Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

bap1331

Andrew Luck Rookie Card

Recommended Posts

I try to collect all the Peyton Manning cards but ever since he left I got dismotivated...lol. I am still interested in the Peyton Manning SP Authentic rookie card which I think is the most expensive Peyton one out there (even more now that he left)

109427.JPG?v=20111113162748

It was $1500 a couple months back.

But now I want to collect the Andrew Luck rookie card but I dont know where to start. Im guessing that if SP Authentic holds the most expensive Peyton rookie card, wouldnt it be the same for Andrew Luck? Does SP Authetic still exist? I cant find one for Luck.

Any advice would help on collecting cards. Which brand should I get for Luck?

Im really interested in this one though:

FRONT_large_3235069.png

What do you think would be the best Andrew Luck card?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2012 Sp Authentic will not be releases until about Dec, or Jan. Upper Deck has lost a huge foothold in the card collecting cirlcles. They no longet have a NFL liscense, which maens players can only be pictured in College uniforms. Pannini National treasures is a higher end product then Sp Authentic. It also has yet to be realsed for the upcoming season. The best 2012 products already out there at this time is Topps Inception, Pannini Elite.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow. In a year, that card will be enough to buy more cards like that.

Question: How do people put prices on cards and signatures like that? Do they get together and say "How about 1000? $1000 sound okay to you guys?"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow. In a year, that card will be enough to buy more cards like that.

Question: How do people put prices on cards and signatures like that? Do they get together and say "How about 1000? $1000 sound okay to you guys?"

Supply and demand.

It's only worth what others are willing to play.

Best way to gauge actual value of cards like this is looking at recent ended auctions on ebay. In my opinion that is more accurate than a price guide.

I did see some new rookie cards at a show at a mall that I didn't even know was happening, but back to the point a lot of the cards are out there are kinda horrible looking since they lack Logos and the NFL license.

For example:

5G95K55M93M23J23H1c7166b4eaefa4eb15d2.jpg

Others are nicer because they have the license and such.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2012 Sp Authentic will not be releases until about Dec, or Jan. Upper Deck has lost a huge foothold in the card collecting cirlcles. They no longet have a NFL liscense, which maens players can only be pictured in College uniforms. Pannini National treasures is a higher end product then Sp Authentic. It also has yet to be realsed for the upcoming season. The best 2012 products already out there at this time is Topps Inception, Pannini Elite.

Thanks for the info. Im guessing SP Authentic wants the real game action for photos on the cards, right?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the info. Im guessing SP Authentic wants the real game action for photos on the cards, right?

That cant be, since they do not have a nfl liscense. They just try and space out the releases over the full season. Sp Authentic is usually one of the last to hit the market.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Supply and demand.

It's only worth what others are willing to play.

Best way to gauge actual value of cards like this is looking at recent ended auctions on ebay. In my opinion that is more accurate than a price guide.

I did see some new rookie cards at a show at a mall that I didn't even know was happening, but back to the point a lot of the cards are out there are kinda horrible looking since they lack Logos and the NFL license.

For example:

5G95K55M93M23J23H1c7166b4eaefa4eb15d2.jpg

Others are nicer because they have the license and such.

Thanks for the answer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm currently waiting for the Topps Finest auto/jersey patch. They should be out sometime in Aug. However, I might wait to see how the SP Auths or SPXs (if they even make them) Andrew Luck rc cards fair.

I really wanted one of those PM SP Auth rcs but they where just to expensive.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not big into any of the current Luck rc cards thus I'm kind of waiting...

yea but might as well get them all since we dont know which one will be the expensive one. lol. Especially his rookie year. For Peyton, I have the ones where he won the Super Bowls and want the rookie card mainly. Wasnt too interested in the rest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hope u find it.i know.if you are anything.like i did to help my brother to find a special penny.we looked and looked through our milk money every day.then we found that penny.then one of my brother ' s jelious friends stole it.then i stole it back.because i knew his classroom.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The basic Andrew Luck RC that will be worth having is his one from Topps Bowman Chrome. Everything else is ok but the Chrome stuff always holds value over them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yea but might as well get them all since we dont know which one will be the expensive one. lol. Especially his rookie year. For Peyton, I have the ones where he won the Super Bowls and want the rookie card mainly. Wasnt too interested in the rest.

