Totally disagree. Eli has never been in the conversation as an MVP when he played . He was never ranked as one of the best qbs when he played. I think the whole he won 2 super bowl argument is absurd. Does that mean that the LT who played in those 2 super bowl wins deserves to b in the hall of fame even though he had an average career? The hall of fame me is for the truly elite players of their time. Eli is well below such players like Marion, Montana, Favre, his brother, Brady, Young and I could go on.