[Could Philip Rivers be in the Colts future?]

[What's the odds Luck un-retires?]

He's done. He was a weirdo to begin with. If he does come back, it'll be after Indy drafts a qb so he can go to another team. 

[Andrew Luck Perma Merge thread]

When a team repeatedly misdiagnose u, maybe we shouldn't blame the player. That being said, I hate Andrew Luck right now. Can't help it. He lied and than ran away. 

[Andrew Luck Perma Merge thread]

19 hours ago, superrep1967 said:

He's said many times how much he likes it here. 

He also said he'd be ready for week 1 many times. 

[Andrew Luck Perma Merge thread]

1 hour ago, aaron11 said:

 

hes still here, just had his daughter at ST Vincent hospital on November 12th.  have a relative that worked with them

Judging by the last pic I saw of him, I want someone to explain how he hasn't lost any muscle mass. Is he still working out? That would tell you he's done or not. 

[Are we basically the jags when they had leftwich?]

Leftwich was a stud when healthy. Had a cannon. And that Jags team was nowhere near as talented as this team. This should've been a 12-4 season at the least. 

[Are y'all still turn a blind eye to these coaches or what?]

Byron Leftwich outcoached them. Amazing. 

[Andrew Luck Perma Merge thread]

I find it odd that this guy continues to live in the city. Someone on twitter said they saw him at whole foods. I thought for sure he would go to some place in Europe to relocate. 

[Andrew Luck Perma Merge thread]

41 minutes ago, Orioles22 said:

We can talk about drafting quarterbacks, but the Colts could be chasing a good quarterback for the next 20 years. The most obvious way to fix most of our problems is to hope Andrew is healed up and ready to go again by next season.

U ask me, he awes this fanbase a return. He has taken zero responsibility for his own actions. I'm going to be ready for wk 1. Then the week before retirement he's doing qb drills with a smile on his face in front of fans. Then just abruptly retires and says he chose himself or some crap. Come to think lf it, just draft Tua. 

[Hypothetically, Andrew Luck comes back next year, could you even get a 2nd rnder for him?]

1 hour ago, jvan1973 said:

He isn't coming back.   The end

I thought this until I saw that pic of him. He's still in a weight room somewhere. I think he didn't want to be a depressed weirdo around his pregnant wife. As a competitor, he can't be content with his career ending like that.  Will be interesting.

[Hypothetically, Andrew Luck comes back next year, could you even get a 2nd rnder for him?]

19 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

If Andrew decided to come back,    Jacoby would be traded

There is no way. I just can't see that. This is why I made this thread, I've seen enough that Jacoby can be better than Dak. And then its a Dak/Romo situation. Romo was better than Dak, but you just couldn't overlook the results. Barring injury, this team should go at least 11-5. A bye is even a possibility. You can't trade Jacoby. 

 

20 minutes ago, Four2itus said:

Troll thread......

 

answering question as if serious....

Thanks for contributing

[Hypothetically, Andrew Luck comes back next year, could you even get a 2nd rnder for him?]

He basically quit on the team. Its no doubt he could've been a great one, but he left the best team he's ever had. He abandoned them. But teams like Chicago, Oak, Wash, Cincy, Tampa, and probably some other team I can't think of will want him. But not for a 1. 

[Colts QB Andrew Luck spent the day hanging at the team’s facility]

Jacoby Brissett may be a SB winning qb next yr. Why are some of you talking about upgrade?

[Colts QB Andrew Luck spent the day hanging at the team’s facility]

8 hours ago, ReMeDy said:

 

Agreed. His wife tells him what to do, and Luck agrees, just like his wife told him to retire.

If he was as moody and depressed as he claims he was in 2016-17, then I can understand his wife not wanting that during her pregnancy. Luck is the type not even get a prenup. The guy is just weird. If he comes back, it would be interesting. I get the feeling the team really likes Jacoby. And he's never quit on them. I don't think all of his teammates are ok with how he left. Luck doesn't seem like the type to want to go play somewhere else either.

[Colts QB Andrew Luck spent the day hanging at the team’s facility]

6 hours ago, Smonroe said:

Here’s my fantasy scenario:  Week 10 and the Colts are in the hunt for the division.  They’re playing solid D and the running game is strong.  They look like a sure SB contender. 
 

Then tragedy strikes, Jacoby is injured and out for the year.  
 

The guys on the team convince Andrew to come back and “manage” the games for them. The team isn’t on his shoulders, but everyone thinks they can win the SB with him steering the ship.

 

Hey, a guy can dream, right!

Wishing for Jacoby to get hurt isn't cool. Jacoby has dreams too and seems like a good dude. Luck is an oddball. He looks perfectly satisfied that he has zero legacy and will only be remembered for how he retired. Manning and the other greats basically had to be dragged away from football. 

[Week 4 impressions: Brissett]

Can the mods just make the former qbs name appear like a curse word? ****** ****

[The reasons why Andrew Luck will return next year.]

On 8/31/2019 at 7:41 AM, coltfaninnewyork said:

Get this straight the colts own his rights 

If Brissett gets paid. No way they can pay Luck. And imagine the circus if he came back to the Colts under those circumstances. It may only take a 2 to get him.

[Luck’s Newspaper Ad]

The amount of time I wasted defending this quitter to seahawks fans sickens me and I want that time back. 

[The reasons why Andrew Luck will return next year.]

It's going to be so interesting if Dak sucks and Jerry Jones comes begging Luck out of retirement. 

[The reasons why Andrew Luck will return next year.]

I'll be ready wk 1. The man lies. 

 

If Jacoby balls out, Luck is going to SF,Oak, or Dallas in a trade. 

[Gil Brandt with Luck Facts]

There is no way he's a HOFer after quitting the way he did. I thought he best football was ahead, screwed the pooch on that one. 

[JMV having traces of doubt in his opinion on this situation]

I don't see Irsay letting Luck keep 24mil in bonus money if there is no injury. 

[Luck Retires/ The timing of it all... (merge)]

11 minutes ago, presto123 said:

How long from now will it take for Andrew to sit down for an interview? Any guesses?

He only did interviews because he was obligated to. He doesn't strike me as the kind of person that wants attention. He definitely wont do any interviews during the season. 

[Luck Retires/ The timing of it all... (merge)]

Its a shame Indy doesn't have investigative journalists. Becuz it is more to this. And no way did Irsay and co just let him keep 24mil out of the kindness of their heart. They probably didn't want to get sued for a couple hundred mill for malpractice. 

 

I still don't see why Luck would be on the field at LOS doing qb drills if he was going to retire. 

[Why Boo [Merge]]

41 minutes ago, threeflight said:

This.

 

Especially to quit 2 weeks before the season starts?  It isn't like he is laid up with an ACL. He was just shown on film running around completely fine.

 

I really find that inexcusable.  Especially since he was already paid this season.

What did JJ say?