Lucky Colts Fan

Top 10 Current Colts

Recommended Posts

It's the off-off-season, so let's do some more rankings!  haha

 

Who are the 10 best players on the 2018 Colts?

 

1.  Andrew Luck

2.  TY Hilton

3.  Adam Vinatieri

4.  Quenton Nelson

5.  Ryan Kelly

6.  Jack Doyle

7.  Malik Hooker

8.  Anthony Castanzo

9.  Eric Ebron

10.  Rigoberto Sanchez

Just missed the cut:  Quincy Wilson

 

QB and WR are #1 and #2, so that's good.  But the rest are three OL, two TEs, the K, the P, and only one defensive player...  :help:

 

Anyway, that's my ranking.  Interested to see how ya'll rank 'em!  :thmup:

  • Like 1
  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Luck

Vinatieri

Hilton

Castanzo

Doyle

Sheard

Simon

Kelly

Geathers

Woods

 

I made a list comprised of veterans who have proved themselves as valuable parts of this time.

I could't bring myself to include one year guys like hooker who only played half a season, Ebron who stunk it up in Detroit and could end up being good or bad.  Nelson #4?....he hasnt even played a snap yet...

 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

   I find it difficult to rank players, because so much depends on health and the play of those around them. 

     I’m really interested to see how Geathers plays this year because he could be another (bigger) Bob Sanders. IF he can stay healthy. 

      If we assume these players will stay healthy and play up to their potential:

Luck

Hilton

Nelson

Geathers

Hooker

Kelly

Hines

Sheard

Wilson

Autry

Ebron

 

We may differ in our rankings but when I look at these lists, I’m amazed that people think the Colts are void of talent.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

It's the off-off-season, so let's do some more rankings!  haha

 

Who are the 10 best players on the 2018 Colts?

 

1.  Andrew Luck

2.  TY Hilton

3.  Adam Vinatieri

4.  Quenton Nelson

5.  Ryan Kelly

6.  Jack Doyle

7.  Malik Hooker

8.  Anthony Castanzo

9.  Eric Ebron

10.  Rigoberto Sanchez

Just missed the cut:  Quincy Wilson

 

QB and WR are #1 and #2, so that's good.  But the rest are three OL, two TEs, the K, the P, and only one defensive player...  :help:

 

Anyway, that's my ranking.  Interested to see how ya'll rank 'em!  :thmup:

 

It's a really interesting question and one that would be great to revisit come the end of the season, or even week 8, and see where we stand in terms of opinions at that point.

 

In terms of your list, it's a really solid attempt and I can't find much fault in what is there (although it's obviously all opinions based). I would perhaps take out Sanchez and have Sheard sneak into the top 10 but I think this list could change significantly week to week next year. Would potentially swap Doyle and Kelly too but, aside from that, I like it. :thmup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Luck

2. TY

3. Doyle

4. Vinny

5. Hooker

6. Nelson

7. Kelly

8. Sheard

9. Castanzo

10. Wilson

 

Quite a few could fit into those 8-10 slots though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) QB Andrew Luck

2) WR TY Hliton

3) FS Malik Hooker

4) DE Jabaal Sheard

5) G Quenton Nelson

6) OT Anthony Castanzo

7) K Adam Vinitieri

8) TE Jack Doyle

9) C Ryan Kelly

10) RB Marlon Mack

 

Honorable mention: TE Eric Ebron, LB Darius Leonard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

It's the off-off-season, so let's do some more rankings!  haha

 

Who are the 10 best players on the 2018 Colts?

 

1.  Andrew Luck

2.  TY Hilton

3.  Adam Vinatieri

4.  Quenton Nelson

5.  Ryan Kelly

6.  Jack Doyle

7.  Malik Hooker

8.  Anthony Castanzo

9.  Eric Ebron

10.  Rigoberto Sanchez

Just missed the cut:  Quincy Wilson

 

QB and WR are #1 and #2, so that's good.  But the rest are three OL, two TEs, the K, the P, and only one defensive player...  :help:

 

Anyway, that's my ranking.  Interested to see how ya'll rank 'em!  :thmup:

No love for Sheard and Simon? How does Nelson make top 10 lol he's played not a NFL snap yet lol 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

there probably would be rookies on this list, but its hard for me to put there there now 

 

same is true for hooker hes played like 8 games, and was pretty quiet outside of the three big plays he made.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1 Sheard 

2 Hilton 

3 Doyle 

4 castanzo

5 vinny 

6 Kelly 

7 luck

8 hooker

9 Nelson 

10 Mewhort 

 

i put luck at #7 because he hasn’t played an nfl snap in almost a year and a half so he’s a bit of a wild card. I’m sure after the season is over he will be #1 again

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, rock8591 said:

 

Again, this will change between now, preseason, and the first 2 games of the regular season.

 

By then, Nelson could easily get to #3 on the list, but for IMO, no rookie should be on the list at this point as they've yet to play a single game.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Definitely, the health of Luck is the key a #1 without a doubt, defines our team regardless. It can advance, or set us back years.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 6/16/2018 at 6:27 PM, Nesjan3 said:

Nelson #4?....he hasnt even played a snap yet...

 

9 hours ago, ProblChld32 said:

How does Nelson make top 10 lol he's played not a NFL snap yet lol

 

5 hours ago, rock8591 said:

By then, Nelson could easily get to #3 on the list, but for IMO, no rookie should be on the list at this point as they've yet to play a single game.

 

Come on.  You've seen his film.  You know what he is.  He's a beast, not a bust.

 

Nelson is one of the 10 best players on this team.  He is one of the 5 best players on this team.

 

He's spectacular.  He's tremendous.  He's really something, let me tell you.

you-know-it-i-know-it-everybody-knows-it

 

But fair enough.  I will offer this revised ranking without rookies.

 

1.  Andrew Luck

2.  TY Hilton

3.  Adam Vinatieri

4.  Ryan Kelly

5.  Jack Doyle

6.  Malik Hooker

7.  Anthony Castonzo

8.  Eric Ebron

9.  Rigoberto Sanchez

10.  Quincy Wilson

Just missed the cut:  Jabaal Sheard and John Simon

  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like Castonzo but the guy had so many boooo moments last year but again hopefully with other better cast around him we see him the top 10 kind.
 

Andrew Luck
TY Hilton
Adam Vinatieri
Jabaal Sheard
Clayton Geathers
Quenton Nelson *R
Rigoberto Sanchez
Malik Hooker
Al Woods
Anthony Castonzo
 

I really wanted Simon over Nelson but with scheme changed not sure how effective would he be? Also Kelly there but injury from last year hopefully is back 
 

Anyways GO COLTS!! Love from Canada
Come on NFL starts the season already well not really let us enjoy FIFA 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Andrew Luck

Adam Vinateri

TY Hilton

Ryan Kelly

Jacoby Brissett

Jack Doyle

Anthony Castanzo

Malik Hooker

Sheard

Rigoberto Sanchez

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

luck 

hilton

nelson only rookie i will list, he could be better than ty too

kelly

sheard

doyle

hooker

Vinatieri

Castanzo

brissett 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

 

 

 

Come on.  You've seen his film.  You know what he is.  He's a beast, not a bust.

 

Nelson is one of the 10 best players on this team.  He is one of the 5 best players on this team.

 

He's spectacular.  He's tremendous.  He's really something, let me tell you.

you-know-it-i-know-it-everybody-knows-it

 

But fair enough.  I will offer this revised ranking without rookies.

 

1.  Andrew Luck

2.  TY Hilton

3.  Adam Vinatieri

4.  Ryan Kelly

5.  Jack Doyle

6.  Malik Hooker

7.  Anthony Castonzo

8.  Eric Ebron

9.  Rigoberto Sanchez

10.  Quincy Wilson

Just missed the cut:  Jabaal Sheard and John Simon

 

as of now, Sheard would have to be above Wilson, Ebron, Hooker and I'd even put him ahead of  Doyle.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1.  Andrew Luck

2.  TY Hilton

3.  Andrew Luck

4.  TY Hilton

5.  Andrew Luck

6.  TY Hilton

7.  Andrew Luck

8.  TY Hilton

9.  Andrew Luck

10.  Adam Vinatieri

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.