Yeah I hear ya, usually you can put your $ on the SP Authentic for some of the top tier rc cards, but they come out pretty late. There are also some good playoff series cards. It's tough because if you get a card right now before many of the others come out you might end up seeing one you like better but if you're a major collector you can just go grab one of his other cards down the road.

The playoff prestige auto rc looks like a very nice card and are available right now. Also the Topps Finest Jersey/patches should be out sometime soon. The pic of the Finest jers/patch I think is just a concept but it should look similar.

27641306.jpg

In my case it's very tough which one to choose because I'll probably just buy one premium Andrew Luck rc card. I'll probably wait a bit to explore my options and I'm really looking forward to see how the SP Authentic turn out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The basic Andrew Luck RC that will be worth having is his one from Topps Bowman Chrome. Everything else is ok but the Chrome stuff always holds value over them.

If your lucky enough to grab a pack that isn't already bowed. Hate those dang cards. I've got boxes and boxes of chrome, not a single one of them is straight.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If your lucky enough to grab a pack that isn't already bowed. Hate those dang cards. I've got boxes and boxes of chrome, not a single one of them is straight.

I think it's because of the finish on the card that makes it that way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK, so I have an autographed Peyton rookie card, as well as an autographed Eli rookie and an autographed Archie rookie card. They're all in phenomenal condition, but I haven't sent them in to be graded yet. I'm hoping they're worth some $$, but time will tell. As I check out some of the going rates for Andrew autographed rookies, they go anywhere from $100-1000 and up. Think the Manning family rookie cards are worth anything?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Popular Now

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I don't understand the original post, lol.  I don't think Ballard screwed anything up.  I also don't think it was on him to keep Pagano, imo.  Apparently, no one knew the extent of Luck's shoulder.  I seriously doubt any coach would come in with this young, injury decimated team without their starting QB and expect to do much.  Not saying that Pagano needs to stay.  I personally he's surpassed his time here and the longer he stays the worse the locker room may get.  It seems like the team just has no fight in them, contrary to what he says.  I saw several players attempt to soft tackle, walking around on the field, little effort.     Next year pending on if Luck gets healthy, Colts are likely poised to have high draft picks.  Ballard will most likely bring in his own coaching staff unless Irsay wants to keep Pagano and co around for some reason.  Unfortunately this was supposed to be a rebuild year but just due to the injuries, lack of experience it makes it very difficult.  
    • Idk if you actually watched the play but hooker got targeted directly at his needs on the Sideline when the guy could've went way higher..he threw himself toward hookers knees and he didn't even have time to brace because it was a blind side hit and you're gonna blame him for getting injured?
    • Wonder if we could fire Ted right now at least.   Maybe Chuck could call the D or something.   Get us back to playing that Rex Ryan style like we used to play. I'm just thinking out loud I guess.  Just reaching for something.  Anything
    • Not anyone we have (except maybe Schottenheimer) and no one would want to come here. We have to let this train through hell get all the way through and wait and see who Ballard prefers at HC. 
    •   You're partially correct. Some of what I am saying (and have said) does walk the line of politics. However, while it might be easy to lump everything together; it does not all fit in the same box.    A lot of what I am talking about is a deep emotional connection to a football team.   I am trying very hard to walk the line about what is acceptable to discuss on this forum, and the waters can get very muddy. I do believe my statements holds true. Ignoring a lot of things happening lately won't fix anything. A person has to take action, within the confinements of the rules, and also within the parameters of moral values.   I believe the same can be said for political reasons or for undesired results of the product on the field. In my mind, the product on the field is not a reason for scaling back emotional investment. However, the politics obviously hit a different nerve for some of us. Not everyone will agree on these issues. It is also very tough to balance them once we understand a persons position.   Nevertheless, actions through participation or lack of participation speak very loud. it is a bottom line business, and it takes both active fans and talented players for the marriage to work. 
  • Members

    • krunk

      krunk 8,133

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • ColtsAC

      ColtsAC 47

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • will426

      will426 808

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • indy1888

      indy1888 329

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Cynjin

      Cynjin 1,750

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • CurtisPainterAll-Star

      CurtisPainterAll-Star 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Mr. Irrelevant

      Mr. Irrelevant 689

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Hooksalot

      Hooksalot 6

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • XxGoosexX

      XxGoosexX 23

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • VaAllDay757

      VaAllDay757 308

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active: