Colts receiving corps

[alexpr]

I was watching some highlights when the colts went to the Super Bowl and lost against the saints (specially the comeback against the Jets) and I came to this question:

 

Which receiving corp would you take?

 

2009-2010

 

Wr 1: Reggie Wayne

Wr 2: Garçon 

Slot: Austin Collie

TE:  Dallas Clark

 

 

2013 

 

 

Wr 1: Reggie Wayne

Wr 2: DHB

Slot: TY Hilton

TE:  Allen/Fleener

 

 

I think I would take the 2009-2010 corp, I even think that was one of the top 3 receiving corps in that time what a lost opportunity to take that Lombardi home ( Thank you, onside kick)

[TKnight24]

I'd take the current receiving core.

It's alot of potential here with so many guys. And this core had more depth than the super bowl one did. Can't wait to see what Griff Whalen brings this year

[21isSuperman]

When everyone is healthy, I would take the first group.  Fleener is still relatively unknown and DHB has had problems with drops.  Garcon is better than DHB, and Clark was an excellent route runner, receiver, and he was a matchup nightmare.  And when healthy, Collie was one of the best slot WRs in the game.

[jvan1973]

I'll let you know in a few months

[dw49]

No doubt the 2009 group , but I do like this year's group also.

[Slick_Rick]

I would take this years group for the sole fact that Hank Baskett isn't in it.

[AllYouNeedIsLuck]

When everyone is healthy, I would take the first group.  Fleener is still relatively unknown and DHB has had problems with drops.  Garcon is better than DHB, and Clark was an excellent route runner, receiver, and he was a matchup nightmare.  And when healthy, Collie was one of the best slot WRs in the game.

Garcon's not better than DHB. He's been put in better situations in his career with Peyton being his QB and all. 

[Crunked]

I would take this years group for the sole fact that Hank Baskett isn't in it.

My fantasy football team post the 9-10 season....Hell in a Hank Baskett

[AntonMcG]

Right now I would have to agree that the 2009 group seemed stronger. Collie and Garcon were incredible finds for us that year.

[ar1888]

2009 group. I was watching 2009 games this past weekend, and Dallas Clark was just unstoppable. I will be happy if Allen and Fleener combined become as reliable as Clark. Austin Collie catches anything thrown in his direction even if it meant paying with a shot to the head.

[lollygagger8]

That's why you never put all your eggs into one Baskett. 

[Dark Superman]

I'll have to see how this year pans out before I make that pick.

[Dustin]

Assuming Collie is able to stay healthy, the 2009 corps.

[T Y Goodbye]

I think a lot might disagree with me, but Hilton is way more of a threat at the slot than Collie ever was..Collie had better hands, but no where near the speed and elusiveness that Hilton brings to the table...Reggie is still Reggie..(thank goodness)...Dallas was a lot more seasoned at the time, but I would put Allen in at TE for comparison in this case, as he didn't get injured and improved with each game, and made some nice plays...Now, its down to Garcon, vs DHB. I think that DHB has improved over the years, even with revolving systems and QB's, and Garcon wasn't exactly known for having the greatest hands..he would catch the impossible ones, but drop the easiest of catches. Their speed is pretty much equal, as well as in size...The only edge I would give to Garcon is hustle. I will never forget the game Ed Reed Intercepted Peyton and was running it back for a TD, when a blur came from behind. Next thing you know Garcon caught Reed and knocked the ball out of his hands.

 

Only because I think Hilton has more of an edge over Collie, then Clark does over Allen, I'd take this years squad over the 2009 squad..

 

That's my 2 cents, for what its worth..

[Smonroe]

The OP asked which one would you take. Since we haven't seen this years group we can't say which is better. I think it's safe to say Peyton could make anyone look good. So I'd take this years group for the potential.

[21isSuperman]

Garcon's not better than DHB. He's been put in better situations in his career with Peyton being his QB and all. 

I do admit that I don't as much about DHB as I would like.  But Garcon is an incredibly physical receiver.  He is a linebacker playing in a wide receiver's body.  With that said, it is possible that DHB is also as physical.  But I've gone on record to say Garcon has the potential to be one of the best WRs in the game if he fixes his drops and can stay healthy

[Gavin]

Whiever unit performs the best ;) 

[ALuck>RG3]

I think a lot might disagree with me, but Hilton is way more of a threat at the slot than Collie ever was..Collie had better hands, but no where near the speed and elusiveness that Hilton brings to the table...Reggie is still Reggie..(thank goodness)...Dallas was a lot more seasoned at the time, but I would put Allen in at TE for comparison in this case, as he didn't get injured and improved with each game, and made some nice plays...Now, its down to Garcon, vs DHB. I think that DHB has improved over the years, even with revolving systems and QB's, and Garcon wasn't exactly known for having the greatest hands..he would catch the impossible ones, but drop the easiest of catches. Their speed is pretty much equal, as well as in size...The only edge I would give to Garcon is hustle. I will never forget the game Ed Reed Intercepted Peyton and was running it back for a TD, when a blur came from behind. Next thing you know Garcon caught Reed and knocked the ball out of his hands.

Only because I think Hilton has more of an edge over Collie, then Clark does over Allen, I'd take this years squad over the 2009 squad..

That's my 2 cents, for what its worth..

Do you know what game garcon did that becuz I really want to see it now?

[T Y Goodbye]

Do you know what game garcon did that becuz I really want to see it now?

 

After a lot of searching i finally found it...

 

Go to 4:40 of the video of the highlights of the game to see the play.

 

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d815c70d8/NFL-GameDay-Ravens-vs-Colts-highlights

[Deathiltis]

( Thank you, onside kick)

Please... it still hurts.

[FicmanS]

This current crew does look REALLY good, in the Lucas Oil open practice DHB looks like he will be a fantastic addition.  TY and Allen/Fleener are going to continue to improve...

 

I REALLY like this current crew...

[Technician Trav]

Do you know what game garcon did that becuz I really want to see it now?

it was a playoff game around the 2009 season i believe... dont hold me to that, im not 100 percent sure.. altho i do kno it was a playoff game.. i remember well because it was my first ever colts playoff game .. and omg did the place go nuts...lol