Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Rank the QBs in AFC


danlhart87

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, Myles said:

I would.   

Fair enough, but the stats don't back that up. Traditional or otherwise. 

https://www.footballperspective.com/final-2019-passing-stats-mahomes-and-tannehill-lead-the-way/

 

I get that he can just as easily fail next year and Rivers done it for a longer period and all that. But based on last year and how well Tannehill fit in  that TEN system, he is the better performing qb. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, rayski said:

Fair enough, but the stats don't back that up. Traditional or otherwise. 

https://www.footballperspective.com/final-2019-passing-stats-mahomes-and-tannehill-lead-the-way/

 

I get that he can just as easily fail next year and Rivers done it for a longer period and all that. But based on last year and how well Tannehill fit in  that TEN system, he is the better performing qb. 

We shall see, (maybe...)

 

I'm giving Rivers the benefit of doubt. He will have much better protection and now has some decent weapons to utilize. Tannehill was excellent last year, no doubt. It's why I have him just below Rivers. I want to see him do it again this year to show some consistency. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, RollerColt said:

We shall see, (maybe...)

 

I'm giving Rivers the benefit of doubt. He will have much better protection and now has some decent weapons to utilize. Tannehill was excellent last year, no doubt. It's why I have him just below Rivers. I want to see him do it again this year to show some consistency. 

That is why I put Rivers above him.   Add to that the great O-line the Colts have and I wouldn't put Rivers below second in the AFC South.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This is it, and that's how I saw Ballard's pushback -- he's always going to be small. So what do you do with that? Whether they were talking about Worthy or someone else, I don't think Ballard's point was that he needs to put on 10-12 pounds and he won't be able to. I think the point was you can't count on that, so judge his body as it is now.   As for Worthy, he's not much smaller than Josh Downs. At a certain point, small is small. If you draft a guy like that, you need to be comfortable with his size, not betting that he's going to get bigger.
    • Dobbs doesn't strike me as being team president/GM material, and the fact that there has been little movement, little evolution in Ballard's approach in 8 years, tells me Dobbs is more of a yes man, a rubber stamp man.  Other teams can see that.  If Dobbs, or anyone, were actually challenging Ballard from time to time, you might see a change in approach occasionally.
    • If I can find it, I’ll post it. But I think with most teams, they don’t have a plan for TEs. They just draft them just because. Steichen is a guy that seems to have a plan for the players that are drafted. And we’ve seen in Ballard’s recent presser that getting guys the staff can create a plan for is important to them.   This past season we drafted Downs who was different from the receivers that Ballard typically drafts. He had a lot of success because of his own ability, but Shane also schemed up ways to get him favorable match ups. I think Bowers is the type of guy that would flourish with Shane scheming him up. He’s a mismatch against LBs and safeties.
    • Well it’s expensive to move up into the top five.  He said in his presser moving up for Harrison is a “fantasy “.  I would guess he’s referring to pick 4 or there about.   That’s expensive.  I don’t consider he meant that high when he mentioned striking distance.  For me striking distance starts at pick 9.   Probably costing our 2nd round pick as well.  Let’s face it the only 2nd rd picks where Ballard acquired a great player with were Leonard and Taylor.  Leonard in the 30’s and Taylor pick 41.  We would be giving up 46 with a chance to get elite.  Pick 46 would probably get good not even great if he used it.  I’m hoping he tries for greatness this time and stays or moves up.  Please don’t trade back.  That’s all I ask.
  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...