Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

In good hands to find our next QB?


CR91

Recommended Posts

Dodds was with the Seahawks when they drafted Russell Wilson

 

Ballard was with the chiefs when they drafted Patrick Mahomes

 

Reich was with the eagles when they drafted Carson Wentz

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 105
  • Created
  • Last Reply
29 minutes ago, CR91 said:

Dodds was with the Seahawks when they drafted Russell Wilson

 

Ballard was with the chiefs when they drafted Patrick Mahomes

 

Reich was with the eagles when they drafted Carson Wentz

 

Excellent points.

Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, CR91 said:

Dodds was with the Seahawks when they drafted Russell Wilson

 

Ballard was with the chiefs when they drafted Patrick Mahomes

 

Reich was with the eagles when they drafted Carson Wentz

 

And I was a Colt fan when we drafted both Peyton and Andrew.:rock:

Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, hoosierhawk said:

And I was a Colt fan when we drafted both Peyton and Andrew.:rock:

 

Excellent. So who is the next great QB for the colts

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, danlhart87 said:

Trevor Lawrence.

 

We're not that bad. We'd have to legit tank.

Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, CR91 said:

 

We're not that bad. We'd have to legit tank.

Ballard and Reich would never intentionally tank a whole season, but it could get ugly if we lose a QB to injury 

 

ive said im not a big jacoby fan but i think he would get us 6-8 wins again.  if we stick with him and he gets hurt,  we would probably be picking high 

Link to post
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, aaron11 said:

Ballard and Reich would never intentionally tank a whole season, but it could get ugly if we lose a QB to injury 

 

ive said im not a big jacoby fan but i think he would get us 6-8 wins again.  if we stick with him and he gets hurt,  we would probably be picking high 

Not high enough to draft Lawrence.

He seems like a sure-fire lock for #1, and no one is going to trade the rights to the next Elway, or Luck, or whomever they're comparing him to

Link to post
Share on other sites

Bold prediction 

 

TB finishes with the #1 pick and Colts finish #2. After months of Lawrence to TB speculation the Bucs surprise everyone and take Justin Fields leaving Lawrence to fall to the Colts.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, danlhart87 said:

Don't speak too soon

 

I really don't feel like I am. This is a decent Colts team. There are many people who look at this team like we were 2-14 last year. We finished 7-9 and were just a couple of field goals away from 9-7. This is a team that with the one or two additions is on the cusp of challenging in the AFC. Maybe I'm the eternal optimist, but I would be completely shocked if we were anywhere close to drafting T.L. next year. If by some chance we are feel free to bring this back up and I will eat my slice of humble pie, but until then I will be an optimist.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't want to waste another year. We need to move up and draft a QB..Any day 1 QB. With Jacoby at the helm, we'll be hovering around the .500 mark again. Will be in the same position again next year. We've watched Jacoby for almost 2 full seasons. I just don't see any improvement.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Hammer said:

I don't want to waste another year. We need to move up and draft a QB..Any day 1 QB. With Jacoby at the helm, we'll be hovering around the .500 mark again. Will be in the same position again next year. We've watched Jacoby for almost 2 full seasons. I just don't see any improvement.


Agree.  We probably won’t move up though, and the top 4 QBs will be gone before we pick.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Hammer said:

I don't want to waste another year. We need to move up and draft a QB..Any day 1 QB. With Jacoby at the helm, we'll be hovering around the .500 mark again. Will be in the same position again next year. We've watched Jacoby for almost 2 full seasons. I just don't see any improvement.

I suspect whichever QB gets drafted, he's going to sit behind Jacoby for a year.

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, danlhart87 said:

Bold prediction 

 

TB finishes with the #1 pick and Colts finish #2. After months of Lawrence to TB speculation the Bucs surprise everyone and take Justin Fields leaving Lawrence to fall to the Colts.

Pipe dream

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Smonroe said:


Agree.  We probably won’t move up though, and the top 4 QBs will be gone before we pick.  

 

Agreed, But the case to be made here is. If 4 QBs go in the top 12 picks then there is going to be some REALLY good players on the board for the Colts to choose from. Could even trade back later into 1st round at that point and still potentially get a stud and pick up another 2nd or so.

 

Alot of opportunity with where they are.

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Hammer said:

I don't want to waste another year. We need to move up and draft a QB..Any day 1 QB. With Jacoby at the helm, we'll be hovering around the .500 mark again. Will be in the same position again next year. We've watched Jacoby for almost 2 full seasons. I just don't see any improvement.

Who says we will waste another year with Jacoby if a rookie sits behind him a year. We weren’t that far off last year. It’s not like we got blown out all year. With just a few plays here and there and better kicker with Jacoby and Hilton not getting injured we would of made the playoffs.

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Colt.45 said:

I suspect whichever QB gets drafted, he's going to sit behind Jacoby for a year.

 

  I think you may be right but it will still be wasting a year because whoever we might draft next year will sit behind Jacoby. Let's get it over with.

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, Chloe6124 said:

Who says we will waste another year with Jacoby if a rookie sits behind him a year. We weren’t that far off last year. It’s not like we got blown out all year. With just a few plays here and there and better kicker with Jacoby and Hilton not getting injured we would of made the playoffs.

 

 "Who says?"...I believe I just did.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Hammer said:

 

  I think you may be right but it will still be wasting a year because whoever we might draft next year will sit behind Jacoby. Let's get it over with.

Jacoby has one left on that 2 year deal. He started the year great. It wasn’t until after he was injured and couldn’t really step into his throws. The film doesn’t lie. The pass was hampered by injuries. It will improve with more outside threats besides TY. I’m with you wanting a QB as well. He’ll just be sitting unfortunately. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Hammer said:

I don't want to waste another year. We need to move up and draft a QB..Any day 1 QB. With Jacoby at the helm, we'll be hovering around the .500 mark again. Will be in the same position again next year. We've watched Jacoby for almost 2 full seasons. I just don't see any improvement.

I don't want to waste another year either.  The quickest way not to is find a way to get a veteran like Carr or sign Bridgewater and trade JB.  You can then continue to build your roster as we were planning to do with Luck.  If we draft a rookie with pick 13 or earlier my preference would be to start him right away and trade JB.  Eliminate the boos and the drama and get everyone behind the new QB.  Still a lost season with a rookie though.  

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ballard brought in JB..Where's that rank on this list? 

 

I can see a scenario where the Colts are pretty bad next year though- how bad depends on a few things, including injuries, schedule, AFCS teams performance ect. When I listen/read about what this team needs, it's not a small list- it's half of the offense for starters, and if it's QB, WR, LT, TE1/2 it's not all getting dealt with this year. The D was pretty lackluster by the end of the season and it was largely healthy and I think that unit is going to be basically what we see this next year.

So, say Ballard decides JB keeps the job because he's not into Rivers, Newton ect we draft a guy like Love, but he's not ready, JB get's hurt early, Love either sucks, or doesn't play.. Oh there's a way this team could be a 4/5 win outfit. Will that happen. Who knows? I hope not, but I'm not going to pretend this team isn't in choppy waters right now.

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, lincolndefan said:

 

Would be a great mistake! IMO

History disagrees with you.  Most of the greats sat for a year or 2 behind another QB.  Brady behind Blesdoe, Rodgers behind Favre, Mahomes behind Smith, etc.

 

When you throw a rookie right into the fire on week 1 day one that's a tough emotional hurdle to clear.  More than 1 promising QB has been destroyed that way.  Some do fine of course, but enough don't that you have to consider whether it's worth the risk, especially when the risk is almost completely unnecessary, all you have to do to avoid being forced into that risk is NOT get rid of your incumbent starter

Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Hammer said:

I don't want to waste another year. We need to move up and draft a QB..Any day 1 QB. With Jacoby at the helm, we'll be hovering around the .500 mark again. Will be in the same position again next year. We've watched Jacoby for almost 2 full seasons. I just don't see any improvement.

2017:  3-13

2019: 7-9

 

Nope, no improvement at all.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no doubt if we upgrade weapons and they stay mostly healthy Jacoby will improve. I just don’t know if he can improve enough to get us where we need to be. A lot of weird things happened this year. Sometimes things aren’t as bad as they seem.

Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, Gigc said:

Not high enough to draft Lawrence.

He seems like a sure-fire lock for #1

So did Tua... Many surefire no. 1s fall a bit.  I'd say it's 50/50 Lawrence isn't even the first QB drafted next year.

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, bravo4460 said:

 

Agreed, But the case to be made here is. If 4 QBs go in the top 12 picks then there is going to be some REALLY good players on the board for the Colts to choose from. Could even trade back later into 1st round at that point and still potentially get a stud and pick up another 2nd or so.

 

Alot of opportunity with where they are.

That would be great. Caveat being it's gotta be a scenario in which JB isn't the future.... No drafted players not even WR..... Will make JB improve on reads, leading his man, going through progressions....

Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh boy!!!  Another QB thread!

 

Props to the original post and he made a very good point, then it turned into a JB or no JB thread again.

 

Point is, we have 3 very good people making the decision on what to do, so I trust they'll do the right thing.

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, CR91 said:

 

Excellent. So who is the next great QB for the colts

The 4 of us ain't telling. If we did everyone would want to jump in front of us in the draft. Oh, guess I gave a little away by mentioning draft so now you know he's in the draft.

