Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Recommended Posts

This is very basic. Pretend the Colts have zero needs other than depth. Got it? Zero.

 

I invite you to select....in order, the top five talents in the draft that you want on the team. Remember, need has nothing to do with this exercise.

This is about making a top 5 big board, of your ranking of impact players as if you were a scouting agency who represents no team. (Selecting a QB #1, is saying that is the most talented/impactful player in this draft)

Link to post
Share on other sites

#1 - Chase Young, DE, Ohio St - The true best player on the board, and at one of the most important positions, dominant edge rusher

#2 - Joe Burrow, QB, LSU - Although a one-year-wonder, he put it all together and won everything.  National championship and Heisman.  Most important position on the team.

#3 - Andrew Thomas, OT, Georgia - Yes, there are players that are being ranked higher than him, but OT is another one of those important positions.  Take him before the others.

#4 - Jeffrey Okudah, CB, Ohio St - Dominant cover corner is another one of those prime time positions.

#5 - Derrick Brown, DL3T, Auburn - Had to choose between him and Simmons.  I think a dominant DT is more important than a dominant off-LB.

 

Please note that I did not name a WR in my top five.  I once heard an NFL analyst on TV say that if you compared the different positions on a team to parts on a car, the WR is the radio.  Seriously.

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

This is hard one. There are so many great players in this class... I will also assume you don't want us to include positional value in this. 

 

Chase Young

Jeffrey Okudah

Joe Burrow

Isaiah Simmons

 

The fifth one is extremely hard for me. I can argue for like... 5-6 players here... Derrick Brown, Lamb, Jeudy, Andrew Thomas, Jedric Wills... hell... even Tristan Wirfs needs to be in this discussion, even though he will probably be RT, he will be a great one IMO. I think I will go with Jerry Jeudy here as my last one. 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, stitches said:

This is hard one. There are so many great players in this class... I will also assume you don't want us to include positional value in this. 

 

Chase Young

Jeffrey Okudah

Joe Burrow

Isaiah Simmons

 

The fifth one is extremely hard for me. I can argue for like... 5-6 players here... Derrick Brown, Lamb, Jeudy, Andrew Thomas, Jedric Wills... hell... even Tristan Wirfs needs to be in this discussion, even though he will probably be RT, he will be a great one IMO. I think I will go with Jerry Jeudy here as my last one. 

Thanks all for taking the time to do this exercise. Yes, chose to ask for 5, as it gets pretty murkey after that. There are some well thought responses in this thread. 

 

1) Chase Young

2) Derrick Brown

3) Jeffrey Okudah

4) A.J. Epenesa

5) Isaiah Simmons

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Four2itus said:

Thanks all for taking the time to do this exercise. Yes, chose to ask for 5, as it gets pretty murkey after that. There are some well thought responses in this thread. 

 

1) Chase Young

2) Derrick Brown

3) Isaiah Simmons

4) Jeffrey Okudah

5) A.J. Epenesa

I still haven't watched Epenesa. Some people have him top 5, others I've seen have him in the mid-late teens. What's your take on him? What does he do well and how does he win in the league? 

 

Either way, exercises like this IMO show that if we don't pick a QB it's very likely that we will have the chance to draft a really good prospect. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
42 minutes ago, stitches said:

I still haven't watched Epenesa. Some people have him top 5, others I've seen have him in the mid-late teens. What's your take on him? What does he do well and how does he win in the league? 

Well, he is going to have to continue to develop. He's got power, that's for sure. He is long, which is a trait Ballard seems to covet. It remains to be seen if he can continue to grow in the NFL, especially in space. Straight leverage, he's a monsta. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
59 minutes ago, stitches said:

I still haven't watched Epenesa. Some people have him top 5, others I've seen have him in the mid-late teens. What's your take on him? What does he do well and how does he win in the league? 

 

Either way, exercises like this IMO show that if we don't pick a QB it's very likely that we will have the chance to draft a really good prospect. 

Here are some highlights, wish I had more time to watch whole game film, but as you know, every player has highlights, and lowlights. Seems to be a lot of up with this guy.

