I would say my time definitely that is since 1977 when I first started watching at 6 years old. Even if you included Unitas and Graham which is all-time, Rodgers would still be top 10 IMO. He has won 4 League MVP's and a SB + his stats are great. Hard to keep him out of the top 10. Not to mention his talent. I go by their play not who I like. So, I am not biased when doing a QB list. A lot of people hate Rodgers but that has nothing to do with his play.
I have Peyton 3rd and Unitas 5th, all-time. FWIW. You may have different opinions and that is fine. I would love to see your top 10 list, just to get a different perspective. .
To add to this, I watched most of the great QB's of the 70's and despite Bradshaw winning 4 SB's, he isn't in my top 10. He is more top 15ish to me. Great but was on loaded teams with arguably the greatest defenses of all-time.