Name your top 5 current Colts

[danlhart87]

1. Luck

2. Wayne

3. Mathis

4. Freeman

5. Castonzo

[chad hugo]

if its based on their current performances then...

 

Luck

Mathis

Wayne

Davis

Freeman 

[Gavin]

Wayne

Mathis

Freeman

Redding

Chapman

 

 

 

Yeah what are we basing it on?

[AllYouNeedIsLuck]

Luck, Wayne, Mathis, Hilton, and Davis 

[Guest TeamLoloJones]

1. Wayne

2. Luck

3. Mathis

4. Bethea

5. Boomstick

 

Coach Pagano gets an honorable mention.

[Ja'Crispy]

5 best performers?

 

1. Luck

 

2. Mathis

 

3. Davis

 

4. Wayne

 

5. Freeman

[The Peytonator]

Luck

Wayne

Mathis

Castonzo

Davis

[Caleb3502]

Luck, Wayne, Mathis, Freeman, McAfee

2 from the offense, 2 from the defense, and a special teamer

[Zubulon Zellenzevo]

That's tough, I like the whole team so I don't think I can single anyone out. But I'll try... LoL

Luck

Wayne

Mathis

Freeman

Davis/Butler

 

then:

T.Y. Hilton- Needs to be targeted more!! He has great potential get the ball to him more. This way whenever Wayne decides to retire Hilton is ready to step up.

Bradshaw- Super power rusher when healthy. Running angry

Richardson- already 2 touchdown rushing games

Bethea- Always a great performer, wish his counterpart was healthy Landry

Thorton- who has done amazing as a rookie

[TKnight24]

1. Dylan

2. Dylan

3. Dylan

4. Dylan

5. Dylan

Go !

[indycrazy1887]

Luck

Redding

Mathis

Wayne

Bethea

Davis hilton castonzo and patty mac with the honorable mention

[indycrazy1887]

Maybe it'd be easier to do top 5 offense and defense

[pgt_rob]

My favorite Colts:

 

1. Wayne

2. Mathis

3. Butler

4. Bradshaw

5. Luck tied with McAfee

[Dustin]

1. Dylan

2. Dylan

3. Dylan

4. Dylan

5. Dylan

Go !

because I spit hot fire

[Hans Moleman]

Luck

Wayne

Mathis

Castonzo

Davis

 

+1. Honorable mention to McAfee

[MakeItWayne]

Luck

Richardson

Hilton

Landry

Davis

[Colts_Fan12]

Luck

Mathis

Bradshaw

Wayne

Davis

[NewEra]

Corey Simon

Quin pitcock

Hank basket

Qadry Ismail

Nick Harper

Wait, wrong top 5? Heh

[LuckToReggie]

Luck

Wayne

Davis

Mathis

Boomstick

[GoColts8818]

Luck, Wayne, Mathis, mcafee, redding

[jvan1973]

Wayne

Mathis

Freeman

Redding

Chapman

Yeah what are we basing it on?

I'm not sure what you're basing it on. Must be some weird scale where 4 career tackles gets you in the top five

[gacker65]

Wayne

Mathis

Bethea

Allen

Freeman

 

Honorable mention: Redding

[shakedownstreet]

man redding has been balling this season. freeman seems on another level too. the other three need no mention

[mo0nlighting]

Robert Mathis

Reggie

Luck 

Cory Redding

Patty Mac

 

Everybody else is tied for 6th favorite

[Dark Superman]

1. Luck

2. Wayne

3. Mathis

4. Freeman

5. Castonzo

Luck,Hilton,Landry,Mathis and Davis.

[rock8591]

Hank Baskett

Tony Ugoh

Quinn Pitcock

Keyunta Dawson

Antonio Johnson

[jmac_48]

The O

The D

Chuck

Grigs

Irsay

 

Honorable Mention: Special Teams

 

Yup! that covers it...

lol

[Warhawk]

Based purely on personal preference:

 

1. Wayne

2. McAfee

3. Luck

4. Mathis

5. Angerer (bought his jersey after Manning left, got some compliments from Jets fans when I went to the Jets game last year for going with an unusual selection)

 

Honorable mentions to Bradshaw, Bethea, Fleener, Hilton, and Chapman.

 

Honorable honorable mentions to Toler, Butler, Allen, Cherilus, and Reitz.

 

I could probably keep going, frankly...

[BPM_Colt]

Hard to narrow it down to 5

 

1. Mathis

2. Luck

3. Wayne

4. Redding

5. Freeman

 

Cherilus, Davis, Bethea, Butler, and Freeman are right up there as well

[colts_100nascar17fan]

Luck Landry Wayne Davis Bethea......Butler/Freeman/Toler close

[ColtsBTM12]

1. Wayne ( Been here long time future HOFer, class act)

2. Luck (Great QB of the future)

3. Mathis (  Long-time sack master, class act)

4. Bethea ( Great pro, member of 06 champs)

5. McAfee ( What's not to love?)

[T Y Goodbye]

1. Dylan

2. Dylan

3. Dylan

4. Dylan

5. Dylan

Go !

 

Is Dylan the apple juice vendor at LOS?..

[MFT5]

Luck

Wayne

Davis

Bethea

Fleener

... It was hard to keep TY of my list but Luck was a given.

Reggie and Bethea are rocks on this team and Fleener is a matchup nightmare that could make us unstoppable.

And he endured the most criticism this off season and is showing more ability each weak

I've been a fan of Davis since Miami drafted him mainly because of his 90+ Press Coverage in madden

[Greenoughrunner]

Luck
Wayne
Hilton
Mathis   
McAfee
Bethea

[Malakai432]

Jeff Linkenbach

Mike McGlynn

Samson Satele

Erik Walden

Cassius Vaughn

[dudeski]

wayne

luck

mathis

allen

davis

 

 

 

can't believe there is no love for allen

[Narcosys]

Im going against the grain

 

1.  Whalen

2.  Wayne

3.  Davis

4.  Landry

5.  Richardson, Luck, Fleener, Hilton, Allen, Bradshaw, Mathis  all tied.

[Guest TeamLoloJones]

1. Blaine Gabbert (Thanks for the pick six)

2. The Neckbeard (presented by Geico)

3. Griff Whalen, Drake Nevis, and Caesar Rayford (and the forum goes BOOM)

4. The first round pick we sent to Cleveland (whoever we picked, he was going to be a HOFer)

5. Matt Schaub (see Blaine Gabbert)

[RomanianColtsFan]

People that I would enjoy hanging out with

Reggie Wayne

Robert Mathis

Cory Redding

Darius Butler

Bjoern Werner

among others. Colts got a lot of good guys on their roster.

[jamesie jr]

Top Performers?

1. Luck

2. Mathis

3. Wayne

4. Costanzo

5. Mcafee.

 

Favourite players?

1. Mathis

2. Wayne

3. Mcafee

4. Hilton

5. Butler

(Honerable 6th for Ballard because he's on the IR so he doesn't count towards the list because he isn't active right?)