Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Irsay: Chosing Between Luck And Griffin Similar To Peyton And Leaf

bap1331
 Share

Recommended Posts

bap1331 Walk On

bap1331

Posted
Posted

Um...i font think that will be the case again. Leaf was pretty obvious not to be the choice. I remember they said that when they asked Leaf what he was going to do with the contract money. He said go to Vegas. Peyton said hit the playbook. They will both be very good in my opinion. Griffin justbreminds me of Cam Newton mixed with Ben Roethlisberger, and Mcnabb. His arm is scary. Its kinda like makes you want him to be chosen over Luck. Id be happy with either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TWR1993 Walk On

TWR1993

Posted
Posted

I would also be happy with either but I would prefer the Colts taking Luck over Griffin because with Luck your getting i guy who most experts think can come in and contribute from day 1. While with Griffin you have a guy with a lot of potential but a guy who is going to be a project and might take a while to really adjust to playing in the NFL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Flash7 Team Captain

Flash7

Posted
Posted

I would also be happy with either but I would prefer the Colts taking Luck over Griffin because with Luck your getting i guy who most experts think can come in and contribute from day 1. While with Griffin you have a guy with a lot of potential but a guy who is going to be a project and might take a while to really adjust to playing in the NFL.

I think that most people feel that RGIII is a project. I think he may be more than just a project. From what we've been able to see from Cam Newton is that when he ran out of options to throw to, he was very effective as a runner. RGIII has that ability as well. He's very elusive and incredibly fast. He may be able to keep the chains moving.He is also a very good passer and may be further along than most would give him credit for. The problem is that he will not be able to sustain this type of play with his size. Even Tebow at 6'3" and 235lbs has taken a beating.

Interestingly enough, Luck is 6'4" and 240lbs, and he runs a faster 40 than Tebow. I vote Luck over RGIII, but feel that RGIII can be incredible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
oldunclemark Walk On

oldunclemark

Posted
Posted

I think that most people feel that RGIII is a project. I think he may be more than just a project. From what we've been able to see from Cam Newton is that when he ran out of options to throw to, he was very effective as a runner. RGIII has that ability as well. He's very elusive and incredibly fast. He may be able to keep the chains moving.He is also a very good passer and may be further along than most would give him credit for. The problem is that he will not be able to sustain this type of play with his size. Even Tebow at 6'3" and 235lbs has taken a beating.

Interestingly enough, Luck is 6'4" and 240lbs, and he runs a faster 40 than Tebow. I vote Luck over RGIII, but feel that RGIII can be incredible.

That;'s a real point Flash..

Tebow could not have played this week even if Denver had won....

RG3 is not the runner Tebow is but that's a real concern...

Luck's not going to be asked to run for the Colts...That's not how they roll (or used to roll)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
doogansquest Walk On

doogansquest

Posted
Posted

I would also be happy with either but I would prefer the Colts taking Luck over Griffin because with Luck your getting i guy who most experts think can come in and contribute from day 1. While with Griffin you have a guy with a lot of potential but a guy who is going to be a project and might take a while to really adjust to playing in the NFL.

Which doesn't matter as niether player would be contributing here day 1... or year 1...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
bap1331 Walk On

bap1331

Posted
  • Author
Posted

So he's calling one of them Ryan Leaf...

LOL unfortunately, yes!

IDK butbi have a feeling that Luck will fit into our system more. Rgiii will fit into somewhere where their offensive line needs work. We did all learn the lesson with Vick that an out off pocket Qb will not succeed. Defenses have vastly improved since back then. He will be a good fit with the redskins though. They're an all run offensive line.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jay305 Walk On

Jay305

Posted
Posted

RG3 for me has a way higher ceiling than Luck. Hes not like Vick or Young he goes through his reads first. When he cant throw he'll run. Now he does tend to struggle with his reads at time and take off that at the NFL level is very correctable. Also he needs to get better at throwing towards the middle of the field and intermediate routes. In college he did most of his work on the sideline be it deep or short but most of his throws go there with deadly accuracy. Also hes only 21 granted he wont grow any taller, but he can definitely fill in his frame more once he starts training and conditioning on an NFL level.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
UndecidedFrog Walk On

UndecidedFrog

Posted
Posted

RG3 for me has a way higher ceiling than Luck.

