Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Pjil B On Colt Problems, We All Stated The Same Thing


Recommended Posts

No matter who plays QB, it’s not going to make that much difference. Seriously, the Colts’ problems are more of a manifestation of several factors beginning with no No. 18

. Neither Painter nor Collins can make up for poor early-round draft picks in recent years, poor coaching, a flawed defensive philosophy and awful special teams.

My link

Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly, wouldn't mind it if Polian was gone.

well who did the poor draft picks, The Polians , and they had to agree to Cal;dwells philosophy & his coaching changes right, so implicitly he is saying the Polians caused some of these issues & were not perfect were they

Link to post
Share on other sites

Polian trys to be so smart hes out smarting him self but seriously at the time of all the draft picks I liked them

2010 jerry hughes

Freeney ankle cost us un the superbowl and that playoff game to the chargers when we could get no pass rush so I thought it was good to get the third pass rusher

2009 donald brown

Alot of us were down on joe addia cause of his injury history and dancing

We thought brown would be the next big thing a push addia out of town

2008 mike pollack

I liked the pick because we where not sure if we could sign jeff or if he would retire

So we drafted pollack he was the best rated center in the draft that year

2007 gonzo

We all knew marvin had lost a step an gonzo made sense at the time he showed flashes that he could be that number two but we all know what happened

Look back at the time of the picks

A top pass rusher

A top 2 running back

The top center

a playmaking wide out

All of this is based off of college rankings at the time

Link to post
Share on other sites

Polian trys to be so smart hes out smarting him self but seriously at the time of all the draft picks I liked them

2010 jerry hughes

Freeney ankle cost us un the superbowl and that playoff game to the chargers when we could get no pass rush so I thought it was good to get the third pass rusher

2009 donald brown

Alot of us were down on joe addia cause of his injury history and dancing

We thought brown would be the next big thing a push addia out of town

2008 mike pollack

I liked the pick because we where not sure if we could sign jeff or if he would retire

So we drafted pollack he was the best rated center in the draft that year

2007 gonzo

We all knew marvin had lost a step an gonzo made sense at the time he showed flashes that he could be that number two but we all know what happened

Look back at the time of the picks

A top pass rusher

A top 2 running back

The top center

a playmaking wide out

All of this is based off of college rankings at the time

Exactly. All of these players did well in the college game. You can't expect them to have success for certain in the NFL because you have no idea how they will do. All you have is game film from their play in college. At the time (like you said), many people liked the picks. Now, those same people are attacking Polian and saying he is a bad GM, it's a little embarrassing to see.

Gonzo and Brown are in their make-or-break year and so far, neither has shown any reason why we should keep him. With the way things are going so far, I don't expect either to be on the roster next year. As for Pollak, I have heard that his best position is center, so they might move him to center after Jeff retires. As for Hughes, give him time. I give him this year and next to prove himself. If he doesn't produce next year, he will be gone.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Exactly. All of these players did well in the college game. You can't expect them to have success for certain in the NFL because you have no idea how they will do. All you have is game film from their play in college. At the time (like you said), many people liked the picks. Now, those same people are attacking Polian and saying he is a bad GM, it's a little embarrassing to see.

Gonzo and Brown are in their make-or-break year and so far, neither has shown any reason why we should keep him. With the way things are going so far, I don't expect either to be on the roster next year. As for Pollak, I have heard that his best position is center, so they might move him to center after Jeff retires. As for Hughes, give him time. I give him this year and next to prove himself. If he doesn't produce next year, he will be gone.

Hughes in most analysis at the time I read was projected as an OLB in a 3-4 not a pure DE for draft purposes, also after screaming about the OL in SB 44 I stil cant understand not taking Scaffold

Brown at RB was a sc hock I thought, but not the pick of Brown , the pick of a RB

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have no problem with Pollak, if he turns out to be the center he's projected to be right now.

I thought Brown was a good idea at the time, but he's clearly out of the picture next year, if not sooner. I'm of the opinion that he was a part of the supposed trade the Colts were trying to work out at the end of training camp. Whatever happened to that, I don't know.

I have no problem waiting for Hughes. Though I also recall him being projected as a pass rushing OLB at draft time. That doesn't mean it won't work out though. There aren't many opportunities for him to play right now with 4 DEs ahead of him (2 pro-bowl rushers, and two run stuffers).

Speaking of his projected position though, both of our pro-bowlers could be near the end of their careers, at least with the Colts. We bring in Anderson & Brayton (bigger run stuffers), who's ages I'm too lazy to look up right now. We seem to be drafting a bit bigger guys lately. Did Coyer run cover 2 in Denver? What's his preferred defense? Could it be we're already in the process of changing defensive schemes?

Gonzo: I like him. OR, I like my recollection of what he was/could be. Last year was wasted for him, and it wasn't his fault. This year he's being held out, first due to recovering from a nagging injury, and now I believe it's because of the unsettled QB situation (why bother until Kerry has his stuff down, save Gonzo for a more effective time). I think he has a much better chance of hanging around next year than Brown does.

Now to the main topic of the interview. I'm a Caldwell backer. Not that I'm blind, but I allow for mistakes, and growing pains, and the situation we've been in since early last season (injuries). That, plus I've not yet seen anything that blatantly tells me he's horrible. HOWEVER, Coyer's redirect of the question concerns me, though it may be out of ignorance (on my part). So, I gotta ask.....

The Colts are a pretty closed organization (Irsay tweets aside). They hold everything close to the vest, until they have to divulge information. That said, and me being from out of town, is it uncommon for the coordinators to give interviews? Could it be that there are topics he can discuss, and others that are to be directed to the HC or a Polian?

