Draft A or B?

[GoColtsGo5150]

Both drafts courtesy of the Draft Network mock draft machine. Quite simply: which (if either) draft do you prefer and why? I am aware there are repeat players in both drafts but then again, they were BPA and I clearly like them.

 

Draft A

13.Justin Herbert QB, Oregon

34. Javon Kinlaw IDL, South Carolina

44. Prince Tega Wanogho OT, Auburn

75. Joshua Uche EDGE, Michigan

112.Michael Pittman Jr. WR, USC

142. Kyle Dugger S, Lenoir-Rhyne

173. Chase Claypool WR, Notre Dame

190. Jacob Breeland TE, Oregon

204. Jaron Bryant CB, Fresno State

 

Draft B

13. Derrick Brown IDL, Auburn

34. Jordan Love QB, Utah State

44. Prince Tega Wanogho OT, Auburn

75. Quartney Davis WR, Texas A&M

112.Joshua Uche EDGE, Michigan

142.Kyle Dugger S, Lenoir-Rhyne

173. Mitchell Wilcox TE, South Florida

190. Kindle Vildor CB, Georgia Southern

204. Binjimen Victor WR, Ohio State

[SP_21]

Although I’m not sold on either player, I like Herbert much more than Love. So I’d go with “A”. Kinlaw in the 2nd is an absolute steal as well. 

[coltsfanej]

I say B. Idk enough about either QB to be sold but by what I understand  Brown is an absolute stud and that Kinlaw is a definite step down from Brown. So I say take a surefire blue chip player in the first if u get the chance. And Love is said to have as much potential as any QB in the draft 

[Vexed]

I gotta go with B. Just wish Pittman or Claypool was in B but Brown is a win win and I’m in the Love camp.

[AZColt11]

If I had to choose, I'd probably say B.  A gets the better QB and Kinlaw in round 2 is a steal, but B has the better overall player in Brown, and I don't mind Love as much in round 2.

 

Neither gets us much of an impact WR though.

[Freenyfan102]

Love a better QB funny

[Kangaroo]

You could go Brown at 13 , then Kinlaw at 34 (not sold on either QB)

[funktacious2]

They look like really any draft simulator where you don't try to make them realistic, just a pipe dream. I'd be very happy with either. But just about everyone you have past your 1st round picks will probably go sooner than where you have them. That's just the way these simulators go.

[Repeat Offender]

Love vs LSU....not our guy

[Zoltan]

I like both but I don't think they are realistic,

 

although I think number 44. Prince Tega Wanogho OT, Auburn is realistic and would be a great move to eventually replace Castonzo at LT and we have the players and staff to help him improve.

[Mel Kiper's Hair]

I don't think draft A is possible. From the things I've read it appears that Herbert and Kinlaw both will be top 10 picks. Would be an amazing draft if we were able to get them both!

[Four2itus]

B please.