I am so with you Nate. Peyton is done for year and kerry just ain't gonna cut it for us here in Indy Garrard could definitely win us some games and at least we could have ticking running game all in one guy
Both of them are important to the team. But if I had to pick between Mathis or Wayne, I would have to go with Mathis. Manning has shown that he can move the offense and do well with anyone as a receiver. But If Mathis is not there to get to the quarterback then Manning won't get the ball in his hands as much so it wouldn't matter if Wayne was still with the Colts or not. Don't get me wrong I would love to see Mathis and Wayne in a Colts uniform until they retire.