Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Chris Simms top 40 QB list


Recommended Posts

11 minutes ago, w87r said:

I agree with all that.

 

I think you might of posted top 10 in here. I know there was a couple. Where do you have Wentz?

 

Below is my list. I had Wentz at 17. He's had a great surrounding cast (OL and pass catchers), so could have easily put him around 20ish too. 

 

 

Quote

 

Based partly on stats/science, partly on surrounding cast, and a little bit of art, my rank is

 

1. Mahomes

2. Brees

3. Wilson

4. Jackson

5. Stafford

6. Prescott

7. Carr

8. Watson

9. Cousins

10. Tannehill

11. Ryan

12. Rodgers

13. Big Ben

14. Brady

15. Rivers

16. Garoppolo

17. Wentz

18. Lock

19. Minshew

20. Murray

21. Fitzpatric

22. Goff

23. Jones

24. Winston

25. Mayfield

26. Bridgewater

27. Allen

28. Darnold

29. Dalton

30. Foles

31. Trubisky

 

Not going to give the rooks or some of the still pending FAs an official slot, but here's my range for some of those guys.

 

Burrow 16-20

Tua 26-30

Herbert - 30ish

Stidham - 21-25 (based on BB gameplan)

Hoyer - 21-25 (based on BB gameplan)

Haskins/Montez - 31-35

Newton - 26-30

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 177
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Both Brees and Carr were top 10 in just about every meaningful stat last year. Brees had a great surrounding cast, but still tore it up. Carr did not have a great surrounding cast but still did very v

I will start with I was never a JB fan and even after the 5-2 start I was waiting for the wheels to fall off.  However, besides Tua I would take JB over anyone on that list so far. JB is a model pro a

Right?    A case for him between 20-25 could be made, but 10th? Yeah, no... 

Posted Images

18 minutes ago, EastStreet said:

Below is my list. I had Wentz at 17. He's had a great surrounding cast (OL and pass catchers), so could have easily put him around 20ish too

Right on, seems you're right there with me thinking he shouldn't be in top 10.

 

Hell top 7 at this point. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, w87r said:

Right on, seems you're right there with me thinking he shouldn't be in top 10.

 

Hell top 7 at this point. 

 

When I did the exercise, I put together stats for all the QBs.

Looking at all the factors, he was good in some areas, and very very average in others. All while having the best OL in the league, and good to great group of pass catchers. No way top 7. If you can't be top 10 in any stats while having that supporting cast, you don't deserve it.

 

17. Wentz 94
QBR - 11th
Passer Rating - 13th
Comp% - 17th
YPG - 15th
ANY/A - 16th
TD% - 17th
INT% - 5th
2019 OL Rank - 1st
2019 WR/TE Rank - 1st
2020 WR/TE Rank - 14th
 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

40. Tua Tagovailoa

39. Dwayne Haskins

38. Mitchell Trubisky

37. Justin Herbert

36. Taysom Hill

35. Jarred Stidham

34. Tyrod Taylor

33. Jameis Winston

32. Case Keenum

31. Nick Foles

30. Gardner Minshew II

29. Teddy Bridgewater

28. Ryan Fitzpatrick

27. Andy Dalton

26. Joe Burrow

25. Drew Lock

24. Jared Goff

23. Sam Darnold

22. Daniel Jones

21. Baker Mayfield

20. Jimmy Garoppolo

19. Derek Carr

18. Josh Allen

17. Philip Rivers

16. Drew Brees

15. Tom Brady

14. Ben Roethlisberger

13. Kirk Cousins

12. Kyler Murray

11. Ryan Tannehill

10. Cam Newton

9. Matthew Stafford

8. Dax Prescott

7. Matt Ryan

6. Carson Wentz

Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, w87r said:

Been off the rails. lmao

 

 

Where would you rank Wentz, as be hasn't been listed yet 

 

I think in the 10-15 range. Hasn't shown same game as his MVP worthy season he got hurt, IMO.

 

Tough to be looking at this list and make a rational thought.

 

 

Yeah. Probably 10-15 for Wentz. Rodgers should be in there as well but looks like he will be top 10.

 

Simms top 10 is going to be insane. I am not sure why anyone values this guys opinion.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, FortheWin said:

Yeah. Probably 10-15 for Wentz. Rodgers should be in there as well but looks like he will be top 10.

 

Simms top 10 is going to be insane. I am not sure why anyone values this guys opinion.

I don't think too many people value his opinion. At least not on this board.

 

List has been bad from the start.

Link to post
Share on other sites

40. Tua Tagovailoa

39. Dwayne Haskins

38. Mitchell Trubisky

37. Justin Herbert

36. Taysom Hill

35. Jarred Stidham

34. Tyrod Taylor

33. Jameis Winston

32. Case Keenum

31. Nick Foles

30. Gardner Minshew II

29. Teddy Bridgewater

28. Ryan Fitzpatrick

27. Andy Dalton

26. Joe Burrow

25. Drew Lock

24. Jared Goff

23. Sam Darnold

22. Daniel Jones

21. Baker Mayfield

20. Jimmy Garoppolo

19. Derek Carr

18. Josh Allen

17. Philip Rivers

16. Drew Brees

15. Tom Brady

14. Ben Roethlisberger

13. Kirk Cousins

12. Kyler Murray

11. Ryan Tannehill

10. Cam Newton

9. Matthew Stafford

8. Dax Prescott

7. Matt Ryan

6. Carson Wentz

5. Lamar Jackson

4. Deshaun Watson

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, RollerColt said:

Just saw the completed list. There’s going to be a lot of Lamar Jackson fans calling him out. 

Go ahead and post the rest of list if you've seen it.

 

I just post them when I see them posted on pft website

Link to post
Share on other sites

40. Tua Tagovailoa

39. Dwayne Haskins

38. Mitchell Trubisky

37. Justin Herbert

36. Taysom Hill

35. Jarred Stidham

34. Tyrod Taylor

33. Jameis Winston

32. Case Keenum

31. Nick Foles

30. Gardner Minshew II

29. Teddy Bridgewater

28. Ryan Fitzpatrick

27. Andy Dalton

26. Joe Burrow

25. Drew Lock

24. Jared Goff

23. Sam Darnold

22. Daniel Jones

21. Baker Mayfield

20. Jimmy Garoppolo

19. Derek Carr

18. Josh Allen

17. Philip Rivers

16. Drew Brees

15. Tom Brady

14. Ben Roethlisberger

13. Kirk Cousins

12. Kyler Murray

11. Ryan Tannehill

10. Cam Newton

9. Matthew Stafford

8. Dax Prescott

7. Matt Ryan

6. Carson Wentz

5. Lamar Jackson

4. Deshaun Watson

3. Aaron Rodgers

2. Russell Wilson*

1. Pat Mahomes*

 

*Haven't seen 1 and 2 yet, but with Rodgers 3, there is no way Wilson's in front of Mahomes, right? 

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, w87r said:

40. Tua Tagovailoa

39. Dwayne Haskins

38. Mitchell Trubisky

37. Justin Herbert

36. Taysom Hill

35. Jarred Stidham

34. Tyrod Taylor

33. Jameis Winston

32. Case Keenum

31. Nick Foles

30. Gardner Minshew II

29. Teddy Bridgewater

28. Ryan Fitzpatrick

27. Andy Dalton

26. Joe Burrow

25. Drew Lock

24. Jared Goff

23. Sam Darnold

22. Daniel Jones

21. Baker Mayfield

20. Jimmy Garoppolo

19. Derek Carr

18. Josh Allen

17. Philip Rivers

16. Drew Brees

15. Tom Brady

14. Ben Roethlisberger

13. Kirk Cousins

12. Kyler Murray

11. Ryan Tannehill

10. Cam Newton

9. Matthew Stafford

8. Dax Prescott

7. Matt Ryan

6. Carson Wentz

5. Lamar Jackson

4. Deshaun Watson

3. Aaron Rodgers

2. Russell Wilson*

1. Pat Mahomes*

 

*Haven't seen 1 and 2 yet, but with Rodgers 3, there is no way Wilson's in front of Mahomes, right? 

 

Yep. That’s the full list in all its “glory”. Thanks for keeping up with it. Sure as heck don’t agree, but it’s been fun to laugh at Simms. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
40 minutes ago, w87r said:

40. Tua Tagovailoa

39. Dwayne Haskins

38. Mitchell Trubisky

37. Justin Herbert

36. Taysom Hill

35. Jarred Stidham

34. Tyrod Taylor

33. Jameis Winston

32. Case Keenum

31. Nick Foles

30. Gardner Minshew II

29. Teddy Bridgewater

28. Ryan Fitzpatrick

27. Andy Dalton

26. Joe Burrow

25. Drew Lock

24. Jared Goff

23. Sam Darnold

22. Daniel Jones

21. Baker Mayfield

20. Jimmy Garoppolo

19. Derek Carr

18. Josh Allen

17. Philip Rivers

16. Drew Brees

15. Tom Brady

14. Ben Roethlisberger

13. Kirk Cousins

12. Kyler Murray

11. Ryan Tannehill

10. Cam Newton

9. Matthew Stafford

8. Dax Prescott

7. Matt Ryan

6. Carson Wentz

5. Lamar Jackson

4. Deshaun Watson

3. Aaron Rodgers

2. Russell Wilson*

1. Pat Mahomes*

 

*Haven't seen 1 and 2 yet, but with Rodgers 3, there is no way Wilson's in front of Mahomes, right? 

 

With his list you never know :funny:

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

He does have Rodgers at 3, I agree with him on that. Jackson should be 2, Wilson 4, JMO.

Same. I know there are knocks against Lamar, but he was the MVP. Definitely should have been 2, and Watson should be 5.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...