Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Jay Kirk Baseball Thread since 2017: The 2020 season, Nationals Repeat?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 15.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • 2006Coltsbestever

    5809

  • NFLfan

    2277

  • Jay Kirk

    2230

  • PrincetonTiger

    1837

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Just wanted to let everyone know I still feel healthy, just working a lot. Hozer and I miss doing play by play of Cubs games on here and commenting on the games. Everything will be back to normal soon

I just got an anonymous call on my phone which I usually don't answer when I don't see a number I recognize. I answered it and the person said SOX and hung up.  I have no clue who it was  

As most of you know, I'm a Cardinals fan.  But you don't know that at one time I was a Cubs fan.  This was in the early 1980's while I was in college and got cable TV.  Our TV provider had WGN and sin

Posted Images

6 hours ago, HOZER said:

After all the low scoring games they had this shortened season, I wasn’t surprised, pretty much picked up where the left of the previous season. Somethings broke.....hope they get it fixed next season. Already seeing talks of Epstein finishing his contract next season then moving on, hope he hasn’t already checked out!!!

 

6 hours ago, Barry Sears said:

For you Cubs fans...didn't know if you saw this - 

 

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2020/10/theo-epstein-discusses-cubs-future.html

Ya, the likelihood is he will move on after next season. He has always said 10 years in one spot is the right time to leave. Did it in Boston, and next year is his 10th year. 

 

I do not believe he will checkout. He is trying to prepare the organization for the next move though. The thought is Hoyer will take over for him next year as the President. No one knows what Theo will do, or if he will continue to stay in a organization. 

From the non-Cubs fans perspective, what would you think if he became the Commissioner? Everyone hates Manfred, and Theo is articulate and thoughtful and actually likes the game of baseball

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Barry Sears said:

For you Cubs fans...didn't know if you saw this - 

 

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2020/10/theo-epstein-discusses-cubs-future.html

Yeah I have feeling next season will be his last in Chicago. Just a vibe I get. Change is good sometimes, Maddon is a great example of that as I thought David Ross has been solid for the team so far. Maddon looked like he had worn his welcome with the players. We need to work on getting a better hitting coach IMO because something isn't right there. I can't really complain because it has been a hell of a 6 season span overall since 2015 - 3 Division Titles, 5 Playoff appearances, 3 NLCS appearances, and we won our 1st WS in 108 years in 2016. It is what it is.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/6/2020 at 5:26 PM, 2006Coltsbestever said:

Yeah I have feeling next season will be his last in Chicago. Just a vibe I get. Change is good sometimes, Maddon is a great example of that as I thought David Ross has been solid for the team so far. Maddon looked like he had worn his welcome with the players. We need to work on getting a better hitting coach IMO because something isn't right there. I can't really complain because it has been a hell of a 6 season span overall since 2015 - 3 Division Titles, 5 Playoff appearances, 3 NLCS appearances, and we won our 1st WS in 108 years in 2016. It is what it is.

Theo has always said 10 years is the time to change organizations/leave one. After that, you dont add as much. 

 

And it is hard to say it is the Hitting Coach, we've had 3 since 2017, normally that also can mean that it is the players not taking too, or even too much change

Link to post
Share on other sites

Two more MLB Hall of Famers have died. Former Yankees pitcher Whitey Ford died last week; later this month he would have celebrated his 92nd birthday.

 

Former Reds second baseman Joe Morgan died today at age 77. 

 

May they both rest in peace. 

  • Sad 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, NFLfan said:

Two more MLB Hall of Famers have died. Former Yankees pitcher Whitey Ford died last week; later this month he would have celebrated his 92nd birthday.

 

Former Reds second baseman Joe Morgan died today at age 77. 

 

May they both rest in peace. 

I used to imitate Whitey Ford as a young baseball player in the little league. RIP Mr. Ford

While I was not a Reds fan at the time, the Big Red Machine was real.  RIP Mr. Morgan.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, NFLfan said:

Two more MLB Hall of Famers have died. Former Yankees pitcher Whitey Ford died last week; later this month he would have celebrated his 92nd birthday.

 

Former Reds second baseman Joe Morgan died today at age 77. 

 

May they both rest in peace. 

 

It's been a sad past few weeks with the passing of Seaver, Brock, Gibson, Ford and Morgan.  Hits home even more since I saw all of them, with the exception of Ford, play in person and many times on TV.

Rays up 2-0!!

 

 

tampa-bay-rays.jpg

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

Dodgers lose again, down 2-0 in series vs the Braves. Doesn't look good again for them.

I was hoping for a Braves/Rays WS once I saw the LCS matchups. I kinda enjoy watching the Dodgers acting like the Colts team of Manning and being great in the regular season but not in Post. Also of course want to see the Astriks lose.

 

I also realized, all 4 teams in the LCS, I had planned to see in the season normally. Was gonna go to FL teams, TX teams, ATL, and CA teams before I got sick and Covid

Link to post
Share on other sites

Rays up 3-0!!  One win from the World Series.  I really enjoy watching this team play...great defense, awesome pitching and timely hitting.  They've knocked off the Billion-Dollar Yankees and about to eliminate the Cheatin' Astros.

 

 

tampa-bay-rays.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, PuntersArePeopleToo said:

I did not think we would get a Game 7 in the AL and Game 6 in NL should be interesting. Did anybody catch the games? I missed today since I was moving

It would not shock me at all if it ended up Dodgers vs Astros and Dodgers get their revenge. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

It would not shock me at all if it ended up Dodgers vs Astros and Dodgers get their revenge. 

The fact both series went to a game 7 is surprising. I truly did not think both leagues would end up doing that after the way the series started

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought I had done it here prior to the playoffs, but I can't find a post.  Anyway, I had entered a contest on MLB to fill out a bracket and had the Rays and Dodgers in the World Series.

 

I think the Rays win in 6 games...the Dodgers always manage to choke in the WS and I'm thinking it will happen again.

 

It's also a match up of a low team payroll vs. one of, if not the highest team payroll.  I know the Rays will be the underdog, but I believe they prefer that, honestly.

 

LET'S GO RAYS!!!!

 

 

tampa-bay-rays.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Barry Sears said:

I thought I had done it here prior to the playoffs, but I can't find a post.  Anyway, I had entered a contest on MLB to fill out a bracket and had the Rays and Dodgers in the World Series.

 

I think the Rays win in 6 games...the Dodgers always manage to choke in the WS and I'm thinking it will happen again.

 

It's also a match up of a low team payroll vs. one of, if not the highest team payroll.  I know the Rays will be the underdog, but I believe they prefer that, honestly.

 

LET'S GO RAYS!!!!

 

 

tampa-bay-rays.jpg

I hope the Rays win but the Dodgers are due. We will see?

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, landrus13 said:

Rays and Dodgers are tied 2-2 in the WS. Rays won game 4 last night in a wild fashion. Anyone else see it?

I missed it...I was at a soccer playoff game that night, but watched the highlights and it was an incredible game!!

 

Rays lose last night, so their backs are against the wall, but I would not be surprised if they force a game 7.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Barry Sears said:

I missed it...I was at a soccer playoff game that night, but watched the highlights and it was an incredible game!!

 

Rays lose last night, so their backs are against the wall, but I would not be surprised if they force a game 7.

It looks bad but you never know. Dodgers were due so it doesn't surprise me.

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, PuntersArePeopleToo said:

The MLB Season could end tonight, and then we can go back to Players and Owners fighting. It is highly likely that will happen based off reports

Eh! Why should they be any different? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Congrats to the Dodgers...they finally won a WS after so many unsuccessful tries the past few years.  I saw someplace that I think it is Betts and Kershaw make the same yearly salary combined than the entire Rays roster!!!  I guess you can buy a championship if you have enough money.

 

The Rays proved you can acquire and develop young talent, sell them on your system and approach to the game and be successful without having billionaires on your roster.

 

Well, it was the most unusual season in the history of the game, so here's hoping 2021 will be normal again although the chances aren't looking great right now.

 

Enjoyed all the chatter this season and look forward to some Hot Stove talk in the coming weeks.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, PuntersArePeopleToo said:

And a final covid positive test. Turner then acted reckless after being confirmed positive. MLB investigating including him staying on the field after security told him he needed to quarantine 

 

That was irresponsible. This guy here lambasted him:

 

https://sports.yahoo.com/justin-turners-selfish-celebration-is-a-symptom-of-a-much-larger-problem-152422116.html
"Justin Turner was selfish in wanting to celebrate after testing positive for COVID-19, but it's a symptom of a much larger problem in America."

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, PuntersArePeopleToo said:

@NFLfan You see MLB is set to approve the sell tomorrow I think? And de Blasio is trying to work a way to deny it

 

I did not know that. I have been avoiding the news, as everything is so negative. Do you have a source? I want the sale to be approved. Why would the mayor be against it? Why does he have a say in it? 

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, NFLfan said:

 

I did not know that. I have been avoiding the news, as everything is so negative. Do you have a source? I want the sale to be approved. Why would the mayor be against it? Why does he have a say in it? 

 

@PuntersArePeopleToo I read it. Apparently Steve Cohen had pleaded guilty to insider trading. 

