Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

calling holmes and mewhort


Recommended Posts

please come back soon for the sake of our running game.

Louis definitely looked overwhelmed. From what I could see Harrison looked okay.

But you're right, the line was much better in pass protection than in run blocking.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Louis definitely looked overwhelmed. From what I could see Harrison looked okay.

But you're right, the line was much better in pass protection than in run blocking.

That is a plus, the pass protection was solid without 2 starters. Even when the backups came in, usually our backup QBs are little more than tackling dummies for the defense but even they had sometime to make reads last night (though, apparently Harnish can't read).

Link to post
Share on other sites

That is a plus, the pass protection was solid without 2 starters. Even when the backups came in, usually our backup QBs are little more than tackling dummies for the defense but even they had sometime to make reads last night (though, apparently Harnish can't read).

 

im gonna be upset if we waste a ps spot for harnish

Link to post
Share on other sites

im gonna be upset if we waste a ps spot for harnish

I feel the same way. Unfortunately, I think Luck really likes him. I was hanging out with Harnish's trainer yesterday, and we had a whole discussion about this. I was telling him I didn't think Harnish could complete a pass to save his life, to which he responded that he doesn't really need to because "The Franchise" loves him. They room together too. He also went on to say that Luck has confided in Harnish his disappointment with Trent. Made comments about how he can't believe how much was given up to get him. Take that as you may. This guy has been Harnish's primary offseason trainer for the past 4 years, and he seemed pretty genuine with the things he was saying.

Link to post
Share on other sites

That is a plus, the pass protection was solid without 2 starters. Even when the backups came in, usually our backup QBs are little more than tackling dummies for the defense but even they had sometime to make reads last night (though, apparently Harnish can't read).

Harnish has looked poor, although I do not believe that his pass protection has been very good. However, when he has had protection he still has made poor throws.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harnish has looked poor, although I do not believe that his pass protection has been very good. However, when he has had protection he still has made poor throws.

His pass protection certainly hasn't been great but it's definitely better than in years passed. He's also had better targets to throw to as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites

His pass protection certainly hasn't been great but it's definitely better than in years passed. He's also had better targets to throw to as well.

That's true. He looked halfway decent that first year I thought, not so much since then.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 He also went on to say that Luck has confided in Harnish his disappointment with Trent. Made comments about how he can't believe how much was given up to get him.

 

how likely is this true?

Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel the same way. Unfortunately, I think Luck really likes him. I was hanging out with Harnish's trainer yesterday, and we had a whole discussion about this. I was telling him I didn't think Harnish could complete a pass to save his life, to which he responded that he doesn't really need to because "The Franchise" loves him. They room together too. He also went on to say that Luck has confided in Harnish his disappointment with Trent. Made comments about how he can't believe how much was given up to get him. Take that as you may. This guy has been Harnish's primary offseason trainer for the past 4 years, and he seemed pretty genuine with the things he was saying.

I find it extremely hard to believe Luck would say something like that about a teammate, even to his best friend.

Link to post
Share on other sites

how likely is this true?

I have been ruminating over that very question since yesterday. What I have come up with is that my friend was being honest that he was told by Harnish; however, I'm not convinced Harnish was being entirely honest. Every fiber of my being is telling me that Luck is far to much of a consummate professional to risk team chemestry with such a comment. In the end, that's why I brought it to the forum lol.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been ruminating over that very question since yesterday. What I have come up with is that my friend was being honest that he was told by Harnish; however, I'm not convinced Harnish was being entirely honest. Every fiber of my being is telling me that Luck is far to much of a consummate professional to risk team chemestry with such a comment. In the end, that's why I brought it to the forum lol.

 

thats not luck. he wouldnt throw someone under the bus no way

Link to post
Share on other sites

I find it extremely hard to believe Luck would say something like that about a teammate, even to his best friend.

 

I agree and this is the first time I've ever heard of Luck and Harnish being that close.

 

I mean he's probably good friends with Fleener and Whalen because they played together at Stanford.  And I think he's gotten to know Castanzo pretty well too because he said they play board games together.

 

But I've never heard about him hanging out with Harnish.

 

This is the first time I've ever heard it suggested that he's close with Harnish.

 

I don't care if Harnish is Luck's best friend though. . . there is no reason to keep him around.  He's not developing to the point where he's gonna be a good backup. 

