NFL preseason QB Rankings

[lollygagger8]

14 hours ago, MPStack said:

 

I don’t think we will have to be worried about another 2006 Divisional meltdown like the Steelers dished out.

 

Never has any Colts game upset me more, than that game. 

 

 

That one Saints game where they ran it up like 62-7 while Sean Payton was eating hotdogs up in the booth was top 5 tick me off games ever. 

[Myles]

7 hours ago, neug3246 said:

That list was a joke Arron Rodgers was #2. Dont get me wrong he is a good QB but hasn't played like a top 10 since he won the Super Bowl. His game tonight also proved thst he isn't a number 2 QB 

Rogers still plays like the best QB in the league.

[Archer]

Thought about it and in a very partisan fashion put together my list for this year:

1) Mahomes

2) Brees

3) Ryan (underrated by many)

4) Wilson

5) Wentz

6) Rodgers

7) Roethslesberger

8) Mayfield

9) Goff

10) Rivers

11) Brady

12) Prescott

13) Watson

14) Cousins

15) Carr

16) Flacco

17) Stafford

18) Brissett

19) Foles

20) Trubisky 

21) Garoppolo 

22) Darnold

23) Newton

24) Jackson

25) Mariota

26) Manning

27) Fitzpatrick

28) Winston

29) Murray

30) Dalton

31) Allen

32) Keenum

[Restinpeacesweetchloe]

1 minute ago, Archer said:

Thought about it and in a very partisan fashion put together my list for this year:

1) Mahomes

2) Brees

3) Ryan (underrated by many)

4) Wilson

5) Wentz

6) Rodgers

7) Roethslesberger

8) Mayfield

9) Goff

10) Rivers

11) Brady

12) Prescott

13) Watson

14) Cousins

15) Carr

16) Flacco

17) Stafford

18) Brissett

19) Foles

20) Trubisky 

21) Garoppolo 

22) Darnold

23) Newton

24) Jackson

25) Mariota

26) Manning

27) Fitzpatrick

28) Winston

29) Murray

30) Dalton

31) Allen

32) Keenum

That is very fair. 

[runthepost]

20 minutes ago, Archer said:

Thought about it and in a very partisan fashion put together my list for this year:

1) Mahomes

2) Brees

3) Ryan (underrated by many)

4) Wilson

5) Wentz

6) Rodgers

7) Roethslesberger

8) Mayfield

9) Goff

10) Rivers

11) Brady

12) Prescott

13) Watson

14) Cousins

15) Carr

16) Flacco

17) Stafford

18) Brissett

19) Foles

20) Trubisky 

21) Garoppolo 

22) Darnold

23) Newton

24) Jackson

25) Mariota

26) Manning

27) Fitzpatrick

28) Winston

29) Murray

30) Dalton

31) Allen

32) Keenum

Newton is 15. He played last year on a bum shoulder 

[coltsva]

19 minutes ago, Archer said:

Thought about it and in a very partisan fashion put together my list for this year:

1) Mahomes

2) Brees

3) Ryan

4) Wilson

5) Wentz

6) Rodgers

7) Roethslesberger

8) Mayfield

9) Goff

10) Rivers

11) Brady

12) Prescott

13) Watson

14) Cousins

15) Carrthles

16) Flacco

17) Stafford

18) Brissett

19) Foles

20) Trubisky 

21) Garoppolo 

22) Darnold

23) Newton

24) Jackson

25) Mariota

26) Manning

27) Fitzpatrick

28) Winston

29) Murray

30) Dalton

31) Allen

32) Keenum

Take out the old guys, and there’s only a few who have proven themselves over several seasons. 

 

Everyone else is average, below average, or hasn’t played enough to give a definitive rating.

[holeymoley99]

Flacco is nowehere near this high at this point of his career IMO.

[IndyScribe]

12 hours ago, Chloe6124 said:

I don’t care. We have way more weapons on top of it.

Trubisjy was bad last year as well.

[Patrick Miller]

I have no idea what to expect but I'm optimistic.

[Myles]

4 hours ago, Archer said:

Thought about it and in a very partisan fashion put together my list for this year:

1) Mahomes

2) Brees

3) Ryan (underrated by many)

4) Wilson

5) Wentz

6) Rodgers

7) Roethslesberger

8) Mayfield

9) Goff

10) Rivers

11) Brady

12) Prescott

13) Watson

14) Cousins

15) Carr

16) Flacco

17) Stafford

18) Brissett

19) Foles

20) Trubisky 

21) Garoppolo 

22) Darnold

23) Newton

24) Jackson

25) Mariota

26) Manning

27) Fitzpatrick

28) Winston

29) Murray

30) Dalton

31) Allen

32) Keenum

Wentz is too high.   Ahead of Rogers?

