Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

cjrulli

Brian Bil\lick on Mike & Mike

Recommended Posts

Greeny and Bilick sending some major love to the Colts this morning on Mike & Mike. Golic brought up the point of out of the three AFC elite QB's (Luck, Manning, Rivers) which team has a defense that will carry them the furthest.

 

Bilick said on paper Denver has the best defense with all of the new acquisitions they have made. However he went on to say that the Colts have quietly and most arguably the best defense out of the three. Praising Manusky for his scheme and play calling while also bringing up how well the offense is keeping the ball.

 

Greeny also argued that if he had a chance to mulligan his pick to win the AFC he would switch it to the Colts at this time.

 

Their observations and points are some of the exact things we've spoken about on the forums, but it was nice to hear Bilick show us some love. I enjoy his insights and usually believe what he's talking about.

 

If I can find the segment I will post the link.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, just think after the first two games there were calls out to fire all the coaches and the GM. Funny how some of the armchair QBs, coaches and GMs only think they know what's going on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Greeny and Bilick sending some major love to the Colts this morning on Mike & Mike. Golic brought up the point of out of the three AFC elite QB's (Luck, Manning, Rivers) which team has a defense that will carry them the furthest.

 

Bilick said on paper Denver has the best defense with all of the new acquisitions they have made. However he went on to say that the Colts have quietly and most arguably the best defense out of the three. Praising Manusky for his scheme and play calling while also bringing up how well the offense is keeping the ball.

 

Greeny also argued that if he had a chance to mulligan his pick to win the AFC he would switch it to the Colts at this time.

 

Their observations and points are some of the exact things we've spoken about on the forums, but it was nice to hear Bilick show us some love. I enjoy his insights and usually believe what he's talking about.

 

If I can find the segment I will post the link.

Bilick definitely seems like o n e of the smarter football analysts out there, at least out of all the knuckleheads on NFLN...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, just think after the first two games there were calls out to fire all the coaches and the GM. Funny how some of the armchair QBs, coaches and GMs only think they know what's going on.

As you know, coaches should always be fired for the number 1 offense and number 3 defense.

 

Our offense is so predictable that that the fans know the call and somehow some of the best DCs in the sport don't :)

 

Need I bring out the sarcasm symbol???  :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bilick definitely seems like o n e of the smarter football analysts out there, at least out of all the knuckleheads on NFLN...

I honestly do not understand why he has never been a head coach again.....I think the owners feel intimidated by his intelligence.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I honestly do not understand why he has never been a head coach again.....I think the owners feel intimidated by his intelligence.

Probably because he was touted as an offensive genius coming out of Minnesota , and won on defense in Baltimore. He kept Matt Cavanaugh around too long as offensive co ordinator, insisted on drafting Kyle Boller, got rid of Trent Dilfer and went with Elvis Gerbac the year after the Super Bowl, and when Gerbac failed, did not put in Randall Cunningham in the Pittsburgh playoff game in 2001.

I like Brian, and will always like him as an ex Raven, but look at his record compared to Harbaugh. Harbaugh is a much more consistent coach record wise.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably because he was touted as an offensive genius coming out of Minnesota , and won on defense in Baltimore. He kept Matt Cavanaugh around too long as offensive co ordinator, insisted on drafting Kyle Boller, got rid of Trent Dilfer and went with Elvis Gerbac the year after the Super Bowl, and when Gerbac failed, did not put in Randall Cunningham in the Pittsburgh playoff game in 2001.

I like Brian, and will always like him as an ex Raven, but look at his record compared to Harbaugh. Harbaugh is a much more consistent coach record wise.

I was hoping you would respond.  Thank you.  I think having Qzzie Newsome does not hurt either

 

I really like Billick  He and Mike Martz were both "Evil Geniuses.'   :)

 

Edit:  I like John Harbaugh too...moreso than Jim...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably because he was touted as an offensive genius coming out of Minnesota , and won on defense in Baltimore. He kept Matt Cavanaugh around too long as offensive co ordinator, insisted on drafting Kyle Boller, got rid of Trent Dilfer and went with Elvis Gerbac the year after the Super Bowl, and when Gerbac failed, did not put in Randall Cunningham in the Pittsburgh playoff game in 2001.

