Yah I know you can’t compare them one to one exactly but I think a lot of people either overated luck based on potential or under rate brissett because he wasn’t some stud prospect. I hope as the season goes on we can bump this thread and update it so we can see how brissett compares to luck. Obviously I would rather have luck but I don’t think he’s head and shoulders above brissett either. I can’t wait to see how the season plays out either way.
I don't see Ballard giving up picks for either of those guys. Minkah is good, but Ramsey is a head case.
I also think Ya-Sin will figure it out and eventually be good. Desir and Moore are legit, but seem to be better in man.
In the nicest way, it's a bit of a pointless comparison. Too much variance between the two situations to do a week by week comparison. You could look overall at the end of the year for a better comparison but again different roster, different schedule and just the whole madness that is Luck retiring when he did.
I'd argue too that there are some better metrics to use. Go on PFR and look at stuff like adjusted net yards per attempt, TD%, INT% etc. Volume stats aren't really all that useful in a vacuum.