 

We either re-sign Hasselbeck for another season or draft someone 4th round or later to be he backup.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with you there. Luck has exercised restraint in throwing any player under the bus, let alone a starting offensive teammate. If he were to throw someone under a bus, I'd rather it be Harnish haha.

 

if he doesnt throw satale under the bus he doesnt throw anyone haha

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree and this is the first time I've ever heard of Luck and Harnish being that close.

I mean he's probably good friends with Fleener and Whalen because they played together at Stanford. And I think he's gotten to know Castanzo pretty well too because he said they play board games together.

But I've never heard about him hanging out with Harnish.

This is the first time I've ever heard it suggested that he's close with Harnish.

I don't care if Harnish is Luck's best friend though. . . there is no reason to keep him around. He's not developing to the point where he's gonna be a good backup.

We either re-sign Hasselbeck for another season or draft someone 4th round or later to be he backup.

I agree. Under no circumstances can Harnish be allowed to be/ depended on as our backup QB. I think MH is done after this year though, unless he somehow agrees to another year at a discounted rate. For this reason, I would agree with your assertion that we draft a QB next year.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree. Under no circumstances can Harnish be allowed to be/ depended on as our backup QB. I think MH is done after this year though, unless he somehow agrees to another year at a discounted rate. For this reason, I would agree with your assertion that we draft a QB next year.

 

He sort of retreated on retirement talk.  I'd take him for another year at 3 million if he wanted it.  It would give us the chance to spend that draft pick on the defense.

 

But Harnish has to go, he's just not gonna be an NFL QB, not even as a backup. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

He sort of retreated on retirement talk. I'd take him for another year at 3 million if he wanted it. It would give us the chance to spend that draft pick on the defense.

But Harnish has to go, he's just not gonna be an NFL QB, not even as a backup.

That would be great if MH came back. He is such a luxury to have. Honestly, you present a great point. I would much rather not have to use a high pick on a QB when we are so close to the monster being built!

Link to post
Share on other sites

We won't and we can't. Yes used up all of his PS eligibility.

 

You may be right,  but I thought it was reported here last year that players have 3 years of PS eligibility and not 2.

 

Of course, much of it depends on how much actual time is spent on the 53 man roster.     And I don't think Harnish has spent much time there.

 

I'm not speaking with any confidence here,  but that what's I thought I read here last year.....

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with you there. Luck has exercised restraint in throwing any player under the bus, let alone a starting offensive teammate. If he were to throw someone under a bus, I'd rather it be Harnish haha.

 

I heard Harnish tried to throw himself under the bus, but he missed.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He sort of retreated on retirement talk.  I'd take him for another year at 3 million if he wanted it.  It would give us the chance to spend that draft pick on the defense.

 

But Harnish has to go, he's just not gonna be an NFL QB, not even as a backup. 

Yeah and I can't believe Painter is still in the league. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tell it to Pam Oliver, he put it in her ear hole:)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wL5bgPSLAiI

 

 

Everybody say..

oops upside your head, say oops upside your head,

(All the ladies say)

say oops upside your head, say oops upside your head,

(All the fellas say)

say oops upside your head, say oops upside your head,

(everybody say)

say oops upside your head, say oops upside your head,

Link to post
Share on other sites

im gonna be upset if we waste a ps spot for harnish

Welp being touted Mr. Irrelevant is probabaly not a #hashtag any NFL player wants to be known for. It's like "I have aspirations to be the crapiest NFL player of all time." That being said, he is a NFL player. That is much more than I personally have ever amounted to!! Lol

Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel the same way. Unfortunately, I think Luck really likes him. I was hanging out with Harnish's trainer yesterday, and we had a whole discussion about this. I was telling him I didn't think Harnish could complete a pass to save his life, to which he responded that he doesn't really need to because "The Franchise" loves him. They room together too. He also went on to say that Luck has confided in Harnish his disappointment with Trent. Made comments about how he can't believe how much was given up to get him. Take that as you may. This guy has been Harnish's primary offseason trainer for the past 4 years, and he seemed pretty genuine with the things he was saying.

 

Harnish is from my neck of the woods. I have friends who went to school with him at Norwell and they weren't too fond of his personality. I wish the best for the guy though. Not sure if he will make the team after this season.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harnish is from my neck of the woods. I have friends who went to school with him at Norwell and they weren't too fond of his personality. I wish the best for the guy though. Not sure if he will make the team after this season.

