the defense bent but didnt let them do much at all after the catch, and their completions were mostly short 
  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...