I would have made him the backup behind Brissett. But there is no reason to think he should be starting right now.
He's got a lot of raw arm talent and good athleticism. But you need a QB to be a mature leader on and off the field and you need a QB to be smart. Brissett already has those qualities. We're not yet sure about Kelly.
Let's make sure the man can go a whole year without getting into trouble.
I would not read too much into the Colts and the Texans beating the Chiefs. Against the Colts, the Chiefs were without their #1 and #2 receiver, 2 or 3 of their starting oline, and during the game lost their ILB, probowl DT and someone else.
Against the Texans the #1 WR was on a pitch count, still without their #2 WR, still missing 2 starting olineman, probowl DT, staring ILB.
I'm not saying the Colts or Texans did not earn their wins, both played good games but we all know if the Colts were that handicapped the Colts fans would be using that as a reason after a loss (don't believe me, look at the threads after the Oakland loss and how many people said, if the Colts had Funchess, Hilton and Leonard the game would have been different)
I really doubt he would come back to play in one game. He already has the rings.
Also I'm not sure how useful he would be. Even if he's in shape it's doubtful that he could suddenly come back and jump into the game with little to no practice the entire season and play extremely well.
I think Hoodie would say "Thanks but no thanks"