Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Colts to work out FA kickers today


NannyMcafee

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 189
  • Created
  • Last Reply

About dang time

 

Again..... AT THIS STAGE..... we are missing EXTRA POINTS!

 

You cant tell me that there isnt someone that can make Extra Points reliably

 

I would be happy with a 98% Extra Point Kicker, with a 75% hit rate for FGs of 0-45 yards

 

You cant tell me that guy isnt available

 

Forget the "big leg" guys.....

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, MikeCurtis said:

About dang time

 

Again..... AT THIS STAGE..... we are missing EXTRA POINTS!

 

You cant tell me that there isnt someone that can make Extra Points reliably

 

I would be happy with a 98% Extra Point Kicker, with a 75% hit rate for FGs of 0-45 yards

 

You cant tell me that guy isnt available

 

Forget the "big leg" guys.....

 

 

 

Should be able to find a guy who can make 40 yard kicks reliably. So we have to make it further for FG range? Who cares. If we had that we would have won 2 other games and possibly last week too. We dont need the best guy. Just better than what we have. 

 

Colts will draft a Kicker this off season. 

 

Kevin Bowen said in his pod cast, that vinny has never had an elite leg, and was never the most accurate (after going through his history of coyese). He is literally the clutch kicker. And that's gone now. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1070 podcast suggested that there was a double standard when it comes to Vinatieri.  That other players (like Cain) are given a message of "do better or else", but AV gets a pass on a 70% extra point rate.  They said that there's no way that the locker room doesn't see that, and that it doesn't have an effect.

 

Not saying that I have any insider info into the locker room.  Just repeating what 1070 podcast was saying.  At any rate, it ain't good, and it can't continue.

Link to post
Share on other sites

IF the Colts really are trying out kickers, then I think it's safe to assume that they've informed AV about it. And AV, being the class act that he is, has probably signed off on the decision to bring in new kickers.

 

AV has to know that he's struggling mightily and he has to know that this is what is best for the team.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  I’d love for it to work out as Vinny just kicking better. Is he capable of kicking extra points consistently? YES!! 
  That being said, I understand why they are bringing guys in, but what if part of the blame is the snap, hold and blocking?  Can a “new guy” negate those things. 
  He might be done or he might just be in the same boat as other Colts: ALL needing to play better.

   Going to be interesting to see how this plays out.

     If Vinatieri does retire, I would love to see them get Blankenship from Georgia.

     Rodrego and Rigaberto

Link to post
Share on other sites
24 minutes ago, Chloe6124 said:

Ballard won’t have the guts to do it. 

 

 

What if the kickers they work out all have terrible tryouts?

 

Is that Ballard "not having guts" to not drop AV for someone else to produce the same results?

 

SMH... why a personal attack on Ballard? It serves no purpose and is low class in this instance 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mixed emotions on this, but they at least need to see who's available.  I know some of the misses haven't all been AV's fault, but he has missed kicks that an NFL level kicker should miss.

 

He may be the GOAT, but he's not the greatest of right now.  We have 3 big divisional games coming up and can't afford to lose any of them due to missed extra points and makeable FG's

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, John Hammonds said:

1070 podcast suggested that there was a double standard when it comes to Vinatieri.  That other players (like Cain) are given a message of "do better or else", but AV gets a pass on a 70% extra point rate.  They said that there's no way that the locker room doesn't see that, and that it doesn't have an effect.

 

Not saying that I have any insider info into the locker room.  Just repeating what 1070 podcast was saying.  At any rate, it ain't good, and it can't continue.

Not to pile on Vinny, but losses like that definitely gas an impact.

Similar to how a win like that can have an affect.

It can change the way you coach and play.

 

Out team's success somewhat hinges on the sense of team and emotion.  It carried us last year.  Sum is greater than the parts.

  Unfortunately , in some ways it has divided us, coaching, management, and players in some ways.  I think we are seeing some of this in overall team play.

 

  The way we play football, fieldgoals and extracpoints are at a premium.  The gameplan relies on them i think.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, CoachSmok3 said:

 

 

What if the kickers they work out all have terrible tryouts?