 

Quote

At issue appears to be Cohen’s shady financial dealings in the past. According to the Post, language in the Citi Field lease prevents “'[a]ny Person that has been convicted in a criminal proceeding for a felony or any crime involving moral turpitude or that is an organized crime figure' from leasing Citi Field." Cohen, as you may remember, pleaded guilty to insider trading charges in 2013 and paid $1.8 billion in fines, but never faced jail time

.

 

Link

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, NFLfan said:

 

I did not know that. I have been avoiding the news, as everything is so negative. Do you have a source? I want the sale to be approved. Why would the mayor be against it? Why does he have a say in it? 

 

2 hours ago, NFLfan said:

 

@PuntersArePeopleToo I read it. Apparently Steve Cohen had pleaded guilty of insider trading. 

 

.

 

Link

This is where I get the news https://www.bleachernation.com/cubs/2020/10/29/report-the-mayor-of-new-york-city-will-do-everything-he-can-to-stop-the-sale-of-the-mets/

 

Cubs Blog, guy also use to be lawyer so sometimes can add that take. 

 

And it is correct he has, but he has also been minority owner of Mets already. He has a little take on it

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, PuntersArePeopleToo said:

 

This is where I get the news https://www.bleachernation.com/cubs/2020/10/29/report-the-mayor-of-new-york-city-will-do-everything-he-can-to-stop-the-sale-of-the-mets/

 

Cubs Blog, guy also use to be lawyer so sometimes can add that take. 

 

And it is correct he has, but he has also been minority owner of Mets already. He has a little take on it

 

It sounds more like a column rather than a report. The author is saying that the mayor is trying to squeeze money out of Cohen. That is speculation. He also wrote that Cohen's company, not Cohen, was guilty of insider trading. It sounds like this guy is finding ways to defend Cohen. He also admits that he is cynical. Whenever I read something like the following (italicized), I don't take it seriously.  He sounds a bit like Mike Florio (Pro Football Talk) who makes assumptions and presents them as fact.

 

I don’t know what it would be – better lease terms for Citi Field, some investment agreement on real estate, or even something shadier – but it seems like any time a political entity has a way to block, or threaten to block, a company from doing something major, they squeeze out those extra pennies.

 

I want the sale to happen and I am not sure why the Mayor is involved. But this guy is not reporting -- he is giving his opinion and making the public believe that it is a fact. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, NFLfan said:

 

It sounds more like a column rather than a report. The author is saying that the mayor is trying to squeeze money out of Cohen. That is speculation. He also wrote that Cohen's company, not Cohen, was guilty of insider trading. It sounds like this guy is finding ways to defend Cohen. He also admits that he is cynical. Whenever I read something like the following (italicized), I don't take it seriously.  He sounds a bit like Mike Florio (Pro Football Talk) who makes assumptions and presents them as fact.

 

I don’t know what it would be – better lease terms for Citi Field, some investment agreement on real estate, or even something shadier – but it seems like any time a political entity has a way to block, or threaten to block, a company from doing something major, they squeeze out those extra pennies.

 

I want the sale to happen and I am not sure why the Mayor is involved. But this guy is not reporting -- he is giving his opinion and making the public believe that it is a fact. 

He was doing sorta of a mix, between reporting what is being reported and give his opinion as to why it may be happening. It was cause the land for Citi Field is public and due to the company having the guilty plea the NYC Mayor can look into and potential deny.  And while it was his company, he was in charge still at the time. 

 

Either way, de Blasio gave approval after MLB approved so the sell is official. 

 

 

Also did you see this 

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, PuntersArePeopleToo said:

He was doing sorta of a mix, between reporting what is being reported and give his opinion as to why it may be happening. It was cause the land for Citi Field is public and due to the company having the guilty plea the NYC Mayor can look into and potential deny.  And while it was his company, he was in charge still at the time. 

 

Either way, de Blasio gave approval after MLB approved so the sell is official. 

 

 

Also did you see this 

 

 

No, I had not seen it. I'm trying to stay away from the news for my state of mind. There is just so much negativity. But thanks for sharing it. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Cardinals decided to decline the $12M option on Wong. Bought him out for $1M. He's now a free agent. Yadi and Wainwright are also FAs. They both wanna play together. Atlanta has appeared as a suitor for Wainwright, That would make a ton of sense on both sides. 

 

MLB free agency started today at 5pm. I think it'll be quiet for awhile until we see what the market is gonna look like. It's a really bad year to be a FA. Most teams are wanting to shed payroll. Not sure how many are willing to spend to try and improve. I think most guys are gonna sign their qualifying offers if they were offered one. Trevor Bauer was offered one by the Reds today. I know I saw a few others, but I can't remember who. I'll try to look for an article.

