So If Peyton Manning Wins Multiple Super Bowl Titles With The Broncos...

[Tsarquise 443]

Will he be remembered as the GOAT as a Colt or a Bronco?

[Dustin 89]

Both.

[Flux 0]

If he wins multiple superbowls in the next few years he will be remembered as THE G.O.A.T....period. As far as being remembered as either a Colt or a Bronco...to us he will obviously always be a Colt.

[Gavin 5]

wont happen and in truth he isnt the Greatest Of All Time, stats back that up and SuperBowl victories? Tom Brady has more, is he the greatest of all time? likely not, Favre has multiple superbowls and all time records while he has thrown his share of picks (number one in that category as well) he is still the best, stats back that up, teams win superbowls, players earn records, stats and so forth

[supremecoltsfan300 0]

Both. He'll always be a colt, but SBs will have an imporant part on 18s legacy that if he wins another sb he will also be remembered as a bronco.

[Vance 6]

How can he be a goat, when he's a horse...?!

[Flux 0]

wont happen and in truth he isnt the Greatest Of All Time, stats back that up and SuperBowl victories? Tom Brady has more, is he the greatest of all time? likely not, Favre has multiple superbowls and all time records while he has thrown his share of picks (number one in that category as well) he is still the best, stats back that up, teams win superbowls, players earn records, stats and so forth

So let me get this straight...you're saying that the ALL-TIME leader in Interceptions thrown and fumbles lost ( in other words, the all-time leader in turnovers) is the greatest QB of all time??

[Gavin 5]

ever heard of a Liger? a cross between a lion and a Tiger?

[JWF 0]

ever heard of a Liger? a cross between a lion and a Tiger?

Broncolt?

[Gavin 5]

Yes I am go look at all the other POSITIVE records he owns all the main ones for a quarterback, are you saying Peyton is the greatest? cause superbowl victories alone would shut that argument down

[Nobody 9]

wont happen and in truth he isnt the Greatest Of All Time, stats back that up and SuperBowl victories? Tom Brady has more, is he the greatest of all time? likely not, Favre has multiple superbowls and all time records while he has thrown his share of picks (number one in that category as well) he is still the best, stats back that up, teams win superbowls, players earn records, stats and so forth

Wow. I have read too many of your *ic posts. You are no colts fan. Favre won 1 Super Bowl, 0 SB MVPs, turnover machine, and had a much better team throughout his career. No. Peyton will hopefully prove to everyone what he can do with a better team, even of not fully healthy.

[Gavin 5]

Correct I forgot he was in two won one I stand corrected but still stats back it up hes not the greatest and I assure you I am a colts fan just cause I dont remember everything doesnt mean Im not a colts fan

[Jaric 44]

Brett Farve is not the greatest quarterback of all time. That's not even really up for discussion.

[Gavin 5]

Who is then? no one can say Peyton at this point

[Gavin 5]

But the best thing to do in all honesty is to not get into these type of discussions and just enjoy the game for what it is arguments can be made in many different direction, I choose the one with the most touchdows and yards

[wercolts 0]

Manning is the greatest of all time now.

[jskinnz 1,811]

wont happen and in truth he isnt the Greatest Of All Time, stats back that up and SuperBowl victories? Tom Brady has more, is he the greatest of all time? likely not, Favre has multiple superbowls and all time records while he has thrown his share of picks (number one in that category as well) he is still the best, stats back that up, teams win superbowls, players earn records, stats and so forth

This answer, among many others, make this thread in particular and the topic in general, categorically, mind-numbingly ridiculous. First off, your stats are just simply wrong.

But more importantly, someone can make a very reasoned, rational argument that Manning is the greatest QB of all time right now regardless of the outcome of his final years. Just like someone can make the argument for:

Brady or

Montana or

Unitas or

Marino or

Bradshaw or

Baugh or

Graham or

Favre

It is a pointless debate with no ability to truly determine the "winner."

[WeSpy 11]

ever heard of a Liger? a cross between a lion and a Tiger?

There are Tigons as well.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiglon

[Gavin 5]

Yes seen a Tigon before

[Gavin 5]

Manning is the greatest of all time now.

based on what?

[SyX 0]

wont happen and in truth he isnt the Greatest Of All Time, stats back that up and SuperBowl victories? Tom Brady has more, is he the greatest of all time? likely not, Favre has multiple superbowls and all time records while he has thrown his share of picks (number one in that category as well) he is still the best, stats back that up, teams win superbowls, players earn records, stats and so forth

Okay, Favre played 20 seasons. Manning has played 13. Favre has roughly 17,000 more passing yards. Manning would need to average 2500 yards per season to pass that if he were to play the same number of years. Favre has 109 more TDs, so if Manning were to average 16 more over 7 seasons, he'd pass Favre. Looking at numbers blindly isn't the best way of going about this. As for the G.O.A.T. argument, it really holds no water for me. This is a far different era than when Marino and Montana played, and that was a far different era than when Unitas played.

We've been fortunate to watch a truly great player in Manning, and I wish him continued luck in Denver.

[The Peytonator 455]

wont happen and in truth he isnt the Greatest Of All Time, stats back that up and SuperBowl victories? Tom Brady has more, is he the greatest of all time? likely not, Favre has multiple superbowls and all time records while he has thrown his share of picks (number one in that category as well) he is still the best, stats back that up, teams win superbowls, players earn records, stats and so forth

If you think Brett 'He's just a kid out there' Favre is the GOAT, then you need your Colts fan card taken away.

I get the Brady V Manning debate. At least Brady is respectable. I have zero respect for Favre, the man and the quarterback.

[Gavin 5]

agreed, and I am not saying he wont reach them records if he stays healthy and plays that long which I doubt then he could very well get them, I just enjoy the game for what it is, I usually dont get into those arguments lol

[Gavin 5]

what does Favres stats have to do with me rooting for the colts? as for the no respect of favre, why? cause he didnt want to shut it down? he isnt the first and wont be the last

[Jaric 44]

Who is then?

Not Brett Farve.

[Gavin 5]

Not Peyton

[Jaric 44]

Not Peyton

I never said it was Peyton.

[BleedingBlue 0]

Do you remember Montana as a Chief? Theres your answer.

[BleedingBlue 0]

PS.. peyton always said, "win your division and your two games away from a superbowl"

going to the AFC west was brilliant. He can beat the pats now and be in the superbowl in 1 or 2 years

[ReMeDy 423]

ever heard of a Liger? a cross between a lion and a Tiger?

Yea, I watched Napoleon Dynamite.

[Coffeedrinker 3,537]

Yes I am go look at all the other POSITIVE records he owns all the main ones for a quarterback, are you saying Peyton is the greatest? cause superbowl victories alone would shut that argument down

He has as many superbowl wins as Farve.

[jskinnz 1,811]

Not Peyton

Since you seem to be the expert on this, let me ask you some questions. What is the standard to determine the greatest player of all time? How do you arrive at giving someone that title? Most yards? Most wins? Most Super Bowls?

[Malakai432 1,009]

How can he be a goat, when he's a horse...?!

Perhaps it's The Twilight Zone!

[Fx Stryker 10]

Do you remember Montana as a Chief? Theres your answer.

Not the same. History remembers Super Bowls. Peyton wins a Super Bowl with the Bronco he is equally a Bronco as he is a Colt.

[BleedingBlue 0]

Not the same. History remembers Super Bowls. Peyton wins a Super Bowl with the Bronco he is equally a Bronco as he is a Colt.

I think even if Peyton wins a SB as a Bronco, he will still be remembered as a Colt. I give you that him holding a Lombardi in Orange will be added to the memory bank.

[CR91 6,350]

wont happen

[HarassedOffTheSite 17]

LOL to read people posting that Brett Favre is the GOAT...when Green Bay fans don't even think so is kind of surreal.

Having Brett Favre and Peyton Manning stand next to each other when you're picking players makes it an easy choice:

GOAT = Peyton.

[CCH 0]

Peyton will go into out ring of honor, he'll retire a Colt, and go into the Hall of Fame as a Colt.

[JoKeR 37]

At one time many people considered Dan Marino the best QB of all time and he only went to a Superbowl, many of those people consider Peyton the best. My point is SBs are not a prerequisite, skill and ability are.

[Fx Stryker 10]

Peyton will go into out ring of honor, he'll retire a Colt, and go into the Hall of Fame as a Colt.

NFL does all teams. Baseball you decide what team you go under.