Just asking.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hughes in most analysis at the time I read was projected as an OLB in a 3-4 not a pure DE for draft purposes,

Biug deal, a lot of people had Robert Mathis and Dwight Freeney projected as OLB. One, most of the draft sites get their information from the same company, two most draft sites do that with any DE who is under 270lbs.

also after screaming about the OL in SB 44 I stil cant understand not taking Scaffold
I assume you mean Saffold. One nobody screamed about the oline after SB 44. Polian said they did not play up to Colt standards and that he had projected Saffold as a RT, to which he said that he made a mistake with that (which is often misquoted and twisted so people think he said it was a mistake taking Hughes over Saffold)
Brown at RB was a sc hock I thought, but not the pick of Brown , the pick of a RB

Why was that a shock? The Colts had nobody behind Addai. Hart was coming off a serious injury in which he tore two ligaments in his knee. That year I thought the Colts would take Ziggy Hood in the 1st and Shonn Greene in the 2nd. Instead they took Brown in the first and Moala in the 2nd. Plus all off season Polian talked about in today's NFL you need a two back attack.
Link to post
Share on other sites

@coffeedrinker and 21isSuperman: You are both right. Sadly, you will have to re-post this information again in about 72 hours when everyone claims they know more about the draft than the Polians.

At the time, most of us were pretty excited about these picks. The SAME EXACT PEOPLE are now acting like they knew all along how mediocre they might turn out.

I love how no one mentions the 2011 Draft, where we basically knocked it out of the park in terms of crossing need and BPA. Our first pick may end up the best player on the line by this season's end, and the second pick will probably be rotating in soon. The third is a big, strong, disruptive DT who's already getting playing time, and the fourth has become a major rotational back for us.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • He would be slower in space than Walker. That got Walker fired.
    • Is it against the rules to play a 6-4 guy in the slot to run crossers and slants? Is .10 of a second difference not enough for 6-5 guy to overcome against a 6-0 guy that doesnt really know where you are going? With this type of size could be bully slot, bully X, big bullies everywhere then pound it down their throats with run game taboot. TY is a great Colt. The Ghost is also very fitting lets not forget, so he got paid to teach and mentor this year. We need a guy that cant be ghosted. We keep 6, Campbell plays TY, and we use our mismatches everywhere.  
    • I do not know. I'm not a GM, and don't try to play one on teh interwebs. ;)   This is what I do know-   Chris Ballard, Frank Reich and the assistant coaches knows a lot more about the abilities and skills and their fit of players on the roster than I do. The Pro Player scouting department knows a lot more about the same information concerning Free Agents and potential cut or for trade players than I do.  The Team physician, athletic trainers and medical staff know a lot more about roster health and the health and prognosis of our draft class and potential Free Agents on the radar than I do.   I would want to know everything that our teams Director of Player Personnel and the Director of the Pro Scouting department has on Free Agent tackles and how (much) and what areas are they better than any current player(s) on the team, and how their skill set better fits in with the team playbook that will be installed.   For injured free agents, I'd want full medical details. I'd want my team physician to examine and evaluate the player thoroughly, and have access to discuss in detail with their doctors and view their reports on procedures,treatments, and progress notes.  And I would be in frequent conversations with the owner and head coach about their input on the data that is collected.    Then hopefully make the best, rational decisions (or non-decisions) possible, maybe (hopefully) even one involving the salary capologist's assistance at some point, if necessary. Like Ballard, work diligently and smart, and avoiding the “living in a desperate world” scenario. And it's not about 'who' gets it right, it's just plain about getting it right.   What would you do?    
    • Im a bit curious on some thoughts about our big bodies. Do you all think it is absolutley necessary that these guys can nail every route on the tree? From what I gather its mostly about that. Would think having the size advabtage could negate some of that. Isnt that kinda the point? Contested or arrant throws happen on the perfect ran routes also. Seems we have a bit of trouble getting these guys on the field and producing.
    • I just watched the only tape available on Strachan online - vs West Virginia State. To be fair this seems like it was his worst game of the season, but he didn't impress me much. The CBs that cover him seem tiny and he cannot beat their press-man off the LOS. He gets jammed and his routes interrupted by physically playing defenders. There are several cases where he beats press-man, but it's mostly because of his superior athleticism rather than skill. He is a willing and physical blocker. Runs very limited route tree(mostly go routes and slants). He had some success on the move when he could release uninterrupted and the defender didn't have a chance to put his hands on him, but overall I would say he seems like a serious project.  Right now I cannot see him getting on an NFL roster. IMO it's very likely Ballard will try to sneak him on the practice squad unless he takes a big stept this off-season.     From his highlights tape - he seems pretty athletic against that competition. He does outrun defenders. He has good ballskils - tracks the ball well, catches it securely outside his frame, fights for it and attacks it in the air. You can see the appeal. I just am not sure he will ever be able to beat press-man and get open against NFL level defenders. People above compared him to DK Metcalf but Metcalf is a monster against press-man. He doesn't let defenders put a hand on him... he just overwhelms them with physicality and when they don't try to jam him, he is fast enough to outrun them.    My prediction for him is PS in 2021. 
  • Members

    • Grewich

      Grewich 3

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • throwing BBZ

      throwing BBZ 1,214

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Bleeds Blue

      Bleeds Blue 3

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Nadine

      Nadine 6,728

      Administrators
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • cjrulli

      cjrulli 143

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • PRnum1

      PRnum1 335

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Mr.Debonair

      Mr.Debonair 1,733

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Mel Kiper's Hair

      Mel Kiper's Hair 2,413

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • TheEdgeis1

      TheEdgeis1 8

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Colt.45

      Colt.45 436

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...