Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Brett Favre Is Back!


Fx Stryker

Recommended Posts

I personally think Favre is one of the more overrated QBs to play the game....but that's just me

Had he retired after the loss to the Saints I think we would all be singing a different tune. Just my 2 cents.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Had he retired after the loss to the Saints I think we would all be singing a different tune. Just my 2 cents.

Had the Saints not been launching themselves at Favre's legs for $15,000 the Vikings would have won and Brett would be a top 5 QB of all time right now, I loved him on the Pack.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Had he retired after the loss to the Saints I think we would all be singing a different tune. Just my 2 cents.

I wouldn't. Even before that, he never came across to me as being as great a QB as Brady or Peyton. To me, part of the reason he has such high numbers is because he played for so long. He's a gunslinger, as shown by his high INT number

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldn't. Even before that, he never came across to me as being as great a QB as Brady or Peyton. To me, part of the reason he has such high numbers is because he played for so long. He's a gunslinger, as shown by his high INT number

He was a player, plain and simple. A dang good football player. Short on technique, patience and accuracy, he made up for it with desire and drive.

He was great. Not every QB should be directly compared to Brady/Manning.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He was a player, plain and simple. A dang good football player. Short on technique, patience and accuracy, he made up for it with desire and drive.

He was great. Not every QB should be directly compared to Brady/Manning.

I just think he's overrated. Some people want to say he's the best QB of all time, but I don't think he is even in the top 5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just think he's overrated. Some people want to say he's the best QB of all time, but I don't think he is even in the top 5

I think people get too hung up on numbers, stats and this never ending quest to properly file players in order of greatness.

To me, he was one of the most memorable players of the modern era, a very unique QB and just fun to watch. His story was interesting if nothing else. From the clumsy opportunistic beginning to the strange end. On paper, it was an interesting saga. The media did much to nauseate even the most ardent of Favre fans and Favre didn't really help it by waffling like he did.

His was a classic example of inconsistent (some would say inept) skills and impressive drive and heart.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think people get too hung up on numbers, stats and this never ending quest to properly file players in order of greatness.

To me, he was one of the most memorable players of the modern era, a very unique QB and just fun to watch. His story was interesting if nothing else. From the clumsy opportunistic beginning to the strange end. On paper, it was an interesting saga. The media did much to nauseate even the most ardent of Favre fans and Favre didn't really help it by waffling like he did.

His was a classic example of inconsistent (some would say inept) skills and impressive drive and heart.

I agree. His play was inconsistent, but he always had the love for the game and few people had more fun playing it than he did

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No one ever mentions how he is the all-time leader in both INT's thrown and fumbles lost...he is the NFL'S all-time leader in turnovers. Don't get me wrong he made great plays along with all those bone-head ones, but I just don't think he is anywhere around top 5 QB all time. More like somewhere just outside the top 10.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I personally think Favre is one of the more overrated QBs to play the game....but that's just me

You're not the only one who thinks QB Brett Favre is overrated...Personally, while he was still alive, I thought that Titans QB Steve McNair was much tougher than Brett Favre, who played with just as many injuries too, & he never threw as my INT's as the "Gunslinger" did either

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You're not the only one who thinks QB Brett Favre is overrated...Personally, while he was still alive, I thought that Titans QB Steve McNair was much tougher than Brett Favre, who played with just as many injuries too, & he never threw as my INT's as the "Gunslinger" did either

McNair only got to one super bowl and after that really wasn't as successful in comparison to Farve. While Farve did make some boneheaded throws he also made some amazing throws to match the boneheaded ones.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

McNair only got to one super bowl and after that really wasn't as successful in comparison to Farve. While Farve did make some boneheaded throws he also made some amazing throws to match the boneheaded ones.

Yes, Brett Favre made some amazing throws in his nearly 20 year NFL career, but he had 2 enormous downfalls: 1. Throwing the ball into double or even triple coverage in NFC Championship Games & 2. Failing to realize that throwing the ball away & out of bounds in order to live another down or offensive play series.

I live in WI Blackhawk4. I saw cry baby "I'm too good to practice" #4 1st hand. I would take Steve McNair over Brett Favre in their prime any day of the week. #4 is HIGHLY OVERRATED PLAIN & SIMPLE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, Brett Favre made some amazing throws in his nearly 20 year NFL career, but he had 2 enormous downfalls: 1. Throwing the ball into double or even triple coverage in NFC Championship Games & 2. Failing to realize that throwing the ball away & out of bounds in order to live another down or offensive play series.

I live in WI Blackhawk4. I saw cry baby "I'm too good to practice" #4 1st hand. I would take Steve McNair over Brett Favre in their prime any day of the week. #4 is HIGHLY OVERRATED PLAIN & SIMPLE.

Winning a superbowl and going to another the year shows Farve wasn't completely overrated. He might be overrated in some areas, but unlike McNair he actually got results. McNair never got close to getting back the SB after they lost to the Rams. Farve at least got back to his conference Championship multiple times. Farve might be a bit overrated, but I'll take overrated winning a SB over a solid NFL career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Winning a superbowl and going to another the year shows Farve wasn't completely overrated. He might be overrated in some areas, but unlike McNair he actually got results. McNair never got close to getting back the SB after they lost to the Rams. Farve at least got back to his conference Championship multiple times. Farve might be a bit overrated, but I'll take overrated winning a SB over a solid NFL career.

