All things equal, if every team/game was set up the same I would like Peyton. But things don't work that way and I am one of the few that think if you don't get a ring it is a let down. I would rather have the Giants and Eli's results and 2 rings during that time frame then all our dominant regular seasons and only 1 ring. I have the personality that makes it tough to have team that was capable of winning several more rings than they did.
For that reason I give the nod to Brady, based on results.