Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Which Free Agent O-Linemen, Fit Our scheme?


Recommended Posts

SPORTSTRAC.COM HIGHLIGHTS THESE OFFENSIVE LINEMAN(TACKLES) TO BE THE TOP FREE AGENTS AVAILABLE IN 2013....

 

 

Jermon Bushrod T UFA New Orleans TBD 
Ryan Clady T UFA Denver TBD  
Jake Long T UFA Miami TBD 
Andre Smith T UFA Cincinnati TBD
Will Svitek T UFA Atlanta TBD
Sebastian Vollmer T TBD

 

 

WHO DO YOU THINK FIT'S OUR SYSTEM, WHAT IS HIS STRENGTH/WEAKNESS, AND what should we give up to get him here?

 

 

          TACKLE                       GUARD                        CENTER                       GUARD                        TACKLE

RYAN CLADY /JERMON BUSHROD     LOUIS VASQUEZ         TODD MCCLURE          ANDY LEVITRE      ANTHONY CASTANZO / ANDRE SMITH

 

If "WIN NOW!", is the focus, let our rookies learn from these proven veterans, that still have roughly 7 years left in the tank. There is so much value in the free agent market for lineman this year, we can patch up all the holes in the front line, which will make evaluating our running backs alot easier....(again, just for olinemen only)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Vasquez is a strong as an Ox (39 bench press reps at Combine) he would fit in at Guard, I see Justice staying at RT though,

 

Dont want Andre Smith and his 19 combine reps and suddenly playing in a contract year self.

Levitre is Zone Blocking, (23 reps)

Clady Im not sure would fit either (24 reps)

Vollmer might, he certainly has the strength and technique but not sure about health (32 reps)

Bushrod Im not sold on especially strength wise (22 reps at Combine)

 

 

Out of all those I would target Vollmer if healthy or Vasquez-who I prefer

Link to post
Share on other sites
Vasquez is a strong as an Ox (39 bench press reps at Combine) he would fit in at Guard, I see Justice staying at RT though,

Dont want Andre Smith and his 19 combine reps and suddenly playing in a contract year self.

Levitre is Zone Blocking, (23 reps)

Clady Im not sure would fit either (24 reps)

Vollmer might, he certainly has the strength and technique but not sure about health (32 reps)

Bushrod Im not sold on especially strength wise (22 reps at Combine)

Out of all those I would target Vollmer if healthy or Vasquez-who I prefer

Why not both
Link to post
Share on other sites
Vasquez is a strong as an Ox (39 bench press reps at Combine) he would fit in at Guard, I see Justice staying at RT though,

Dont want Andre Smith and his 19 combine reps and suddenly playing in a contract year self.

Levitre is Zone Blocking, (23 reps)

Clady Im not sure would fit either (24 reps)

Vollmer might, he certainly has the strength and technique but not sure about health (32 reps)

Bushrod Im not sold on especially strength wise (22 reps at Combine)

Out of all those I would target Vollmer if healthy or Vasquez-who I prefer

I'd like Vasquez more than any other lineman, but the combine reps don't say much about them anymore, them reps are only relevant if none of them have added muscle in the last 4/5 years which they will have done.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I see Levitre mentioned a lot. Do the majority of nfl "talent evaluators" feel he has the skill and versatility to play at a high level regardless of scheme? I have not seen it really addressed in any of the articles discussing the FAs.

Link to post
Share on other sites

" Here, the size limitation becomes a disadvantage. Larger offensive linemen have extra weight that must be negotiated for a rusher to reach the quarterback – particularly in the middle of the offensive line. Zone blockers are at greater risk of simply being pushed back into the quarterback because their lack of weight and their inability to dictate leverage give the defender the advantage.

In short, the time window for passing tends to be smaller for a zone-block team than a man-block team. The passing offense must compensate for the time deficiency through other means."

http://www.rockytoptalk.com/2009/8/26/999603/the-passing-game-in-a-zone

Gavin is Totally Correct.

We Need man-blocking OG's for Pass Protection & Run Blocking. The O-Line scheme matters a great deal. Andy LeVitre is a good zone-blocking OG, so he would Not be a good fit on our O-Line.

Louis Vasquez would be a good fit at RG. Maybe Kevin Boothe at LG to complement. We also need to find a RT that would start. This would allow Justice to be the back-up. Vollmer is awesome, but his back problems make me wonder if its really worth it. ?

