Sign in to follow this  
coltsfeva

Worst Coaching Decision

Worst Coaching Decision  

106 members have voted

  1. 1. Which is the worst Coaching Decision?

    • Chuck Pagano - Fake Punt Against Pats
      38
    • Bill Belicheck- 4th and 2 against Colts
      8
    • Pete Carol - Throwing on 2nd and Goal (SB) against Pats
      48
    • Dan Quinn - Passing at the 20 with an 8 point lead
      17


Recommended Posts

coltsfeva    462

Just saw a replay of the 2009 game against the Pats in Indy. Where the Colts came back from a 31-7 deficit and won it when Bill Belicheck went for it on 4th and 2 from the NE 30. The Colts score a TD and leave Brady 13 seconds. Colts 35-34.....BEAUTIFUL! Anyway I know how much we all loved the fake punt a few years later against the same team but it got me wondering which call was worse. Consider the poor execution was in part, why the play failed Pagono said we wouldn't see that play again. So here's my poll and I'm curious to see How people answer.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Buddy Lee    126

The fake punt was an ill-conceived play run with Griff Whalen who hadn't even practiced it. It had no chance. At least the others had a chance.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Seahawks passing from the 2 was a much bigger moment in a much bigger game, but that fake whatever it was that the Colts ran was the worst thing I have ever seen in all my years of watching football...

 

:yuk:  :facepalm:  :thmdown:

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chad72    6,435

In terms of probability of the play working, the fake punt had to be the lowest but in terms of field position and what was at stake, the Seahawks play calling was probably the worst.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
twfish    1,100

The thing with the fake punt is the game wasn't riding on It, it was an attempt to gain momentum so I think the other weigh far heavier

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That Guy    580

Fake punt was bad play design, bad call, bad execution, embarrassing results.

 

Belichick made a good call against the Colts; it just didn't get the results he wanted.

 

Pete Caroll made a risky call, but he has always called plays on intuition.

 

Quinn made a series of blunders in that series, but it was bad execution that got them into trouble.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2006Coltsbestever    10,394

I voted Pete, that was just so ridiculously dumb and I cant even put it into words. You have the ball at the 1 and even have a Timeout left and have Lynch. Then you set up a play to Pass over the middle in traffic. I blame Russell Wilson as well though, he could've audibled out of it and did the right thing by either running himself or just throwing a fade. That was just a huge cluster! It cost a team a sure SB win so that is the worst play by far IMO.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
SilentHill    2,714

It's easily this:

 

Pete Carol - Throwing on 2nd and Goal (SB) against Pats

 

The fake punt was not designed to go off like that, Colt Anderson & Griff Whalen messed it up, sure it was one of the worst plays in NFL history, but it was not executed as it was designed.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2006Coltsbestever    10,394
18 minutes ago, SilentHill said:

It's easily this:

 

Pete Carol - Throwing on 2nd and Goal (SB) against Pats

 

The fake punt was not designed to go off like that, Colt Anderson & Griff Whalen messed it up, sure it was one of the worst plays in NFL history, but it was not executed as it was designed.

I agree, our fake Punt isn't even close to Pete's call. That cost the Seahawks a sure SB win. Our Fake Punt was just a play in the middle of a Regular Season among other bad executed plays by a lot of teams that had no bearing on winning the SB.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

The Seahawks passing from the 2 was a much bigger moment in a much bigger game, but that fake whatever it was that the Colts ran was the worst thing I have ever seen in all my years of watching football...

