Which is probably why the colts are keeping peyton on the active roster to see if he can still play... When peyton gets a full bill of health which i think will be soon and probably before the season ends why should the colts draft andrew luck.. Fans need to remember peyton had two previous neck surgeries and the last one he played through the pain in his last season and he still got the colts to the playoffs, WHEN he is fully healthy with no pain peyton has a pretty good chance of putting up some really good numbers... If the colts draft luck with the way their salary cap is, some players will have to go because they will not be able to have to high end QB's on the roster without some fall out... which in turn would hurt the colts.... These are the three things i see that could very well happen. 1.Colts play peyton at the end of the season and dont draft luck 2. Colts try to reconstruct peytons contract, he doesnt have it so the colts draft luck and trade peyton. 3. Colts reconstruct peytons contract and still draft luck, yet they cannot fill some gaps on defense with TALENT... not players. http://content.usatoday.com/communities/gameon/post/2011/10/phil-simms-no-way-peyton-manning-will-let-colts-draft-andrew-luck/1 There are alot of threads on Luck, but i think this is a plausible question... Andrew Luck or Peyton Manning... because you cant have both.