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Colts brought in a huge guard from the University of Tennessee a few years ago named McClendon.  He held the bench press record for the university at 645 lbs.  Unbelievable.  He had all of us drooling.  Released.  That and many other cases lead me to think very little of those bench reps.   

Link to post
Share on other sites
Vasquez is a strong as an Ox (39 bench press reps at Combine) he would fit in at Guard, I see Justice staying at RT though,

 

Dont want Andre Smith and his 19 combine reps and suddenly playing in a contract year self.

Levitre is Zone Blocking, (23 reps)

Clady Im not sure would fit either (24 reps)

Vollmer might, he certainly has the strength and technique but not sure about health (32 reps)

Bushrod Im not sold on especially strength wise (22 reps at Combine)

 

 

Out of all those I would target Vollmer if healthy or Vasquez-who I prefer

 

I wouldn't get too worked up about bench press totals.    Once they're over 20, I think they're mostly acceptable.

 

Scouts and other talent evaluators also focus on something they call 'funcational' football strength.   Does the player know how to use leverage, balance, hand and foot placement to gain advantage.    Good functional strength is thought of as important, if not moreso, than simple raw power.    That's nice, and certainly important,  but it's not the be-all and end-all for displaying strength.

Link to post
Share on other sites
The Colts brought in a huge guard from the University of Tennessee a few years ago named McClendon.  He held the bench press record for the university at 645 lbs.  Unbelievable.  He had all of us drooling.  Released.  That and many other cases lead me to think very little of those bench reps.   

That was a huge reach by polian. Kiffin acted surprised he was even drafted

Link to post
Share on other sites
Vasquez is a strong as an Ox (39 bench press reps at Combine) he would fit in at Guard, I see Justice staying at RT though,

 

Dont want Andre Smith and his 19 combine reps and suddenly playing in a contract year self.

Levitre is Zone Blocking, (23 reps)

Clady Im not sure would fit either (24 reps)

Vollmer might, he certainly has the strength and technique but not sure about health (32 reps)

Bushrod Im not sold on especially strength wise (22 reps at Combine)

 

Out of all those I would target Vollmer if healthy or Vasquez-who I prefer

 

 

The Colts brought in a huge guard from the University of Tennessee a few years ago named McClendon.  He held the bench press record for the university at 645 lbs.  Unbelievable.  He had all of us drooling.  Released.  That and many other cases lead me to think very little of those bench reps.   

 Doing a ton of reps of 225 at the combine has very little to do with pure strength.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Vasquez... hope we get with adding Raye to the FO today...

Levitre will be tagged / kept by the bills

Vollmer would be good, but doubt NE lets him go and as said above back problems.... Cost.?

Levitre won't be tagged for the Bills,

They have higher priorities.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Levitre won't be tagged for the Bills,

They have higher priorities.

Outside of Mckelvin, Jairus Byrd, Spencer Johnson and Rinehart and maybe Tarvaris Jackson I think most of there list of Free Agents are expendable and those that they keep should come cheap, also four of them are RFA, ask me the highest priority they should have besides looking for a franchise QB (I dont see there being one in the draft this year) is resigning Levitre, they are drafting high enough they can always replace Byrd with another top Safety if they absolutely have to but I dont think they will

Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's please eliminate any of the over priced guys, Jake Long, Clady, and Bushrod.  Personally, I don't see Clady or Bushrod going anywhere.  If we overpay for Long I will puke.  Poor long term investments.  With that being said, Andy Levitre and Sebastian Vollmer are on my wishlist.  Castonzo and Satele aren't going anywhere.  Although I wish Satele would just die.  So we really need Levitre and Vollmer to replace McGlynn and Justice as starters...Reitz will be fine for another year.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I love many of the suggestions I see here. Additionally, I also do not value bench reps as a criteria for O lineman. With that being said, I would absolutely LOVE to bring in Louis Vasquez at guard. He would immediately bolster the middle of our line, providing relief in both the run and pass game. Now at tackle, I have a bit of a different opinion. I think Clady is unattainable, maybe franchised. I do NOT want Long; he's a great leader but appears to be losing a step and is overpriced. The player I would love to see playing right tackle for the 2013-2014 Indianapolis colts is Phil Loadholt. The guy is an animal. Also, if he's good enough for AP he's good enough for me!

