Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Armchair GM's and Madden, do they correlate?

Recommended Posts

I hear the term "armchair GM's" all the time, and it generally makes me think of a hardcore football fan that watches a lot of college tape and pretends to be a GM by judging draft prospects. However, there's a different way that is presented in newer versions of Madden in the scouting feature that is very realistic to how actual GM's may judge prospects, and Madden fans can use this to potentially get more accurate results in real life when watching actual college prospects. This may also be an actual way certain GM's judge prospects throughout the year all the way through the combine.


First, as soon as the first week of college football ends (week 3 of the regular season), you have your list of all the new prospects that are available to be drafted next year (in Madden it's set in stone who is coming out and their projected draft position while in real life players can declare later or choose to go back to school). It tells their position, where they are projected to be drafted, their scheme at their position, and when scouted with points you receive each week, their top 3 skills at that position. So far, this seems to correlate very well with what real life scouts do to gain information on whether they want to draft a prospect or not. Throughout the year, you can hear draft stories ranging from a player making a big play to win a game, to they are struggling in multiple games, to more obscure things like skipping practice which can affect development. All of these stories can positively or negatively affect draft position throughout the year for the highlighted players. So again, this correlates to real life. You get a certain amount of scouting points to find the top 3 skills of any players you want up to a point. In real life, you are also somewhat limited in how many players you are allowed to bring in for interviews and scout. I believe it's 60, so these correlate very well.


After the season is when it gets interesting. Right around when FA starts in the game, you are allowed to do some more scouting, and they give out combine grades. There are more draft stories based on the combine, and you can see who bombed the combine and who succeeded in it. There are your basic grades such as 40 time, bench press, etc... and they affect stats such as speed and strength (just like real life). There are also ranks on how each player did in each drill for their position. This helps determine how good athletically they are compared to their peers, but also doesn't solely make or break them as a player. You can build your own draft board and watch list and go from there. Trades are also a lot harder to pull off, so you can't rip teams off like you used too. You then go through the draft, trade up and down, and you get your players with a lot of strategy and hard work (although the draft goes quicker on Madden).


It's not a perfect science yet, but I do believe "armchair GMing" through Madden does paint a somewhat accurate picture of the process that an actual GM goes through. Obviously we are not watching actual tape of the draftees on Madden, and that's a big part of it, but the entire process and evaluation heavily correlates what a real GM tries to accomplish in real life, and I think a lot of people who follow the Madden blueprint will actually get better results on hitting on picks if they follow it to a T in real life. Not everyone can do it, but this shows a basic version of what a GM goes through every year when drafting players and evaluating them at every position for their favorite team.


Comment below if you agree or disagree, and I'd love to get some discussion from draft gurus, and especially Madden players on this subject!

Link to post
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I would strongly consider signing FA safety Eric Reid.   Than we need to see about focusing on LT, TEs, and DEs for next season.  Worse case may have to see how the Cardinals are using Kelvin Beachum and offer a trade if we end up losing AC early mid-trade season.  Other potential upcoming FA's may look more into would be TB Bucs WR Chris Godwin, TE Gerald Everett, and DE Trent Murphy.     I realized we just paid Kelly at center but oft-injured game-time availability has me wondering how our backup would do.  Am looking at Centers Daniel Kilgore (KC), Evan Brown (Browns) or Josh Andrews (Jets) as potential backup targets.    As for the 2021 draft my early LT target to keep an eye on is Jackson Carman from Clemson in Round 1.  Again I am high on S Hamsah Nasirildeen (Florida St) who went back to school but should still be a first rounder.  TE Pat Freiermuth (Penn St) has me intrigued.  As for DEs had Edge Patrick Jones II (Pitttsburgh) on my wish list in Round 2.  Hilton's age on the end of his career had me looking at WR Nico Collins (Michigan) in Round 3.  Collins has solid hands and no history of drops.
    • I’ve found my new favorite way to watch a game.  Really gives you an idea of what's happening.    You can see play design, who’s out of position, who missed a block, who fell down, even who’s pickin their nose or scratchin their butt. All 22 on the field so you miss nothing.   I especially like to see the blocking bubbles grow or collapse on the line.   I just cant say how much i’m gaining from this.  Each play is run twice...once from sideline (all 22), then from endzone (all 22).  Great to see the plays develop, or a defender fly across the field to a tackle.   No sound, so i will still watch normally first (or radio sometimes for drama), but if anyone never checked it out..... you must!  I cant believe i waited this long.  I have such a better idea of what we’re trying to do and who looks good or bad on EVERY play.   Also, i feel better about last week after watching for some odd reason.  I kept finding myself saying “oh, thats why that happened.”   The normal perspective is such a focused frame , usually on the ball.  We’re missing all the little battles going on in the periphery.
    • Well the misconception was the Jags were going to tank this season. No one told them that.  Your sky is falling opinion is way too pre mature. 
    • My questions are can he find the crack and what will he do mean the crack ain’t there.  Wisconsin doesn’t do cracks, they block chasms against the cornfield circuit.
    • Many die hard colt fans are sugar coating this loss as they want to believe so hard that this was a fluke or lol actually believing the Jags are a good team!  After the Jags just unloaded ALL their probowl talent, you think the roster is loaded?  If their loaded, what do you call this colts roster?  I think the Colts overlooked their opponent even know they haven't won there since a grip.
  • Members

    • RDNScot

      RDNScot 0

      Last active:
    • stitches

      stitches 9,421

      Senior Member
      Last active:
    • funktacious2

      funktacious2 842

      Senior Member
      Last active:
    • Aces101

      Aces101 122

      Last active:
  • Create New...