Who Should Win The Mvp This Year?

[bap1331]

Im all for Peyton! Even NFL Magazine made an article on why Peyton should be MVP.

No one has really impressed this year overall. If you can think of anyone who has carried their whole team around, please name them! Possibly Tim Tebow?

[Dustin]

Defiantly Brees but Rodgers will win because his team is 12-0 and he QB's "America's Sweetheart"

[jbaron04]

who is the colts mvp this years

[Andy]

If Manning doesn't come back and play a game, it's Rodgers, easily. Look at his stats and his impact.

[Andy]

who is the colts mvp this years

A couple of players come to mind, like Pierre Garcon, Pat Angerer and Antoine Bethea. I would say Antoine Bethea.

[MTC]

Aaron Rodgers or Peyton Manning. Either one.

[Blue Horseshoe]

who is the colts mvp this years

Pat McAfee

[bap1331]

alright...who voted for Aaron Rodgers??!!

[Dustin]

Wow, 5 votes for Peyton. That's completely unbiased.

[cokomenow]

Where is Eli Manning in this discussion? I would argue that behind Peyton, and if not for Rodger's stats, Eli is the most valuable to his team right now

[GoColts8818]

Where is Eli Manning in this discussion? I would argue that behind Peyton, and if not for Rodger's stats, Eli is the most valuable to his team right now

Eli is having a career year without question and backing up his comments about being in the class of Brady that he took so much heat for and while his numbers aren't getting as much attention it's still hard to argue with the job Rodgers is doing with Green Bay. Eli should get more pub but he probably wont.

[Blue Horseshoe]

I think Brees does more than Rodgers but Rodgers has a better team.

Honestly, I am getting tired of hearing about Rodgers "Greatest Quarterback Season Ever" when my earlier prediction that the man would not break a single major record looks like it will be correct. He will not break the touchdown record (or even equal Marino's 48), he will not eclipse Marino's 5084 yardage record, he will not beat Brees completion % record, and he will not beat Manning's Passer Rating record.

[chad72]

I voted other. MJD is to the Jaguars what Peyton is to the Colts. Hands down. "Bowling ball of butcher knives" is what Raheem Morris calls him, fitting term .

At least MJD should get offensive player of the year award, if not anything else.

[ViriLudant]

Here's a random one:

Rob Gronkowski.

Best tight end in the NFL, shattered the single-season TD record for a TE, and will increase it by 4-5 before the season is over.

A darkhouse, obviously, but dear god, the guy's phenomenal and only 22 years old!

[GoColts8818]

Here's a random one:

Rob Gronkowski.

Best tight end in the NFL, shattered the single-season TD record for a TE, and will increase it by 4-5 before the season is over.

A darkhouse, obviously, but dear god, the guy's phenomenal and only 22 years old!

Still not having a better season than Rodgers who is on pace for his own record setting season and leading an undefeated team to boot not to mention he has the advantage of being a QB over being a TE.

[Go Blue Horseshoe]

Its gotta be Rodgers. This guy has been simply amazing all year long.