Flacco too high and Stafford too low.  

Brissett to high.   

[Archer]

1 hour ago, Myles said:

Wentz is too high.   Ahead of Rogers?

Flacco too high and Stafford too low.  

Brissett to high.   

 

I am a Wentz fan - this is kind of a projection for this year, rather than who was best in the past.  I admit I slotted Rodgers lower than I would have before last night (Trubisky too, they both looked bad).  Maybe without much preseason work, all qbs are gonna look that way.  At any rate, I also have a good feeling about a Flacco career revitalization in Denver...

[BigQungus]

6 hours ago, Archer said:

Thought about it and in a very partisan fashion put together my list for this year:

1) Mahomes

2) Brees

3) Ryan (underrated by many)

4) Wilson

5) Wentz

6) Rodgers

7) Roethslesberger

8) Mayfield

9) Goff

10) Rivers

11) Brady

12) Prescott

13) Watson

14) Cousins

15) Carr

16) Flacco

17) Stafford

18) Brissett

19) Foles

20) Trubisky 

21) Garoppolo 

22) Darnold

23) Newton

24) Jackson

25) Mariota

26) Manning

27) Fitzpatrick

28) Winston

29) Murray

30) Dalton

31) Allen

32) Keenum

 

Cam is way too low. Trubisky, Flacco, nowhere near him. Jameis Winston will also improve. I see Bruce Arians' style really fitting with him. Goff, Carr, Flacco, Stafford too high. The Carr and Stafford ones are more nitpicks.

 

I could nitpick with the list a little more here and there, but overall pretty good

[BigQungus]

15 hours ago, Colts_Fan12 said:

its 1 game

 

Except it isn't. Throughout his career, I haven't been impressed, and I'm sad to say that cause I have him as my backup on fantasy

[Colts_Fan12]

Just now, BigQungus said:

 

Except it isn't. Throughout his career, I haven't been impressed, and I'm sad to say that cause I have him as my backup on fantasy

I'm not a fan of his but you cant just say an unknown is better than someone with experience after 1 game 

[BigQungus]

Just now, Colts_Fan12 said:

I'm not a fan of his but you cant just say an unknown is better than someone with experience after 1 game 

 

"If you call losing experience"

                                                        - Thanos

[BigQungus]

2 minutes ago, Colts_Fan12 said:

I'm not a fan of his but you cant just say an unknown is better than someone with experience after 1 game 

 

But seriously though, why can't I? He hasn't proven much to me. If I think Brissett is better on paper, then I think Brissett is better. Otherwise by that logic, it would be completely unreasonable to say that Kyler Murray, or some other unproved but talented QB, will be better than Ryan Leaf. It's not about how good they were, or how good they've proven to be, it's about how good you think they will be.

[NorthernBlue]

22 hours ago, MPStack said:

Upvote for my boy mo salah

[Colts_Fan12]

15 minutes ago, BigQungus said:

 

But seriously though, why can't I? He hasn't proven much to me. If I think Brissett is better on paper, then I think Brissett is better. Otherwise by that logic, it would be completely unreasonable to say that Kyler Murray, or some other unproved but talented QB, will be better than Ryan Leaf. It's not about how good they were, or how good they've proven to be, it's about how good you think they will be.

prolly since his team was in the playoffs last year when JB hasn't done a damn thing yet.

 

the experts ranked him ahead for a reason so glad you homer fans dont run things dear god

[runthepost]

51 minutes ago, BigQungus said:

 

But seriously though, why can't I? He hasn't proven much to me. If I think Brissett is better on paper, then I think Brissett is better. Otherwise by that logic, it would be completely unreasonable to say that Kyler Murray, or some other unproved but talented QB, will be better than Ryan Leaf. It's not about how good they were, or how good they've proven to be, it's about how good you think they will be.

Mitch second year passing percentage was 66.6% and a rating of 95.9 % Brissett has not done anything to be better than Mitch. That’s not a knock on Brissett either 

[Archer]

1 hour ago, NorthernBlue said:

Upvote for my boy mo salah

I don’t understand any part of this post, lol.  ;)

[BigQungus]

On 9/6/2019 at 4:10 PM, Colts_Fan12 said:

prolly since his team was in the playoffs last year when JB hasn't done a damn thing yet.

 

the experts ranked him ahead for a reason so glad you homer fans dont run things dear god

 

All hail the all-knowing experts!!

On 9/6/2019 at 4:59 PM, runthepost said:

Mitch second year passing percentage was 66.6% and a rating of 95.9 % Brissett has not done anything to be better than Mitch. That’s not a knock on Brissett either 

 

I'm not saying Brissett has been better than Mitch. I'm saying he is better and will be better than Mitch