He's a game manager. He's not Andrew Luck that can pull a game out his butt. He managed those games pretty damn efficiently for what he had to work with. And then you see what he does last week with a competent coaching staff and offense.
I hope it continues. It may not... but to say we don't have sample of him performing is asinine.
My top 5 of all-time would be:
1. Jerry Rice - Total package and has all the records + 3 SB wins.
2. Michael Irvin by my test was #2. What he did off the field has nothing to do with how he played. He was the heart and soul of the Dallas Cowboys, won 3 SB's, and once he got injured the Cowboys were never the same. He had the best hands I have ever seen as far as running a 10-15 yard route.
3. I put Marvin Harrison here, loved his consistency, speed, and hands.
4. Randy Moss - Freak of nature, unreal speed and dangerous deep weapon.
5. Cris Carter - All he did was catch touchdowns
-I voted other because Irvin is #2 IMO.