who is the best colts QB not named unitas manning or luck

[CR91 6,943]

couple of good ones. bert jones, mike pagel, jim harbough, 

[GoColts8818 4,690]

Jones.

[ReMeDy 434]

Jared "J.Load" Lorenzen.

[OffensivelyPC 1,121]

Jared "J.Load" Lorenzen.

LOL.  I kinda feel bad for the guy, but then I really don't.  Not being able to keep a steady diet cost him his wife and at least several hundreds of thousands of dollars, amongst other things.  It's not quite as bad as getting cut for getting arrested, but it's about as close as you can get. 

[backshoulderfade 115]

Curtis Painter.

[cbear 378]

Marty Domres.  Kidding, just liked his name.  

 

Bert Jones, no question in my mind.  If it wasn't for that shoulder injury.....

[Coltsfanman1953 1]

Tom Matte

[rockywoj 1,014]

Jones.

 

Yup, and it's not even close.  If Bert Jones had not been ruined by injuries, he too would be a Colts QB in the Hall of Fame.

[Blueblazes 9]

Bert Jones. Hands down. The total package of athleticism, cannon arm and football IQ. Very sad his shoulder issues cut his career short. If you didn't see him play, think of Andrew Luck's legs/speed with Brett Favre's arm. No joking.

[jvan1973 5,498]

Well harbaugh did win a few playoff games here.

And Mike Pagel was terrible

[rittdk01 0]

harbaugh 

 

The only Colts I know r in Indianapolis and Harbaugh was the first qb they had when I was a kid.

[USAFHoosier 28]

Bert Jones by a mile

[The Old Crow 763]

Marty Domres

[SteelCityColt 4,473]

Pedantically... the actual question to the question of who IS the best Colts QB not named Unitas/Manning/Luck is Matt Hasselbeck as he's the only Colts QB not named as per the previous.

 

Now who WAS the best Colts QB I'd have to say Bert Jones going from folklore. 

[earlsmitley 3]

Unfortunatly I never got to watch jones play. But I started watching the year before we made it to the afc championship with harbaugh. I remember being real upset when we traded him to san Diego.

[LJpalmbeacher2 1,979]

Only one name should be on this list : Bert Jones

[shakedownstreet 2,145]

gary hogeboom was the truth

[cbear 378]

In my mind, Jones was the first real "gunslinger."  He had the arm and the attitude to match.  His confidence (opponents would say arrogance) literally carried the team at times and gave them confidence in themselves.  Carr, Mitchell, Mackey, Lee, Chester, Doughty, the Sack Pack...that was a fun team to watch.

[Nobody 9]

Jimmy

[Ja'Crispy 0]

Jeff George? Curtis Painter? Kerry Collins?

Jim Harbaugh

[Jon Daily 0]

Kerry Collins

[David Belcher 0]

Bert Jones the reason i started liking the colts in the 70's

[ColtsBlueFL 4,500]

Bert Jones... by a mile.  Then Jim Harbaugh... by 3 miles, then....    then...   uhhhh....  then Chris Chandler.

[Moose Of Woe 2]

Jeff George. He's still trying to get teams to take him.

 

In all seriousness, I liked Harbaugh but Jones was probably the best besides PM/AL/JU.

[JSChicago 0]

Curtis Painter.

 

I was wondering how far I'd  have to scroll down before I saw this... :clap:

[fatboy 71]

Sage Rosenfels

[LordHelpOurColts 0]

Definitely Leftwich

[Tsarquise 454]

Jim Harbaugh

[Warhawk 0]

Nobody even going to mention Earl Morrall?

 

I mean, sure, Jones.  But still.  Dude went 22-3-1.

[coltsfan77 29]

Bert Jones, no question! If not for the shoulder injury, he may have owned a lot of colts and league records that Peyton would have been chasing. The player that made me fall in love with football and the colts as a kid.

[lennymoore24 307]

I think without question Bert Jones.

[SOMDColtsfan 116]

<---Bert Jones

[Coltsman1788 1,542]

Bert Jones without question.

[Buck Showalter 534]

I dont count Bert Jones, he played in Balt.

I liked Harbaugh & Trudeau...

Trudeau just cause he was the QB when my gramps would take me to the Hoosier Dome for games, but i dont think i remember him winning any games...

[CanuckColt 429]

Bert Jones....not even close.

[New Zealands #1 Colts Fan 634]

i believe the win percentage when jim sorgi was in the starting 45 was extremely high

[New Zealands #1 Colts Fan 634]

also i did enjoy watching a  td thrown by one j addai

[colts_100nascar17fan 12]

Harbaugh, Bert jones, earl morrall, Chris chandler

[ColtV 243]

Easy. Mark Hermann...he started the opener in 92 against Cleveland in the first Colts game I ever attended, leading Indy to a humiliating win over the hated Browns.

[JColts72 180]

Bert Jones oh that 75 to 77 run, Poster on wall,  Colts t-shirt with his number and 7th grade book report