 

:yuk:  :facepalm:  :thmdown:

Mine too that was awful.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
100GFB    723

I feel that the Seahawks call was good just wrong play.  Maybe Carroll should have called a fade.  Maybe but we'll never know.  Possibly Carroll went for it, guts and glory because of what happened in the playoff game with GB.  I felt GB had the game but went conservative in their play calling and Coach Carroll didn't want any of that!  We're here to win and being conservative is out of the question.  If the play worked he'd be a coaching genius but it didn't and now he's viewed as the town *!  What about Colts/Steelers as Steelers wanted to put it away but Bettis fumbled.  Darn should the Steelers have passed?  Same as the Seahawks, if they ran and fumbled, should they have passed?  We will never know.  I/we can't predict the future or 'what if' but we can all predict the past. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2006Coltsbestever    10,394
5 minutes ago, 100GFB said:

I feel that the Seahawks call was good just wrong play.  Maybe Carroll should have called a fade.  Maybe but we'll never know.  Possibly Carroll went for it, guts and glory because of what happened in the playoff game with GB.  I felt GB had the game but went conservative in their play calling and Coach Carroll didn't want any of that!  We're here to win and being conservative is out of the question.  If the play worked he'd be a coaching genius but it didn't and now he's viewed as the town *!  What about Colts/Steelers as Steelers wanted to put it away but Bettis fumbled.  Darn should the Steelers have passed?  Same as the Seahawks, if they ran and fumbled, should they have passed?  We will never know.  I/we can't predict the future or 'what if' but we can all predict the past. 

I respect your opinion but I am 99.9% certain Lynch walks into the endzone if Pete calls a run. He gets my vote easily. Had they thrown a fade that would've been much different as well, Pete called the worst play possible.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
100GFB    723
1 minute ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

I respect your opinion but I am 99.9% certain Lynch walks into the endzone if Pete calls a run. He gets my vote easily. Had they thrown a fade that would've been much different as well, Pete called the worst play possible.

Now looking back with 8 in the box a quick slant was not a good call but my main point is not pass/run but Coach didn't want to go conservative.  I respect him for going guts and glory!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, VaAllDay757 said:

Yeah that fake punt will forever pi$$ me off

 

Did you watch it live?  Were you also jumping up and down yelling at the TV?  I mean, I get worked up during games, but I have never yelled at the TV like I did when that happened...

 

:hairout: :censored:  :argh:

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2006Coltsbestever    10,394
3 minutes ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

 

Did you watch it live?  Were you also jumping up and down yelling at the TV?  I mean, I get worked up during games, but I have never yelled at the TV like I did when that happened...

 

:hairout: :censored:  :argh:

I seen it live and thought it was ridiculous but it didn't cost a SB win. Had that happened in the AFC Title Game I would've probably croaked.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

I seen it live and thought it was ridiculous but it didn't cost a SB win. Had that happened in the AFC Title Game I would've probably croaked.

 

OMG, Haha.  Yeah, can you imagine if the Colts had done this in the AFCCG, or God forbid, the SB?

 

I probably would have croaked too!  Either a massive brain aneurysm or heart attack, or both at the same time.

 

It would definitely be the runaway winner for this thread.  Hands down.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BR-549    1,077

We called the "Chuck Punt Formation" Polecat in HS.  Nothing new, it has been around.  We had various alignments and several plays off each alignment.  Rarely did we use it for anything other than 2 pt conversions and I want to say it was +80% successful.  Occasionally mid-field, but only if we were leading.

 

Never did I expect to see it at the college level much less in the NFL.  When I saw them (Colts) line up I was a little surprised but I thought it would be interesting to see pro athletes execute the play.  Patriots sniffed it out immediately though and it was doomed before it even started.  Should have had a "abort" signal and shifted into normal alignment.  Maybe they did and just blew it, I don't know one way or the other.  Shameful day to be a Colts fan either way, lol.

 

I am with others though that the Pete Carol call and what it cost is the worst of the ones listed.  You just have to run it in that situation, especially given the down and the back they had (Lynch).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
csmopar    3,132
2 hours ago, Mr. Irrelevant said:

Why do coaches always do stupid things against the Patriots? That is the question!

Because of their success, opposing coaches try to get cute and try to outsmart Hoodie..... but what happens is using they overthink themselves and hoodie knows this, so he's prepared for those types of plays. Very rarely does hoodie make a dumb decision

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, csmopar said:

Because of their success, opposing coaches try to get cute and try to outsmart Hoodie..... but what happens is using they overthink themselves and hoodie knows this, so he's prepared for those types of plays. Very rarely does hoodie make a dumb decision

 

Yeah, the one time he did do something dumb was when he tried to get cute against Peyton Manning on that 4th and 2.