I like Brian, and will always like him as an ex Raven, but look at his record compared to Harbaugh. Harbaugh is a much more consistent coach record wise.

 

Harbaugh  has also had Flacco his entire tenure.  I read once that Kyle Boller essentially cost Billick his job with Balt.  Billick was convinced he could turn Boller into a franchise QB but for whatever reason it never worked out.  

 

I've always admired Billick and of all the "retread" coaches, he's the one I'd most like to see back on the sidelines. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bilick is one smart former coach.  I'm impressed with his analysis.

Yes, after game 2, many were calling for the coaching staff to be fired.  Hell, we just got beat by the Broncos (top AFC team) and the Eagles (5-1 right now).  What people didn't focus on is the margin of those loses and how competitive we were.  Hopefully, we can continue to improve and get to Glendale, Arizona (for the Super Bowl.  I'm in Phoenix and would love to see big Blue here to win it all!  Go colts!  Ciao!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably because he was touted as an offensive genius coming out of Minnesota , and won on defense in Baltimore. He kept Matt Cavanaugh around too long as offensive co ordinator, insisted on drafting Kyle Boller, got rid of Trent Dilfer and went with Elvis Gerbac the year after the Super Bowl, and when Gerbac failed, did not put in Randall Cunningham in the Pittsburgh playoff game in 2001.

I like Brian, and will always like him as an ex Raven, but look at his record compared to Harbaugh. Harbaugh is a much more consistent coach record wise.

Well...Grbac was coming off a year in KC where he threw 28 td's to only 14 picks and 4000+ yards though while Dilfer only started 12 games the year including the playoffs and SB and really was nothing more then a game manager.....which hey that's great, A lot of teams wish they had good game managers at QB right now and back then no doubt but if you can get a bit more then a game manager.

Which Grbac was a bit more then a game manager for a couple years prior...considering that the game was different then compared today, It also did not help that Jamal Lewis went down with a season ending injury and had an old Terry Allen followed by unproven players or cast offs at rb behind him

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Never easy to win in Pittsburgh.  If the Colts win this one, there will be more media people believing. Scoring will be pretty tough due to the genius of their head-coach and his game-planning expertise.  And stopping the tall and massive Rothlisberger will be the biggest challenge yet for the defense.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably because he was touted as an offensive genius coming out of Minnesota , and won on defense in Baltimore. He kept Matt Cavanaugh around too long as offensive co ordinator, insisted on drafting Kyle Boller, got rid of Trent Dilfer and went with Elvis Gerbac the year after the Super Bowl, and when Gerbac failed, did not put in Randall Cunningham in the Pittsburgh playoff game in 2001.

I like Brian, and will always like him as an ex Raven, but look at his record compared to Harbaugh. Harbaugh is a much more consistent coach record wise.

 

I agree.  It's easier to be an offensive genius when you have Chris Carter and Randy Moss.  Wasn't Marvin Lewis your DC the year you won your first SB?  A great D and a powerful running game can make any coach look good.

 

I think the knock on him was that he always thought he was the smartest guy in the room (and he may well have been).  But he didn't want to listen to anyone else, and the players didn't really relate to him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Never easy to win in Pittsburgh.  If the Colts win this one, there will be more media people believing. Scoring will be pretty tough due to the genius of their head-coach and his game-planning expertise.  And stopping the tall and massive Rothlisberger will be the biggest challenge yet for the defense.

I agree.  Tough place to play against a team that has some talent at the skill positions.  If the offense handles the blitz, Colts will score 30 points.  If the Colts have to slug it out, it will take a late drive to seal the deal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree.  It's easier to be an offensive genius when you have Chris Carter and Randy Moss.  Wasn't Marvin Lewis your DC the year you won your first SB?  A great D and a powerful running game can make any coach look good.

 

I think the knock on him was that he always thought he was the smartest guy in the room (and he may well have been).  But he didn't want to listen to anyone else, and the players didn't really relate to him.

 

To be fair, he only had Cris Carter and Randy Moss for one year. ;)  He also went through an interesting mix of QB's during his time in Minnesota and he retooled the offense to be successful behind each one.  There was Warren Moon, an all time great but a guy that many people thought would suffer from not playing in the Houston Run and shoot.  Moon and Billick proved that to be completely false.  Then there was Brad Johnson, another Trent Dilfer.  And finally Randall Cunningham who was approaching the end of his career being 35 at the time.  Cunningham was pretty much an afterthought by that point, but with Billick (yes, and Carter and Moss lol) they put together the most prolific offense in the league.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bilick definitely seems like o n e of the smarter football analysts out there, at least out of all the knuckleheads on NFLN...

Bilick always strikes me as a dumb smart guy. I like him, but Jay Cutler was his pick for MVP...wth?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To be fair, he only had Cris Carter and Randy Moss for one year. ;)  He also went through an interesting mix of QB's during his time in Minnesota and he retooled the offense to be successful behind each one.  There was Warren Moon, an all time great but a guy that many people thought would suffer from not playing in the Houston Run and shoot.  Moon and Billick proved that to be completely false.  Then there was Brad Johnson, another Trent Dilfer.  And finally Randall Cunningham who was approaching the end of his career being 35 at the time.  Cunningham was pretty much an afterthought by that point, but with Billick (yes, and Carter and Moss lol) they put together the most prolific offense in the league.  

 

You're right, I wasn't trying to say he was a bad coach.  But his reputation as an 'offensive genius' wasn't exactly proven out after he left the Vikings.  BTW, the year he left Jeff George threw something like 20+ TDs in about 10 games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bilick always strikes me as a dumb smart guy. I like him, but Jay Cutler was his pick for MVP...wth?

Ha, oh yeah I think I remember that...

You know you can't win 'em all...

funny...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ha, oh yeah I think I remember that...

You know you can't win 'em all...

funny...

He also claimed he wouldn't pursue Peyton Manning the FA if he were the GM of the texans. He cited that Manning didn't fit their system. Hell, if my OC was so pathetic he couldn't utilize Manning I would fire him on the spot lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He also claimed he wouldn't pursue Peyton Manning the FA if he were the GM of the texans. He cited that Manning didn't fit their system. Hell, if my OC was so pathetic he couldn't utilize Manning I would fire him on the spot lol.

 

A primer for offensive coordinators on using Peyton Manning as your quarterback. . . Shut up and get out of the way.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You're right, I wasn't trying to say he was a bad coach.  But his reputation as an 'offensive genius' wasn't exactly proven out after he left the Vikings.  BTW, the year he left Jeff George threw something like 20+ TDs in about 10 games.

 

Right, and I get that.  As for the offensive genius after he left Minn, as I alluded to earlier, the QB situation in Balt during his time there was abysmal.  Now, from what I've read, Boller was on him..that was his mistake and he owned it.  The rest of the QB's he was given to work with though.... O.o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He also claimed he wouldn't pursue Peyton Manning the FA if he were the GM of the texans. He cited that Manning didn't fit their system. Hell, if my OC was so pathetic he couldn't utilize Manning I would fire him on the spot lol.

 

yeah, if you are an OC & you get 18 as your QB then it's as the Dire Straits say..."Money for Nothin' "

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In answering all of your responses , I would boil down Billick's termination mainly for keeping a horrible offensive co ordinator around so long. The 15-6 loss to the Colts in 2006 is a great example why Billick had to go. You hold Peyton to five field goals, and your offense can't get 16 points. There were many games like that, but Billick doggedly supported Cavanaugh to his own detriment. He really pushed Ozzie to draft Boller, although I blame both of them, and that also cost him.

I like Brian a lot, but like Polian with you guys, it was time for him to go. You can't be going from

13-3 to 5-11 the next year, and wasting top defenses year after year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In answering all of your responses , I would boil down Billick's termination mainly for keeping a horrible offensive co ordinator around so long. The 15-6 loss to the Colts in 2006 is a great example why Billick had to go. You hold Peyton to five field goals, and your offense can't get 16 points. There were many games like that, but Billick doggedly supported Cavanaugh to his own detriment. He really pushed Ozzie to draft Boller, although I blame both of them, and that also cost him.

I like Brian a lot, but like Polian with you guys, it was time for him to go. You can't be going from

13-3 to 5-11 the next year, and wasting top defenses year after year.

 

I find it hard to believe that Cavanaugh would have factored in to Billick's firing.  Cavanaugh was replaced several years before Billick was fired.  I also didn't think Billick would be the type to hold on to a coach that wasn't working out due to him firing Fassell, but that was a couple of years after Cavanaugh so maybe it was a matter of him learning from his mistakes with Cavanaugh that led him to go ahead and pull the trigger on also firing Fassell.  However I remember the Fassell firing being somewhat of a big deal because of the long-standing friendship between he and Billick.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I find it hard to believe that Cavanaugh would have factored in to Billick's firing. Cavanaugh was replaced several years before Billick was fired. I also didn't think Billick would be the type to hold on to a coach that wasn't working out due to him firing Fassell, but that was a couple of years after Cavanaugh so maybe it was a matter of him learning from his mistakes with Cavanaugh that led him to go ahead and pull the trigger on also firing Fassell. However I remember the Fassell firing being somewhat of a big deal because of the long-standing friendship between he and Billick.

I think Bisciotti forced Billick to finally get rid of Cavanaugh in 2005, and when the offense wasn't markedly better under Fassell , he had to go, then the next head to go was Billick. I'm grateful to the guy for Super Bowl 35, trust me, and he's a great guy, but it was his time. He also started to lose the team at the end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Bisciotti forced Billick to finally get rid of Cavanaugh in 2005, and when the offense wasn't markedly better under Fassell , he had to go, then the next head to go was Billick. I'm grateful to the guy for Super Bowl 35, trust me, and he's a great guy, but it was his time. He also started to lose the team at the end.

 

Oh I also get that as well, even good coaches get fired in the NFL.  Personally I would have liked to have seen Billick last one more year to see how he could have done with Flacco, but at the same time I get the "ready to move in a new directoin" approach.  

 

I would like to see Billick back on the sidelines though, for anyone other than Jax, Tenn or Hou :D   Hmm...Oakland is reportedly looking for a big name, splashy HC.  He'd have Derek Carr to work with...that could be interesting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh I also get that as well, even good coaches get fired in the NFL. Personally I would have liked to have seen Billick last one more year to see how he could have done with Flacco, but at the same time I get the "ready to move in a new directoin" approach.

I would like to see Billick back on the sidelines though, for anyone other than Jax, Tenn or Hou :D Hmm...Oakland is reportedly looking for a big name, splashy HC. He'd have Derek Carr to work with...that could be interesting.

He definitely deserves a chance , and I'm just guessing why he hasn't gotten one. I think one of the aspects of his personality that may rub owners the wrong way is his smugness, and sort of know it all demeanor. It works great as an analyst , but may run some owners the wrong way . You would think after a Super Bowl win, someone would have hired him. It is a bit mysterious.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bilick always strikes me as a dumb smart guy. I like him, but Jay Cutler was his pick for MVP...wth?

I seen numerous guys say they thought jay was gonna be MVP.. i couldnt believe it either.. boy did their predictions go down in a firey crash and burn.. lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • IR. PUP. Starts Wk 1.    That's covered it. 
    • Multiple times I have said the length of the deal would be the issue...like probably in four different posts in this thread. But I think there are people who would even be against paying a RB (like Zeke) that much money for 1-2 years...or wouldn't even give up a late pick for him.    I brought up Funchess because signing Zeke would be akin to signing a Funchess each offseason for a few years. From a financial standpoint...that's not unreasonable. The picks are a different discussion...but Zeke is also on a completely different level...and there is going to be an acquisition cost to getting a player like that.    The bit about Mack was meant to be tongue-in-cheek. The rest of my comment isn't meant to be an attack or even a generalization...it's just an observation about what I have seen in many fans the past year (the Mack situation actually predated a lot of this).   There seems to be a theme...that when a talented non-Colts player vet is mentioned as a possibility to acquire (who would have a cost attached)...there are many that are either dismissive or against it...to the point that late round picks are too much to give up. I think that happens more often than people ignoring the acquisition cost and saying "gimme, gimme." (To be fair...I think saying people "routinely" ignore the acquisition cost is as much of an unfair representation or generalization as what I said...just on the opposite spectrum).   I respect your opinion...and we actually agree on many things (including aspects of roster construction)...I just think I must be in the minority when it comes to taking 'big swings' around here.
    • So here we are again, bunches of cap money, hoping our draft picks are as good as last year, but sweating our QB issue.     How many draft picks are we gonna horde?   How much cap space are we gonna bank?   I realize this deal with Zeke might be just a rumor and forum fodder, but if we have a chance to bring him in, I say yes.  As I, and many other members have said many times, we have a QB that can win a super bowl, but so far we have wasted the opportunity because we lack that 1 player that completes the puzzle.     Andrew has suffered more pain playing on our team then any other Colt's player that I can recall,  I say again, it's time to loosen the purse strings and sign some proven talent to give him a fighting chance.
    • I don't look for him to do much at DT. He played really limited snaps on the interior, really only when they game was far out of hand. Much like here in Indy, there were much better guys on that interior at Ohio State. Tyquan didn't get many "meaningful" snaps inside. Even now he's going to get limited snaps inside because Autry, Hunt, and Ward as just better interior players. I still think he would be a good, cheap replacement, for Sheard, if they got him back down in the 260's. He's good against the run and may get a handful of sacks a year against average RT's. I still scratch my head on why they insist on doing what they are doing with him now.     Yea that's not the story. Him and J Bosa were the starting DE's until they left. Hubbard eventually took over for Bosa when he left and Chase was still sitting behind Tyquan, Nick, and Sam. Chase will be a stud though and I have no doubts he'll be a top-10 pick next year barring injury. 6-5 265 with stupid athleticism, and is equally as good against the run as he is rushing the passer.   Maybe they were thinking Tyquan could turn into a Michael Bennett-type, who can bounce inside and outside on the fly, but I just don't see him being that kind of guy. He wasn't overly athletic at 260'ish, so he's definitely going be hindered with another 10-15-20lbs.
    • Cards lost 5-3 in a rain out called after the top of the 8th. Cubs back in 1st place after tonight. NL Central standings heading into August 22nd are:   Cubs 68-58 Cards 67-58 (.5 back) Brewers 65-62 (3.5 back)   Here's a question to Cards fans, @Jay Kirk , @Barry Sears, and @Myles, what do you guys think about important games being called after the bottom of the 5th of games? This was called in the bottom of the 8th. In the playoffs it is different, if a game is called because of weather, the 2 teams resume the next day where it left off. Having said that the regular season is different, thoughts?
  • Members

    • SteelCityColt

      SteelCityColt 6,926

      Moderators
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Swan Ronson

      Swan Ronson 279

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • C0LT5

      C0LT5 102

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • IinD

      IinD 2,283

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • CR91

      CR91 8,688

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • ClaytonColt

      ClaytonColt 332

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Trace Pyott

      Trace Pyott 250

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Defjamz26

      Defjamz26 3,954

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • MrPreGame

      MrPreGame 18

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • KB

      KB 382

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...