Link to post
Share on other sites

https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/mlb-free-agency-six-players-receive-qualifying-offers-including-yankees-dj-lemahieu-reds-trevor-bauer/

 

Trevor Bauer - Reds

DJ LeMahieu - Yankees

Kevin Gausman - Giants

JT Realmuto - Phillies

George Springer - Astros

Marcus Stroman - Mets

 

The QO in 2020 is set at $18.9M. I'd definitely be signing that this year with the market likely to be poor. Probably not gonna get that kinda money on the market this year. Unless the Mets with Cohen or the Yankees or Dodgers decide to spend more. I feel like the Dodgers have a ton of money tied up already so I don't see them as big players.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • No beers for me. I haven't had an alcohol related drink in over 30 years.  Now I may hit the bullet a couple of times? 
    • Nail biter for several reasons. Pre-game beers may be needed for the nerves.
    • If I had to guess, Rivers will be back on the books.
    • Typically to be a HOFer you have to be dominant for ~a decade.  Leonard and Q are ~2.5 years into their careers (about a quarter of the way there).  Leonard has not played 16 games in a season yet, which is somewhat concerning to me.  This year, while he and Q both look very good, I don't think either is deserving of an all-pro award.     So yes, very impressive that Q has been 1st team all-pro 2x and Leonard has a 1st and 2nd team all-pro under his belt.  That is very rare (Gale Sayers and Dick Butkus are the only other 2 teammates who made 1st team all-pro as rookies).  In no way am I knocking Q or Leonard, they're both critical pieces to this team and at the elite level in the NFL at their respective positions.  Labeling them as HOFers this early into their career is a bit of a stretch, though -- let's give them another 3.5-4 years to see if they're still healthy and performing at an all-pro level.  They're certainly off to a good start, but there are a lot of players who have made 2 all-pro teams in their career and are not HOFers (heck, LeRoy Butler was a 4x 1st-team all-pro and has been eligible for HOF induction for ~15 years and isn't in, Steve Wisniewski was 2x 1st team, 6x 2nd team and not in, etc.).  Also, the vast majority of HOFers were not first team all-pro as rookies.  These 2020 rookies are in perhaps the strangest year of the modern era, with limited training camps, no pre-season games, missing games due to COVID (see Taylor), etc.... Pittman, Taylor, Blackmon have all shown flashes of excellence and all have had their own obstacles on top of a weird off-season as rookies (Blackmon coming off injury getting thrown into starting line-up due to HOoker going down, Taylor having Mack go down and now missing a game on the COVID list, and Pittman with compartment syndrome).   No reason to expect any of them to be HOFers, but also no reason why if they stay healthy and continue improving that we don't start talking about them being at the HOF level in 4-5 more years.     In all honesty, it is way too early to tell if this class will stack up to the 2018 class.  We really won't know for another 4-5 years when we see which guys from the 2018 draft are given/not given contract extensions and when the current class is at the same point.      As far as just judging by rookie season alone, it's not unreasonable to think it won't be another >30 years before we see rookie teammates on the first team all-pro squad together (believe Butkus and Sayers was 1965).  That said, aside from Q and Leonard we got solid contributions from Smith and Hines on O, saw solid ST contributions from Franklin and Adams (with Franklin playing a minimal D role as a fill-in starter 2 games and Adams basically invisible on D), got very little from Turay and Lewis and basically nothing from Fountain, Cain.  Wilkins was OK as a 3rd RB and OK as a kick returner and our only UDFA who did anything noteworthy wad Odum as a solid STer and with a couple decent starts when he was needed due to injury.   Overall we had 4 of 11 picks (or 4 of 12 rookies who contributed) who really didn't do much as rookies (33% vs. 66% percent who contributed significantly in some aspect of the game).     So in short, the 2018 class as rookies had 2 studs (Q and Leonard), 2 guys who contributed solidly on O (Hines and Smith), 4 solid ST contributors (Odum, Adams, Franklin, Wilkins), 4 guys who really did nothing (Turay, Lewis, Cain, Fountain).   Three years later, we still have 2 studs (Q and Leonard), 1 very solid RT (Smith),  2 guys who are doing well in a RB rotation (Hines and Wilkins), 2 unknowns on the DL (Lewis and Turay - by far Lewis' best year, but he hasn't really been great), and 3 solid STers (Odum, Franklin, Adams and 4 if you count Hines).   Then we have Cain (gone) and Fountain (still pretty much doing nothing).  Again, about 2/3 of these guys are still contributing solidly in some way on the team, with the other 1/3 still unknown or not doing much (Turay started to come on last year and Lewis is recently coming on this year, so if they both continue, we may see 83% of that class as solid contributors moving forward).     The 2020 class as rookies -- we have 1 borderline stud (Blackmon), 2 very solid  O contributors (Taylor and Pittman), 3 very solid ST contributors (Rodgers, Glasgow, Blankenship), 1 guy who has been OK in a pinch as a backup or extra lineman (Pinter), 1 guy who has made the active roster after mostly being on the PS (Windsor - IMO, he's about as valuable to this year's team as Lewis was at the same point in 2018), 1 guy who has been very solid the past few weeks (Harris) and 2 guys (Eason and Patmon) who have been on the roster but inactive.  That puts us at 7 or 8 guys who have been solid contributors out of 11 as rookies (63% or 72%) and 3 or 4 guys (Eason, Patmon, Windsor, maybe Pinter) for a total of 27-36% of rookies who are not doing much at this point of the season (this could change moving forward if Pinter has to fill in for Kelly for a while and/or if Windsor takes on a bigger role down the stretch, it is not coincidence to me that he was activated the week we cut Day).  So right now, we're looking at 30-40% of our rookies not producing too much, but this could change to 20% (assuming Eason and Patmon don't play this year and Pinter and Windsor see increasing roles).     Overall, Ballard is >60% in both drafts in terms of having productive players as rookies.  It is very unlikely we'll see any team have 2 first team all-pros as rookies again in the near future (or ever).  We may see a DROY from the 2020 draft class like we saw in the 2018 draft class on this team.  Both Leonard and Blackmon have been criticized for being picked too early, etc... Ballard has proven those doubters wrong.     When we look back in a few years, if Eason is a franchise QB and Pittman and Patmon are a solid WR duo (perhaps Harris is still performing well), Taylor is a bellcow >1,200 yard rusher, Blackmon is an all-pro, Pinter is a starter (RG or RT), Rodgers is giving us a TD or more per year as a return guy, Glasgow is a solid STer, Hot Rod is a probowl K, and Windsor is still in the DL rotation and this draft could be better than the 2018 draft.  Again, too early to tell.  If we want to consider Buckner a part of the 2020 draft (the 13th pick), I think there's a good argument that the 2020 draft will exceed the 2018 draft.   Also, something to keep in mind -- our team was in very bad shape when Ballard took over.  In 2017, he was drafting for a team with a coach we pretty much all knew was going to be gone in a year.  In 2018, it was a lot easier to get significant playing time on the roster (at least IMO) because it was so bad.  In a short time, Ballard has put a lot of solid pieces together and this team is a much more difficult team to make the final roster, let alone get significant playing time as a rookie.     I agree with you on your Blackmon assessment.  It'd be cool if he got DROY... and he has made several key plays at critical times (e.g., forced fumble in OT last week)... but he's not perfect.  TBH, I think it was kind of disappointing that the long ball from Rodgers to MVS was not broken up near the end of the 4th quarter.  Blackmon was a step or two behind, but I think most very high end safeties would have broken that play up.     McDaniels dissing Ballard may have actually made Ballard's job easier.  I think Reich was the right guy for this team and after seeing Patricia fired from DET, and looking at stats of Belichick's coordinators who went on to head coaching jobs, they have a pretty poor track record.     Yes, I think Q and Leonard's play has been solid this year, but I don't think either of them deserve to be all-pros (at least not 1st team).  Won't be shocked if Q gets selected though, mainly because of his name and the fact Baldy and other reporters like to really focus on his positive plays.  He's been beaten more this year than I can remember (which is still not a lot) and has more holds than I remember in his first 2 years.     Agree, the most deserving of all-pro on this roster is Buckner (though, I can't see him getting the nod due to lack of stats and the fact that Donald and other interior DL in the league are playing at very high levels).  Second most deserving, IMO, is Hot Rod -- he's likely to be leading the league in points scored after tomorrow's game.  Just hit a big game winner.  Has a solid chance of ending the season >90% FG made and leading the league in points scored -- it'd be hard to vote against him for at least 2nd team K if he finishes the year >90% FG made and leads league in points.
  • Members

    • Happy2BeHere

      Happy2BeHere 813

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Coltpwr

      Coltpwr 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • The Peytonator

      The Peytonator 2,732

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • crazycolt1

      crazycolt1 14,224

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • SicWhitted

      SicWhitted 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • tate

      tate 2

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • bravo4460

      bravo4460 1,770

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • NewColtsFan

      NewColtsFan 21,814

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Stephen

      Stephen 2,454

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...