They are on par but are different types of backs. Mack is more patient and hits the hole when it opens. Wilkins is a straight ahead hard back. I would much rather see Wilkins in 3rd and one than Hines.
What was the embarrassment to the teams that he beat when he was here? Your obsession in this topic is worrying. Honestly, between here and Twitter it seems like your mental health is taking a toll. I'm not being mean, you are obsessed