Tyrod wasn't brought in to start until Herbert gets ready, he was already there. He is a place holder for Herbert, but not all situations are the same. This comparison is way off in almost every aspect.
I fully understand the situation in NO.
The fact Hill can be listed/play as another position, has no effect on JW. It's actually the opposite. They will have 3 qbs with one able to be a gadget guy.
Taysom Hill has 13 career pass attempts. To add to that he is 3 yrs older than JW as well. Pretty sure if Brees goes down, they will be having JW as the QB. Now if both get injured in a game, they have a 3rd emergency QB in Hill.
Sorry PT, just think you're wrong on both accounts here.
If Pascal is not 4th, then the Colts have a problem. That means Hilton is hurt, or Campbell is hurt or Pittman is slow to develop. If all three are healthy and developing as advertised, Pascal is 4th.
The only way Pascal is ever any higher is if something has gone wrong.
He's not going to be higher based on ability and beating out one of the top three. He only gets higher if opportunity shows up. Not based on his ability. Sorry.
Does that mean he isn't a top 40 QB? The fact he backs up a top 5 QB. I think he will dress every game though, tbh.
Ty Detmer wishes he had 1/2 the career Tyrod has had. Tyrod has a winning record and +34 td/int ratio. Only thing similar about those guys is their names start with Ty and end in R. Not even sure where you are going with that comparison, tbh.
I couldn't care less about either of these guys.
Just posted the list, because I was tired of seeing the whole thread be about a guy not even on the list. With only mention of 2 guys actually on it.(Tua/Haskins).