 

https://thedraftnetwork.com/articles/a.j.-epenesa-is-unquestionably-edge1

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, stitches said:

I still haven't watched Epenesa. Some people have him top 5, others I've seen have him in the mid-late teens. What's your take on him? What does he do well and how does he win in the league? 

 

Either way, exercises like this IMO show that if we don't pick a QB it's very likely that we will have the chance to draft a really good prospect. 

 

Some people have Epenesa top-5?      Who?

 

And have they been drug tested yet?

 

LATE ADD:    I just double checked....  

For what it's worth,  and maybe it's worth very little to you or someone else....

 

But Mel has Epenesa ranked 15th.

Jeremiah has him ranked 28th

Todd has him ranked 31st.

 

I'm not saying he's not a talented kid.....    but top-5?    Or even top-10?

I'm not even sure he's a scheme fit in our defense.....?

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Four2itus said:

Well, he is going to have to continue to develop. He's got power, that's for sure. He is long, which is a trait Ballard seems to covet. It remains to be seen if he can continue to grow in the NFL, especially in space. Straight leverage, he's a monsta. 

Not sure he’s either athletic enough or twitchy enough.    Yes, he’s long and powerful, but I think Ballard values the speed and twitch over the other qualities.   

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, WarGhost21 said:

Couldn’t narrow down 5 so here’s my top 10:

 

1) Chase Young

2) Isaiah Simmons

3) DeAndre Swift

4) Derrick Brown

5) Jerry Juedy

6) Jeffrey Okudah

7) CeeDee Lamb

8) Joe Burrow

9) Jonathon Taylor

10) Jedrick Wills

By the way, I wanted to clarify: this is my player power rankings, it isn’t based off of positional value or anything. That’s why Swift is so high. RBs don’t go early but he is a top 5 talent in the class when it all boils down

Link to post
Share on other sites

For me the top of the draft is a lot more offensive heavy than what ive seen in the thread.

I'd go:

1.Chase Young

2.Joe Burrow

3.Ceedee Lamb

4.Jeff Okudah

5.Jerry Jeudy

6.Isaiah Simmons

7. Tua

8.Mekhi Becton

9.Henry Ruggs

10:Derrick Brown

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, NewColtsFan said:

 

Some people have Epenesa top-5?      Who?

 

And have they been drug tested yet?

 

LATE ADD:    I just double checked....  

For what it's worth,  and maybe it's worth very little to you or someone else....

 

But Mel has Epenesa ranked 15th.

Jeremiah has him ranked 28th

Todd has him ranked 31st.

 

I'm not saying he's not a talented kid.....    but top-5?    Or even top-10?

I'm not even sure he's a scheme fit in our defense.....?

 

I mean, I can't defend their rankings since they are... you know theirs, not mine. One is here - @Four2itus ranked him in the top 5. I still haven't gone through his film so I don't know if I will agree with him or not. I think reasonable people can disagree on highly ranked players depending on what they value most and what they project will improve. 

 

Examples(just going through The Draft Network's big boards): 

-Solak has him no. 9: https://thedraftnetwork.com/articles/2020-nfl-draft-big-board-rankings-december-solak

-Sikkema has him no. 10 https://thedraftnetwork.com/articles/trevor-sikkema-s-2020-nfl-draft-big-boardposition-rankings

-Fanspeak has him no.5 https://fanspeak.com/ontheclock-nfl-mock-draft-simulator/preview.php?board_id=0

-Matt Miller has him no. 10 https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2868550-2020-nfl-draft-big-board-matt-millers-latest-rankings#slide1

-Drafttek has him no. 9 https://www.drafttek.com/2020-NFL-Draft-Big-Board/Top-NFL-Draft-Prospects-2020-Page-1.asp

 

and so on... 

 

You can disagree, and I might too after I watch him, but it's not THAT outlandish for someone to have him ranked high. He's a talented player. Different people will have different opinions and that's OK. 

 

About scheme fit... I actually think he fits in the LDE mold that Ballard likes(the Sheard types that might kick inside on passing downs). But this was more a thread about pure talent rather than needs and fit. At least that's how I understood the exercise. 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I'm thinking the reason these Watson topics get locked is because the conversation starts veering into opinions about matters that are not relevant.  In this case, what Easterby is or isn't, and therefore by extension what HOU is or isn't by their employment of him.  Your opinion is determined by whatever lens you own, not proven facts.  Apparently, the locker room and NFL have a diverse set of lenses whereby some things are bigger deals to some players and not such a big deal to others.   It seems some support Watson holding out for a trade because their lens shows them that HOU is bad for the reasons of Easterby and McNair.    So they are supporting Watson holding out for a trade, but, its for different reason than Watson has expressed.   That's why I was wondering why irrelevant topics are being brought into a discussion about Watson and the reasons motivating a trade.  His reasons need to be understood because they would carry on to another owner.  Its not about the reasons we think he should want one, or the reasons why JJWatt thinks he should want one.    Watson's reasons are clearly about EB.  And if Watson is linking Bienemy to a violation of the Rooney Rule, the Rooney Rule has been around for about 15 years and the Texans have complied.  Its almost like he's taken a 3 minute look at the EB situation and expressed a public hot take conclusion without even knowing the Texans record of complying with the Rooney Rule.            
    • I agree what did most pundits say that we had the most complete roster in football last season.  Why, because Ballard built that through the draft for the most part and it hasn't put the team in salary cap hell like many other teams that don't even have the roster that we have so the credit goes to Ballard. 
    • I think the Browns were a lot better team after free agency. Are they championship level no but a lot better. I don't know why Dorsey got fired I thought he was doing a good job trying to make up for no talent.  My point is there are times that you need to dabble in free agency but it is better much better to go the draft rout.  
    • After the 49ers pulled off the exact trade up to the 3rd pick (that I suggested the Colts should do), I would fall over in laughter if they passed on Fields for Jones or Lance.  Fields is just as much the generational prospect as Lawrence.  When you look at the film and compare the numbers it really is a no brainer.  Here’s another Fields stat that puts him above the others.     The average rank of defenses that Fields has faced in his career is around low to mid twenties. Not too many cupcakes or soft touches.  Meanwhile Lawrence, Wilson, & Jones average defensive opponents is in the 40’s or much higher. So Fields put up better career numbers than all of the other QB’s while facing tougher competition week in and week out.     Better career accuracy. Better career rating past his first read (dispelled that lie about him).  Oh and he scored higher on an aptitude test than thousands of other professional athletes from multiple sports who have taken the same test.  Offered a scholarship to Harvard.  Kid is a smart pocket passer who is athletic and can run.  But he has no problem standing in the pocket and delivering accurate throws with conflict happening all around him.    I believe Kyle is just putting Fields to the ultimate test.  He remembers him from his high school QB camp where Fields took the things he learned there and improved his game to the point where he legitimately rivaled Lawrence as the best QB in the country.  Helped turn the best dual threat QB into the most accurate career passer in this draft.  And easily the most fundamentally sound.  That’s growth.    Also Kyle gets to see how Fields handles all of the chatter about Wilson & Jones & Lance being better.  How does he handle the 49ers not attending his first pro day?  How does he handle the leaks attacking his work ethic and commitment?  They could be looking for signs to how he will handle adversity on and off the field at the next level.  So far he’s been near perfect.  The fact he didn’t snap on Orlovsky shows great maturity.  Best QB in the draft. Just pray the Patriots don’t move up to 4th and get him if the 49ers are dumb enough to pass on him after moving up to the 3rd pick. 
    • Yes, I agree with you but I totally believe that Ballard has a plan and will do what's best for our team. I mean he knows better than any of us that he needs a left tackle and a pass rusher he's fully aware of it.  I have total and complete faith in Ballard that he'll put a championship level team on the field come week one. 
  • Members

    • The Peytonator

      The Peytonator 458

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • BigO

      BigO 58

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • coltsfansince65

      coltsfansince65 849

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • tvturner

      tvturner 470

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • hoosierhawk

      hoosierhawk 818

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • ponyboy

      ponyboy 67

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Dcuse

      Dcuse 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Smonroe

      Smonroe 2,317

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • SOMDColtsfan

      SOMDColtsfan 106

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • PrincetonTiger

      PrincetonTiger 8,508

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...