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Imgrandojji said:

History disagrees with you.  Most of the greats sat for a year or 2 behind another QB.  Brady behind Blesdoe, Rodgers behind Favre, Mahomes behind Smith, etc.

 

When you throw a rookie right into the fire on week 1 day one that's a tough emotional hurdle to clear.  More than 1 promising QB has been destroyed that way.  Some do fine of course, but enough don't that you have to consider whether it's worth the risk, especially when the risk is almost completely unnecessary, all you have to do to avoid being forced into that risk is NOT get rid of your incumbent starter

 

Sorry, i didn't explain properly. I mean JB should not start. In fact, i believe he shouldn't be on the team next season.

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, bravo4460 said:

 

Agreed, But the case to be made here is. If 4 QBs go in the top 12 picks then there is going to be some REALLY good players on the board for the Colts to choose from. Could even trade back later into 1st round at that point and still potentially get a stud and pick up another 2nd or so.

 

Alot of opportunity with where they are.

I would love it if 4 QBs in the top 12 picks....

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Barry Sears said:

Oh boy!!!  Another QB thread!

 

Props to the original post and he made a very good point, then it turned into a JB or no JB thread again.

 

Point is, we have 3 very good people making the decision on what to do, so I trust they'll do the right thing.

 

Why complain? Don't read it or move on!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • They have contributed as much their rookie year as the entire group maybe by end of the season, but I doubt there's even a tiny chance of 2 all pros. Even 1 is a major stretch.  I am not sure we have any all pro's on the team since the most deserving one is Buckner (who I count as our first round pick in every way) has impact but no stats to wow anyone not intimately aware of his impact. If he misses this game we may painfully see how valuable.  But their collective impact has certainly added up. 4 starters and 2 solid special teamers in a so far playoff level team is quite a haul for any draft pick class in history.  It is at least adjacent to 2018, unless you don't count Buckner in any way.
    • Nothing against you and I like you as a poster but counting Ballard's 2017 season is a stretch. I realize he was the GM that year (1st year) but he didn't have the Coach he wanted and Luck was out for the year. We went 4-12 that year so his record is a bit skewed because of that. Others have posted the same thing about Ballard's record so you are not the only one and I just don't see how anyone can count that season legitimately. I pretty much go by 2018-this year when he hired Frank and his record would be 25-19 counting the playoffs. Is he the best GM in the league, probably not but he is good. He is responsible for drafting Nelson, Leonard, Mack, signing Houston, signing Rivers and trading for Buckner = great work there. Luck just retiring on the team and McDaniels dissing him even made his job that much harder. 
    • I am late to the party but it doesn't matter because I would've been 1-1 anyway. I had the Lions and Washington so it offsets     Here are my Sunday picks/Monday pick: Ravens 17 Steelers 24 Chargers 19 Bills 27 Titans 27 Colts 30 Panthers 20 Vikings 21 Browns 27 Jags 17 Giants 24 Bengals 10 Cards 27 Pats 23 Dolphins 99 Jets 0 (Fluke's original quote) Saints 24 Broncos 13 49ers 17 Rams 30 Chiefs 34 Bucs 24 Bears 17 Packers 27 Seahawks 31 Eagles 17
    • Yes, love the limited stuff from Harris. I really want to see more routes from him, but overall, love what he's doing. I'd love for him to be a long term answer at slot if Campbell moves to Z.    I'm up in the air on specs. I need to see him hit some long ones, as well as some additional clutch kicks. Glasgow, like I said, I just don't expect much from. Doubt he's ever a contributor on D, but if he kills it on ST, I'm happy.    A buddy of mine (a Ball State grad/fan), thinks Pinter develops into a RT, and the Colts will eventually move Smith over to LT (when AC retires), and let Pinter take RT. I don't know about all that, but I do agree Pinter might develop into more than we think.    I think Pittman will develop into a long term and consistent WR for us. I know he's just starting to emerge, but he just has the look. Good/willing blocker, good hands, etc.. He might not be the 50/50 guy I want, but I also think he might be better at in-stride catching than I thought.    JT, I think he'll be fine once he gets acclimated and use to the run blocking scheme. I don't want to diminish his talent, but most RBs should be able to be successful behind our OL, and he's better than most.    Blackmon is the most interesting to me. He's always been a hammer which I love. He's struggled though in coverage in college, and as we saw, got burnt deep a few games ago. Not sure if he's too aggressive forward, or just struggles with coverage and range. I hope it's just aggressiveness. It definitely helped him when they moved him from CB to S in college, but at the same time, Utah ran a ton of man, which we do not. Love most of what I've seen thus far. I just hope it's not a case where teams get film on him, and start testing him deep a lot. We've been fortunate to play some bad Os early that simply don't go deep a bunch. Will be interesting to follow.
    • It's Rivers he will play, the dude is made of steel  . He played with a torn ACL.
  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...