Look, both McNair & Favre are highly talented quarterbacks no question. Both men took their fair share of NFL hits, bumps, & bruises, over their respective careers. I guess we can just agree to respectfully disagree here. Jim Kelly never won any Superbowl rings either & I would never slight or diminish his clutch gene because of that minor fact. Steve McNair was incredibly smart, tough, & he came within an inch of winning a Superbowl Ring in 1999 against the Rams...The window between Superbowl winners & losers is often a razor thin margin. Winning a ring or not is 1 of many factors to consider when evaluating top flight NFL field generals in my humble opinion. Thank you for your thoughts on this matter Blackhawk4.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Final edition, call it a less penalty driven team draft.   The Colts trade up on Day 1.   Round 1 a)       WR Rome Odunze (Washington) – led all receivers in CFB in pass interference call draws with 9 in 2023. b)      LCB Quinyon Mitchell (Toledo) – Only had 3 penalties in the last two seasons. c)       WLB Edgerrin Cooper (Texas A&M)   Round 2  a)      OL Cooper Beebe (Kansas State) – Jack of all trades OL No matter where Cooper Beebe lines up, he produces elite play. At right tackle in 2020, he was a PFF honorable mention All-Big 12 honoree. As a left tackle in 2021, he was named first-team All-Big 12. In 2022 at left guard, Beebe was a second-team All-American.  Beebe's 94.0 pass-blocking grade over the past two seasons led all offensive linemen in college football. During that span, he didn’t allow a sack on 770 pass-blocking snaps.  Beebe is the only FBS guard who ranks in the top five in both PB (4th) and RB (2nd).  He still hasn’t allowed a sack since the 2020 season. 2023 earned college football midseason all-America First Team.   Very few penalties throughout his career. b)      FS/NCB Javon Bullard (Georgia) – only had 5 penalties in college. c)       SS Jaden Hicks (Washington State) – 2023 PFF TOW 2 honors. Leader on defense that off to a strong start for 2023 earning a 90.1 PFF grade in coverage with one interception after 3 weeks, dropped another but forced 4 incompletions.  Great field and anticipation skills along with ball production.  Versatile can align up in FS, SS, LB, or nickel.  Only had 3 penalties in 2023.   Round 3 a)       CB Khyree Jackson (Oregon) – 2023 PFF TOW 4 honors.  Jackson had a decent Senior Bowl Week and is best in Zone Coverage. Jackson’s got excellent height we covet at 6’3” with great weight at 203 pounds, with ideal arms 32” and the span of 78” and good 4.44s-Forty.  Only committed 4 penalties in 2023. b)       DB Dadrion Taylor-Demerson (Texas Tech) - only 7 career penalties with 200 tackles, 57 stops, 11 pressues, 3 sacks, 16 passes defended, and 10 interceptions. c)       LCB Kris Abrams-Draine (Missouri) - 2023 PFF TOW 4 honors.  After 6 games leads all FBS players with 8 PBUs (1.8 PDPG) while adding 3 INTs.   10 combined interceptions and (7) forced incompletions are the most among Power Five CBs while only allowing 11 catches all season. 2023 college football midseason all-America First Team.  His 86.8 coverage grade is 5th highest in the FBS allowing just 107 passing yards and 11 receptions on the season. d)      SWR Malik Washington (Virginia) – Josh Downs 2.0 and only committed 4 total penalties in five years (52 career games).   Round 4 a)      RG Zak Zinter (Michigan) 2022 PFF Week 5, 11, 12 TOW Honors. 2023 earned college football midseason all-America Second Team. Wasn’t called for a single penalty on 649 snaps. b)      FS Cole Bishop (Utah) junior if he declares – After 5 weeks in 2023, targeted 13 times, 4 catches allowed, 2 INTs, and 4.8 passer rating allowed.  Had a decent Senior Bowl week. Ejected for a targeting penalty.  In 3 years only allowed 7 penalties. c)       RB Isaac Guerendo (Louisville) – 9.97 RAS   Round 5 a)       WLB Michael Barrett (Michigan) PFF TOW 7 honors, round 5 projection had an outstanding year with an overall 90.6 defense grade only behind Edgerrin Cooper.  An 82.5 run defense grade, a 93.5 pass rush grade, and a 77.0 coverage grade.  Didn’t commit a defensive penalty in more than 1800 defensive snaps. b)      SS Malik Mustapha (Wake Forest) – Zero career penalties c)       SS Kitan Oladapo (Oregon St) – only 4 accepted penalties in final 30 games.   Round 6 a)       Edge Jalyx Hunt (Houston Christian) b)      WR Ryan Flournoy (SE Missouri St) c)       Edge Javontae Jean-Baptiste (ND)   Round 7 a)      LG/C Michael Jurgens (Wake Forest) – Only one of two guards in the Power Five with an 80.0 PB and RB grades.   After 10 weeks has an 86.5 PFF grade with his 90.0 run-blocking grade is nearly 5 points higher than the next-best guard.  2023 earned college football midseason all-America Second Team.  Only committed 3 penalties all season in 2023. b)      OC Matt Lee Miami (FL) 2023 earned college football midseason all-America Honorable Mention. PFF TOW 9 honors.  In 2022 he had an 82.5 overall grade with a 90.6 PB and 80.6 RB grade.  As of Oct 15th, Lee is the highest graded center in all FBS earning an 82.7 PFF grade.  Only allowed 2 penalties in 2022 on 1059 offensive snaps given up only four pressures and no sacks. c)       MLB Dallas Gant (Toledo) - 2023 college football midseason all-America Honorable Mention
    • Holy cow!     And then shows he should have been picked top 5 
    • This goes against everything Ballard would do, however it would be something that Irsay would love to do as he is a romantic. Probability is very very low though.
    • This would make us much better and talk about excitement, we really haven't been legit good since 2020 when Rivers surprisingly played good and Taylor was up and coming, + Leonard was a maniac back then. I have had tremendous patience with this team and Ballard. It's time to crap or get off the pot, being average gets old after a while. This fanbase is used to us making the playoffs every year, when it hasn't happened in 3 seasons, time to do something.
    • Boston takes an L at home against a Butlerless Heat team. I can't stand Boston, this is too funny.
  • Members

    • OhioColt

      OhioColt 408

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Behle

      Behle 102

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Aaron86

      Aaron86 440

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Yoshinator

      Yoshinator 9,191

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • crazycolt1

      crazycolt1 10,264

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...