 

That should be a huge compliment and career highlight for Manning!  haha

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Smonroe    7,577

There's no comparison to a coach losing a SB.  It's possible the Seahawks could have lost, but the Falcons had the game on ice.   Both horrible decisions.  

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2006Coltsbestever    10,394
24 minutes ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

 

OMG, Haha.  Yeah, can you imagine if the Colts had done this in the AFCCG, or God forbid, the SB?

 

I probably would have croaked too!  Either a massive brain aneurysm or heart attack, or both at the same time.

 

It would definitely be the runaway winner for this thread.  Hands down.

Yeah it would've been #1 but Pete's was worse because it was the SB IMO. The 4th and 2 Belichick called, I don't blame him. Peyton was a robot that season and we were a machine. BB knew if we got the ball back it was over LOL. A 1st down gives the Pats a win.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RockThatBlue    6,382
42 minutes ago, Lucky Colts Fan said:

 

Did you watch it live?  Were you also jumping up and down yelling at the TV?  I mean, I get worked up during games, but I have never yelled at the TV like I did when that happened...

 

:hairout: :censored:  :argh:

I was on the phone with a friend and I went silent for a few minutes because I was confused at what we were trying to accomplish with that. Even today I'm still confused, especially with McAfees comments about it.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
coltsfeva    462
26 minutes ago, Smonroe said:

There's no comparison to a coach losing a SB.  It's possible the Seahawks could have lost, but the Falcons had the game on ice.   Both horrible decisions.  

Worst part is NE getting two more rings. Yeah, they did what they had to do to win, but those were gifts! ☹️

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nesjan3    355

Its a toss up between the Falcons collapse and the Seahawks play, but the Falcons collapse was a series of bad decisions, if your looking for worst coaching decision in a specific play its the Seahawks by a mile. Throwing over the middle on the 1 yard line with a timeout in the pocket in the superbowl is absolutely crazy, not to mention you have the biggest bruiser of a RB in the NFL at the time. Just absolutely beyond stupid thing.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OLD FAN MAN    418

if all of those plays had worked people would have said they were great calls. every play is a gamble, the ones that work are good plays, the ones that dont work are bad plays

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
southwest1    10,377

Your topic headline is misleading to me because without reading your explanation it creates the impression that fans are being asked to select an INDY coach & select the worst blunder executed in Colts history. 

 

Personally, Jim Caldwell's inability to make halftime adjustments drove me nuts & I'm still shocked he won a SB in Baltimore. I really have no problems with Chuck next to Caldwell who is a good QB coach & not really HC material to me at all. I like the guy & he's been decent in Detroit, but I never would have hired him in Motor City to run an entire football program. OC fine, but HC, not on your life. Can Caldwell help Matthew Stafford beat Aaron Rodgers in the NFC North? Nope. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rockywoj    857

Belichick's decision to go for it rather than punt was an utter FAIL!

 

And at the same time, a great tribute to his respect for Manning.  He said afterward the motivation was he didn't want to give the ball back into Manning's hand, couldn't trust the defence to stop him..   Such an amazing tribute to Peyton Manning's greatness ..l just love that Manning TOTALLY got into the head of one of the all-time greatest coaches, causing said coach to have a total brain fart out of fear.  Love it!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GoColts8818    7,290

Only one of these can you truly point to and say that cost their team the Super Bowl.  Even the Falcons didn't lose the Super Bowl on that single play. 

 

The Seahawks throwing on second and goal when they had maybe the best short yardage back in the NFL was the worst call.  Even the Colts with Peyton Manning knew to run in that situation (see the end of the 06 AFCCG)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
southwest1    10,377
43 minutes ago, rockywoj said:

Belichick's decision to go for it rather than punt was an utter FAIL!