 

Is that Ballard "not having guts" to not drop AV for someone else to produce the same results?

 

SMH... why a personal attack on Ballard? It serves no purpose and is low class in this instance 

Agreed some fans seem to think one player struggles automatically equals someone else being better.  It doesn’t always work that way.  I am all for finding out if someone better is out there but I trust Ballard to make the right decision.

Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, MikeCurtis said:

About dang time

 

Again..... AT THIS STAGE..... we are missing EXTRA POINTS!

 

You cant tell me that there isnt someone that can make Extra Points reliably

 

I would be happy with a 98% Extra Point Kicker, with a 75% hit rate for FGs of 0-45 yards

 

You cant tell me that guy isnt available

 

Forget the "big leg" guys.....

 

 

Well. the Patriots have been searching for one for 7 weeks now... so no, I'd say that guy isn't available at the moment

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, GoColts8818 said:

Agreed some fans seem to think one player struggles automatically equals someone else being better.  It doesn’t always work that way.  I am all for finding out if someone better is out there but I trust Ballard to make the right decision.

 

 

Im out of reactions at 1030am smh lol... But THIS

 

I too am all for looking at our options available! I said it in another thread the other day- id much rather hear the K talk than the QB talk... 

 

The misses have been devastating, and something needs to change... But this isnt Madden where every other FA kicker is still at 78 OVR and as the player you can go 100% from 55 yards plus

 

Kicking also is NOT as easy as some here seem to think. They were probably the same type that was ragging on the kickers back in HS, while they themselves were just standing on the sidelines...

 

The personal attack on Ballard is what got me tho... and Im a HUGE supporter of questioning authority... Calling Ballard "gutless" isnt questioning authority... its just SAD

Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Colts_Fan12 said:

you'll get the same outcome of losing games as you do with AV. parkey does nothing but miss important kicks 

 

If he just hits routine kicks our record is better.  

 

AV is missing both the clutch kicks and the routine ones.  I doubt we're going to find a super clutch kicker right now off the street.  But might as well get one who can hit some routine kicks.  

 

Parkey's percentages from his last year in Chicago are better than AV's percentages this year.  

 

Next offseason I would say try to sign Mason Crosby in FA, he is a high level kicker.  If you can't get him you bring in another free agent and get one via draft or UDFA and let them compete for the job.  But I strongly believe signing Mason Crosby in FA is the best choice.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, John Hammonds said:

1070 podcast suggested that there was a double standard when it comes to Vinatieri.  That other players (like Cain) are given a message of "do better or else", but AV gets a pass on a 70% extra point rate.  They said that there's no way that the locker room doesn't see that, and that it doesn't have an effect.

 

Not saying that I have any insider info into the locker room.  Just repeating what 1070 podcast was saying.  At any rate, it ain't good, and it can't continue.

 

I listened to that and while it does worry me that other players are begrudging the fact that they are keeping vinny, you gotta think, most teams have multiples at each given position. You even have a back up QB. No backup kicker. No backup punter. So when one of your kickers is struggling what are you going to do? Just cut the guy without a backup plan? 

 

It's not as simple as just letting them walk in this case. 

 

But I would be lying if I wasnt worried that the lockerroom is starting to grumble about it. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, John Hammonds said:

1070 podcast suggested that there was a double standard when it comes to Vinatieri.  That other players (like Cain) are given a message of "do better or else", but AV gets a pass on a 70% extra point rate.  They said that there's no way that the locker room doesn't see that, and that it doesn't have an effect.

 

Not saying that I have any insider info into the locker room.  Just repeating what 1070 podcast was saying.  At any rate, it ain't good, and it can't continue.

not saying that isn't true. Question is, what's easier to replace, a 6th round WR who's 5th on the depth chart or a starting Kicker?

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Flash7 said:

We are missing PATs at the moment. Freaking extra points that are considered automatic, and we're missing.

 

If we find a guy that can make those, we've already upgraded the position.

The whole reason the NFL moved them back was to make them not automatic.

 

i agree with you though if someone can hit them better they should be brought in at this point.  However, my point is that just because we want someone to be better doesn’t automatically mean they will do better.  These guys are out there for a reason and while I would like to think they could do better than Adam has at this point I don’t know that.  That’s why I am all for finding out and if they are getting one of them in here.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, csmopar said:

not saying that isn't true. Question is, what's easier to replace, a 6th round WR who's 5th on the depth chart or a starting Kicker?

Probably about the same.

AV's performance makes it easier than it usually would be to replace a kicker.   70% on extra points is not even  defensible.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, GoColts8818 said:

Agreed some fans seem to think one player struggles automatically equals someone else being better.  It doesn’t always work that way.  I am all for finding out if someone better is out there but I trust Ballard to make the right decision.

 

If you look at percentages, most street kickers at this point are better than AV.  There is obviously no one elite out there, and I would argue none of these guys are someone you want to rely upon after this season.  

 

But AV can't hit the routine or clutch kicks right now.  There are street free agents out there who can hit most of the routine kicks at the very least.  Go compare Cody Parkey's percentages in his last year in Chicago (where he kicked out doors with wind coming off the lake) to AV this year (where he is kicking indoors).  Parkey is better.  

 

AV's not just struggling, he's completely dropped off.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, NannyMcafee said:

 

I listened to that and while it does worry me that other players are begrudging the fact that they are keeping vinny, you gotta think, most teams have multiples at each given position. You even have a back up QB. No backup kicker. No backup punter. So when one of your kickers is struggling what are you going to do? Just cut the guy without a backup plan? 

 

It's not as simple as just letting them walk in this case. 

 

But I would be lying if I wasnt worried that the lockerroom is starting to grumble about it. 

At most positions there are guys on the PS too

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Valpo2004 said:

 

If he just hits routine kicks our record is better.  

 

AV is missing both the clutch kicks and the routine ones.  I doubt we're going to find a super clutch kicker right now off the street.  But might as well get one who can hit some routine kicks.  

 

Parkey's percentages from his last year in Chicago are better than AV's percentages this year.  

 

Next offseason I would say try to sign Mason Crosby in FA, he is a high level kicker.  If you can't get him you bring in another free agent and get one via draft or UDFA and let them compete for the job.  But I strongly believe signing Mason Crosby in FA is the best choice.  

I know its frowned upon to draft a kicker. However, the K out of Georgia is one guy I would 100% be in favor of drafting 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, GoColts8818 said:

The whole reason the NFL moved them back was to make them not automatic.

 

i agree with you though if someone can hit them better they should be brought in at this point.  However, my point is that just because we want someone to be better doesn’t automatically mean they will do better.  These guys are out there for a reason and while I would like to think they could do better than Adam has at this point I don’t know that.  That’s why I am all for finding out and if they are getting one of them in here.

Everyone is having problems

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Myles said:

Probably about the same.

AV's performance makes it easier than it usually would be to replace a kicker.   70% on extra points is not even  defensible.  

I agree with the bold. Whats weird in all this is that AV is making the super long ones, 50+. But can't hit between the 25 and 45 yarders consistently. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, NannyMcafee said:

But I would be lying if I wasnt worried that the lockerroom is starting to grumble about it. 

I honestly don't think there's any friction or fracturing in the locker room honestly. They've shown they have each other's back in many aspects (Luck/JB transition, Turay injury).

 

This is a different type of difficult. It could be sticking with the evil you know, or they know he's injured and are riding out the bumps until he heals or it could be Jim not wanting to go out like this.

 

All speculation on my part, but it's crazy how many kickers are missing kicks this year.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Valpo2004 said:

 

If you look at percentages, most street kickers at this point are better than AV.  There is obviously no one elite out there, and I would argue none of these guys are someone you want to rely upon after this season.  

 

But AV can't hit the routine or clutch kicks right now.  There are street free agents out there who can hit most of the routine kicks at the very least.  Go compare Cody Parkey's percentages in his last year in Chicago (where he kicked out doors with wind coming off the lake) to AV this year (where he is kicking indoors).  Parkey is better.  

 

AV's not just struggling, he's completely dropped off.  

Yeah and as we have seen with Adam this year you can’t go off past stats alone.  You have to see what they can do now which is why I am glad they are working out kickers.  If one of them makes Ballard think they can be fairly consistent I am on board with getting them in here.  It’s not a guarantee they will though.  That’s all I am saying.

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, csmopar said:

I agree with the bold. Whats weird in all this is that AV is making the super long ones, 50+. But can't hit between the 25 and 45 yarders consistently. 

I was saying that to a friend. He's totally still got the long range in him, but anything close is a crapshoot.

 

Maybe they go crazy and bring in a K for XPs and 40yds and in...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


  • Popular Now

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Well, part of the issue is the rotational approach to begin with, IMO.  With playoff caliber coaches, QBs, and personnel; I'd think that once the saw the guy who was only good at one thing, they would audible into doing the other.     So if the light guy Lewis is playing 3T a lot, TEN is going to feed Henry until the 3T stops getting washed out.
    • When Peyton had his issues in 2015 with his foot, Kubiak benched him and went with Osweiler because Peyton was hurting the team at that point. This is a HOF QB we are talking about who had earned a LOT of rope. Once Peyton had minor surgery and was back and active and ready to go, that is when Kubiak put him back, and Peyton at least steadied the Broncos ship during the playoffs.    Unless it gets to a point where Rivers' play hurts the Colts like with Peyton where he threw 3 or 4 picks in 1 game within 2 quarters while the Broncos played the Chiefs, Rivers is our starter.
    • It's not even about his production. After he got back from his injury his production has actually been fine. I'm not one of those who wants ungodly numbers from him to think he's showing promise. But I do want to see him beat his man off the release on he outside. I do want him to win some contested balls and show body control and good hands. My problem with him right now is that ... he just... doesn't win his reps really. He needs his man to get stuck in traffic or for a defensive breakdown to happen in order to make stuff happen. Just an example - look at what Claypool is doing. Look at what Ceedee Lamb is doing...   I couldn't care less if he ends the year with 400 yards and 2TDs... It's not what this is about... it's about me wanting to see some flashes of what he could become with development. So yeah, sure... I absolutely agree with you that it's still early in his career and there is time for him to get better and develop, but we still can watch what he's doing now and where he's struggling and evaluate that. IMO he's struggling with pretty much every single aspect of playing X-receiver. Which is why Reich started using him a ton in the slot after his injury.      This is not a coincidence. The jump in production coicides perfectly with Reich moving him inside to the slot and scheming things for him.   
    • Rattle on about your interpretation about what's going on, rather than your knowledge of it.     Why are babbling about something irrelevant, like hindsight?   There was no looking back. There is no hindsight. The trade up for Lewis was criticized immediately when it happened.  My thought yesterday merely triggered a 2.5 year old memory.  It wasn't a new thought based on hindsight.   If you don't know that, you're not qualified to comment about the situation or about me.   Let it go, because you've revealed you ignorance on the matter.   And it was a one sentence comment at the end of a five sentence paragraph.  It was a side comment.  It wasn't a deal until you made it one.   Do us a favor.  Smarten up, or get out.     
    • I think strong side DE plays more snaps for us than weak side DE with more run stopping responsibilities like Sheard and Houston. I am not sure if that is a systematic conscious approach or something that happened by chance. In other words, they want a few jacks who do only 1 trade on a rotational basis instead of 1 jack that does several trades for the weak side DE position. However the hit percentage seems to be low so far with several dart opportunities at the draft board.   That approach only works if those jacks do jack but if they don't do jack, who the jack is won't matter.  
  • Members

    • CoachLite

      CoachLite 647

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Fourstar40

      Fourstar40 9

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Onthefence

      Onthefence 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • newb767

      newb767 27

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • chad72

      chad72 13,504

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Flash7

      Flash7 2,713

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Sumo63

      Sumo63 517

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • greenacres

      greenacres 10

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • PeterBowman

      PeterBowman 3,489

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Caffrey

      Caffrey 118

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...