Link to post
Share on other sites
Outside of Mckelvin, Jairus Byrd, Spencer Johnson and Rinehart and maybe Tarvaris Jackson I think most of there list of Free Agents are expendable and those that they keep should come cheap, also four of them are RFA, ask me the highest priority they should have besides looking for a franchise QB (I dont see there being one in the draft this year) is resigning Levitre, they are drafting high enough they can always replace Byrd with another top Safety if they absolutely have to but I dont think they will

So they can easily replace the guy who might be the best free safety in football but they can't replace a guard? Sometimes your logic is...um....suspect

Link to post
Share on other sites
Let's please eliminate any of the over priced guys, Jake Long, Clady, and Bushrod.  Personally, I don't see Clady or Bushrod going anywhere.  If we overpay for Long I will puke.  Poor long term investments.  With that being said, Andy Levitre and Sebastian Vollmer are on my wishlist.  Castonzo and Satele aren't going anywhere.  Although I wish Satele would just die.  So we really need Levitre and Vollmer to replace McGlynn and Justice as starters...Reitz will be fine for another year.

Bushrod isn't in the same bracket as clady or long (if healthy). And the saints have already said resigning Bushrod won't be easy given their cap situation

Link to post
Share on other sites
Some odd posts here. And BTW Bench reps v Bench press are two different things. Regardless, anyone who does not first value strength in Olinemen is operating on Bill Polian time. And that has passed.

 

Most busts are workout warriors, that's why they are busts.  They get teams excited about their strength only to find out that they can't play the position.  An above poster was basing his value of linemen on their reps and we are just saying that in and of itself is not a very good indicator.  Nothing odd about that.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
Most busts are workout warriors, that's why they are busts.  They get teams excited about their strength only to find out that they can't play the position.  An above poster was basing his value of linemen on their reps and we are just saying that in and of itself is not a very good indicator.  Nothing odd about that.  

 

Forgive me but that is all internet warrior surmising/nonsense.

 

Nevertheless, we need powerful offensive linemen.

Link to post
Share on other sites
To an extent yes but Im sure the event would not be at the combine if it did not have a purpose

For lineman it is more of a muscular endurance test while your smaller guys can be a gauge of strength. They don't have time to test a guys 1 rep or 3 rep Max which would be a better assessment of chest strength.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Most busts are workout warriors, that's why they are busts. They get teams excited about their strength only to find out that they can't play the position. An above poster was basing his value of linemen on their reps and we are just saying that in and of itself is not a very good indicator. Nothing odd about that.

Most busts are workout warriors? What kind of workout warriors were Jerry hughes , Anthony Gonzalez or tony ugoh?

Link to post
Share on other sites
So they can easily replace the guy who might be the best free safety in football but they can't replace a guard? Sometimes your logic is...um....suspect

Sure, either guy can be replaced I just think Byrd can be more easily replaced at this time but I think they will find a way to resign both

Link to post
Share on other sites
Matt Slauson of the Jets is a good man blocking OG too along with Vasquez.

Not sold on picking up Slauson and it has nothing to do with talent, Slauson was in the mix with all the drama that came with the Jets even taking shots at former teammates Damien Woody and Tim Tebow

Link to post
Share on other sites
Some odd posts here. And BTW Bench reps v Bench press are two different things. Regardless, anyone who does not first value strength in Olinemen is operating on Bill Polian time. And that has passed.

 

Ryan Grigson gets paid to do what we're fantasizing about. So as a virtual GM, who do you think would help "our" team, and why?

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's the fourth quarter, your lungs burn, your ankles hurt, you got two fingers smashed between two helmets, your knee has a brace...and it barely helps, and you just took part in a 85 yard drive that stalled...and your kicker missed the FG.

 

Strength, leverage, technique, and playcalling all are very important, but what separates players, is the desire to finish the guy on the other side of the line despite facing the above scenarios. That is where BP failed, imo, at choosing O lineman. Grigs, with more money, less burdening contracts, and a good feel for what will work with what is currently on the roster, will  infuse some real nastiness. This draft and FA season will favor the offensive line.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yes, LOL !! I always remember it as "Ninety percent of the game is half mental." though. As my wife says - 'same thing, only different'.   Josh McDaniels is a great OC (really not sure about HC or as a person of integrity), but I'd much rather have Reich as HC (or even OC) over him. Colts were lucky to land him when JD backed out. I love the back story to the Frank Reich hire as well.   ********** "When seven NFL jobs came open by the end of Black Monday, the day after the 2017 regular season ended, Frank Reich called his agent with specific instructions. Leave me alone. “Going dark,” is the way Reich described it." Unlike McDaniels, unlike Matt Patricia of the Patriots, unlike Pat Shurmur of the Vikings – unlike even another Eagles assistant, quarterback coach John DeFilippo – Reich told his agent- “I'm focused on the task at hand,” he said. “That’s to help our team win playoff games and the Super Bowl. That meant no phone calls, no texts. Whether there was any activity or not (from interested teams calling), I was dark.” ***********   When McDaniels backed out of the job here in Indianapolis and Reich had won just his Super Bowl Ring, this is what Reich wanted his agent to do: "Nothing. Don’t call the Colts. Don’t text them. Don’t even butt-dial them (LOL)." But he really hoped the Colts would call him.   Meanwhile, Bill Polian, who has very close ties to both Irsay and Reich, heard of the JD news. He called up Jim Irsay. He said the answer to his dilemma is right there in front of him over in Philadelphia. Irsay then asked Polian to call Chris Ballard. Despite not even being on Ballard’s original top list of coaching candidates, Reich blew him away in a 10 hour interview. Once the other scheduled interviews with Dan Campbell and Leslie Frazier had wrapped up, the Colts knew. Frank Reich was their guy.   “I thought after I got done interviewing him, ‘My lord, what was I thinking?’” {not considering him in the first place} Ballard later admitted. Even Irsay acknowledged the Colts initially whiffed on not looking into Reich. “The more I think, ‘Jim, How come you are so stupid? How could you not have seen the clarity in this sooner.”   So even as the ex Colts GM, Bill Polian was still instrumental in the Colts/Reich head coach hiring. And I'm pleased with it.        
    • I see what you are saying.  If the Packers could get the 15th pick in the draft the packers would be crazy not to do it.    The Pats would be crazy to give up the 15th pick in the draft for Love.   
    • Honestly this might be my last draft because it fell pretty perfect, unless sometime of pre-draft trade happens. I also only went to 165 because I really don't know players after that.   Big priority for me was to trade down and I wanted to gain capital for next year for two reasons: 1. This draft has the least information in awhile about players 2. We are gonna lose a 1st or 2nd rounder next year and I wanted to supplement it by adding another 2nd round pick. I have seen many different ways to value future picks when doing the value, going off the CBS method of valuing them at the 32 pick of that round Bengals get 222 points (They drafted Kwity Paye after getting Sewell earlier) and Colts get 215 points.   So now to the picks: 38(From Bengals): Samuel Cosmi T: Happy with the pick was hoping he or Teven Jenkins would fall to me and I got one of them making the trade worth it to me. 54: Carlos Basham Jr.: Wasn't expecting him to fall to me, honestly I was more hoping for Payton Turner, but when I saw him sitting there it was a easy pick for me, fills the need at RE and the role of Autry of a DE that can play outside on early downs then jump inside for 3rd/passing downs. 127: Amari Rodgers: Honestly this was a tough pick, it was against him or Shaka Toney and I could of gone with either but I thought it might of been to early for Toney so decided to risk it and see if he fell to the next round. 165: James Wiggins: I wanted to add depth to the Safety position and Wiggins is a versatile player that fits in a split zone system, he has some injury history but Ballard has shown he is willing to take a risk on a Safety with past injury history (Blackmon, Hooker)   Also add in an extra 2nd in 2022   Overall I'm happy with it
    • Sam Cosmi reminds me of the conversation people were having about Kolton Miller a few years ago. Super toolsy but also raw. He may not be a top 20 lock like some have suggested. He can very well be a 1st round pick, but like Miller it will take a team falling in love with the upside.
    • That's the thing... why would an insane athlete with tons of starts in top program in college even be there at 21 for us to take if he was such a no brainer pick and had no warts?! At that spot you are juggling and weighing different sets of positives and negatives for each prospect and in some cases the negatives are almost as strong as the positives. I like Cosmi and I would be happy if we picked him to be our LT of the future, but we should be doing it with the expectation and knowledge that he has a ton of work to do to get to a point where he will be even solid starter, let alone a great one. For example... I am not a huge fan of Sam Tevi or Davenport... but I would not be shocked if one of them beat him for the starting spot year 1(if he was our pick)
  • Members

    • braveheartcolt

      braveheartcolt 1,394

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • ericAmerica

      ericAmerica 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Stephen

      Stephen 1,875

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • IPS Temp Admin

      IPS Temp Admin 0

      Administrators
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • FRW

      FRW 125

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • ClaytonColt

      ClaytonColt 291

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Swan Ronson

      Swan Ronson 46

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Onthefence

      Onthefence 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Barry Sears

      Barry Sears 1,324

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Colts1324

      Colts1324 446

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...