 

And at the same time, a great tribute to his respect for Manning.  He said afterward the motivation was he didn't want to give the ball back into Manning's hand, couldn't trust the defence to stop him..   Such an amazing tribute to Peyton Manning's greatness ..l just love that Manning TOTALLY got into the head of one of the all-time greatest coaches, causing said coach to have a total brain fart out of fear.  Love it!

I don't really consider the decision to go for it by BB an utter fail or jedi mind trick by #18 because in 2009 Manning had a ton of 4th QTR touchdowns that season. Bill knew he had to go for it because Manning was a machine on offense back then like a field general terminator. 

 

It really boiled down to the refs saying that Kevin Faulk fumbled the ball or failed to maintain control of it. A judgement call. I'm glad INDY won naturally, but it wasn't a mistake on Bill's part. It was a calculated risk that came up short. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BOTT    9,498
7 hours ago, southwest1 said:

I don't really consider the decision to go for it by BB an utter fail or jedi mind trick by #18 because in 2009 Manning had a ton of 4th QTR touchdowns that season. Bill knew he had to go for it because Manning was a machine on offense back then like a field general terminator. 

 

It really boiled down to the refs saying that Kevin Faulk fumbled the ball or failed to maintain control of it. A judgement call. I'm glad INDY won naturally, but it wasn't a mistake on Bill's part. It was a calculated risk that came up short. 

I'm happy to say I thought the refs blew that call.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rockywoj    857
7 hours ago, southwest1 said:

I don't really consider the decision to go for it by BB an utter fail or jedi mind trick by #18 because in 2009 Manning had a ton of 4th QTR touchdowns that season. Bill knew he had to go for it because Manning was a machine on offense back then like a field general terminator. 

 

It really boiled down to the refs saying that Kevin Faulk fumbled the ball or failed to maintain control of it. A judgement call. I'm glad INDY won naturally, but it wasn't a mistake on Bill's part. It was a calculated risk that came up short. 

Respectfully, I disagree.  It's not like NE had a trash defence.  You punt that ball and put it on your defense to stop the Colts from driving the length of the field.  It was a boneheaded coaching decision.  Belichick got way too cute / ballsy for his own good.  It's exactly like Dungy said at the time.  You punt that ball, every time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Is this a serious comment or a joke?
    •   You should try using Google before posting something like this.  Browns had over $100 Million cap space in March.   Besides, in Madden you can just turn the salary cap OFF.  Boom.  Problem solved. 
    •   Why?      Why should Pagano be gone over an 0-3 start with our top players out?   We're not losing because of Pagano, we're losing because of a lack of talent, especially at key positions like QB.      You're likely going to get what you want, Pagano's last year.    But it may not happen for a few more months.    Then again, you can never tell with a new GM who may decide to make a statement.    
    • I know this isn't the best time for Colts fans.  A SB looks a far way off at the moment.  We are definitely not at the top of the mountain right now, and things are getting a little scrappy in some of the threads.  But I just wanted to thank everyone for their contributions.  Whether you're a new member posting out of frustration with the current situation, or a seasoned vet that has seen this rodeo before and feels the need to defend the Shoe, or some mix of both or all of those (?), I enjoy reading what you have to say (usually).  I may not like all of your opinions (because let's face it, no two people in the world are going to agree about absolutely EVERYTHING) but I respect you for sharing your opinions with all of us.  Let's all just be thankful that we can have this civil discourse as a fanbase.   Even if we lose to the Browns... ()  at home... () ... ... ...   We still have it better than many others, in more ways than one. 
    •  Might not be quite that high but we are looking at just under 73M per Overthecap for 2018, thats not including us rolling over some of the 20M in cap we still have this yr, nor does it factor in any cuts that may happen. Chances are we roll over at least 10M. It also only accounts for a 3M increase in the cap, which isnt official yet (could be more). So 85-90M in cap for this offseason is very well possible. 
  • Welcome New Members

  • Members