Anyone who says they aren't too fond of Harnish's personality speaks volumes about themselves.  He is "Mr. Personality "  I do know Chandler has "his own" bedroom at Andrew's condo downtown.  And yes, he is close with Chandler who rooms with him at away games.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone who says they aren't too fond of Harnish's personality speaks volumes about themselves. He is "Mr. Personality " I do know Chandler has "his own" bedroom at Andrew's condo downtown. And yes, he is close with Chandler who rooms with him at away games.

Right, they are my good friends but I don't know their relationship with each other. This was in highschool so it was some time ago. I wish the best for him. I would like to see him play behind a decent line to see what he can do.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I liked it a lot, but I found that baseball purists did not like it as much. Even though the Yankees beat the Mets most of the time, most of the games were competitive and the games the Mets won brought good memories.   I recall where I was when this happened. (I get chills. ) I remember walking in the street and I jumped up when utility man Matt Franco got this walk-off hit off Mariano Rivera at the bottom of the 9th. My eyes glanced at a man sitting in his car, who screamed at the same time. It was rare for Mariano to blow a save. This was around 1996 or so.     Listen to that great call. I love it!   That was one of my favorite Mets teams.   
    • Again in terms of projecting values out, this all depends on how we see Braden Smith valued.    I said to go high at $10M a year based on a few things:   1) If you asked many people is Braden Smith a top-5 RT, most would say no. I think he is. either way a top-5 RT slots in at an AAV of $10M a year right now   2) Most of the guys getting top $ at RT got that top dollar by getting it on the open market. Lane Johnson is the exception. However, the Eagles gave him that extension when there was originally talk about him moving to LT as Peters aged. The guys that signed extensions with their current teams got $10M a year or less.    3) This is to say I think Smith can totally get over $10M a year if he hits the open market and wants to test the waters. However, if the Colts looked to extend him now and give him financial security as a 2nd round pick that has not made much money yet in his career and did so in a year where the cap came down and a lot of players are going to take less money if they are not a superstar, I think him signing a deal averaging $10M a year would be a win for him and the Colts     At the end of the day, my entire point of this thread was to simply point out that us investing $50-$55M in a starting OL out of a future cap of around $200-$220M is very, very doable and arguably reasonable in terms of how Ballard likes to build through the trenches. Having an OL tie up 25% of your cap and a combined OL and QB tie up less than 40% of your cap for the next 3-4 years is actually very, very reasonable.   I have admittedly been a big advocate for Trent Williams. He is aging, sure. But he has shown no signs at all of slipping. And he even has one less year of wear and tear on his body from sitting out a year with the whole tumor fiasco where Washington really didn't do right by him with their medical team. So would I throw a 4 year deal at him with big money where the only guaranteed money was paid out in the first two years and then there were salaries on the back end that can easily allow a cut if the performance dips? Absolutely.   Either way, this was really to just get our base chatting about all this since the canned narrative everyone is spitting out is the same narrative that is being fed to fans from the media that says "they'll have too much tied up in their OL with the extension for Kelly and the upcoming extensions for Nelson and Smith." I'm just saying if we managed things the way guys like Mike Bluem have been, then we can comfortably invest in a top FA  LT if we wanted to without it being overly painful downstream. 
    • I personally do not like the idea of trying to come up with a stop gap or developmental guy at the most inportant position on the OL. Solidify that position with a dependable proven LT whether it  Villanueva or someone else. Same with DE. Find a proven pass rusher and pay him. Use the draft or WR, CB and solidifying other positions including OL. I think we are very close to being in  SB contention and 3 to 4 good players may push us over the top. We can't foolishly throw money at these guys but if we are prudent we have plenty of money to carry us.
    • Yeah, my little voice partly thinks the same (perhaps contract year type of performance). I just hate saying it out loud, as he was considered very very raw when drafted. He was used all over the place at USC, and relied way too much on his natural gifts instead of technique. Maybe he was a bit lazy, but it's also possible he was just raw, wasn't able to focus, and things are just now clicking. Or maybe he was lazy a bit, and finally grew up or matured enough to commit to his craft.    He's an interesting guy to follow. I could see it falling either way. I remember his recruiting out of HS (think he was out of Mainland) Thought for sure he'd end up at FSU, UF, or Auburn. My FSU and Auburn buds thought he was a lock lol. One of my FSU buds swore USC bought him a car lol. I was hoping ND would offer, but rumor was, he didn't have close to the grades needed.    
  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...