Another way to think about ceilings is by what the prospect lacks right now that would be required to be successful at the NFL level. Using this criteria, RG3 definitely needs more work to be a successful NFL QB than Luck. Luck is closer, and needs less work.

Beyond the criteria of obtaining what it takes to be a successful NFL QB, I think both prospects have similar potential to be a PBQB or a FHOFQB, although I think projecting this "ceiling" is very imprecise and subject to much bias given that neither of them have played an NFL down yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Playoffs2013 Walk On

Playoffs2013

Posted
Posted

Another way to think about ceilings is by what the prospect lacks right now that would be required to be successful at the NFL level. Using this criteria, RG3 definitely needs more work to be a successful NFL QB than Luck. Luck is closer, and needs less work.

Beyond the criteria of obtaining what it takes to be a successful NFL QB, I think both prospects have similar potential to be a PBQB or a FHOFQB, although I think projecting this "ceiling" is very imprecise and subject to much bias given that neither of them have played an NFL down yet.

I agree with you on this

This is why we need to take luck

#luck2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Malakai432 Practice Squad

Malakai432

Posted
Posted

RG3 for me has a way higher ceiling than Luck. Hes not like Vick or Young he goes through his reads first. When he cant throw he'll run. Now he does tend to struggle with his reads at time and take off that at the NFL level is very correctable. Also he needs to get better at throwing towards the middle of the field and intermediate routes. In college he did most of his work on the sideline be it deep or short but most of his throws go there with deadly accuracy. Also hes only 21 granted he wont grow any taller, but he can definitely fill in his frame more once he starts training and conditioning on an NFL level.

While I do agree with some of what you say, I personally don't think his ceiling is that much higher. Luck IMO will have the ability to create his own plays and playbooks, read schemes, call audibles and run the overall offense at a much higher level than RGiii, especially right out the gate. On the other hand RGiii will always be more athletic and explosive than Andrew Luck. The way Luck runs the offense sometimes is similar to how Peyton runs things. I think it boils down to athleticism and explosivness vs raw intellect and fundamentals, while both sharing some of the same attributes. The one major problem I have with RGiii is that while he is smart and has an arm, he uses his athleticism consistantly on a per game basis which could lead to a sever injury going up against the ferocious defensive players of the NFL. Luck also does the same thing but not to the extent RGiii does, basically around upwards of 1,000 rush yards for Luck and around 2,000+ for RGiii. RGiii has already suffered an isolated tear to his ACL in 2009. Obviously he healed well but we all know mobile, rushing QB's have a tendency to be injury prone. I could also see Luck not relying on his athleticism in the NFL as much as Robert will, possibly leading to less injuries for Luck.

It's all a matter of opinion, there's really no way to guarantee which one will have more success in the NFL. Only time will tell. :tvsmash:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
UndecidedFrog Walk On

UndecidedFrog

Posted
Posted

The one major problem I have with RGiii is that while he is smart and has an arm, he uses his athleticism consistantly on a per game basis which could lead to a sever injury going up against the ferocious defensive players of the NFL. Luck also does the same thing but not to the extent RGiii does, basically around upwards of 1,000 rush yards for Luck and around 2,000+ for RGiii. RGiii has already suffered an isolated tear to his ACL in 2009.

Some statistics to back up what you have noted:

Luck (2011 Stanford Cardinal) rush attempts: 47

RG3 (2011 Baylor Bears) rush attempts: 179

Peyton Manning (1997 Tennessee Volunteers) rush attempts: 49

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ColtsBlueFL Team Captain

ColtsBlueFL

Posted
Posted

I think RGIII would be lucky to be as good as Steve McNair, the 1995 3rd overall choice. McNair could throw, and also run as well. He too, was often injured. But a good player when healthy, quite effective and once a co-MVP with Manning. And he lost a super bowl by 1 yard to the greatest show on turf Rams.

Always freeaky athletic QB's that come out and promise beyond the stars ceilings, but in reality only delivers the spectacular beffuddled with setbacks and injuries. I predict nothing different, unfortunately.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Jules Walk On

Jules

Posted
Posted

Irsay is taking Luck. It's been written for some time.

Griffin is not in the picture, it's just fun to talk about.

Irsay is going with the best prospect since Elway/Manning.

The Colts sucked for Luck. They did not suck for Griffin.

You take Luck 365 days a year and 7 days a week.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
JWF Walk On

JWF

Posted
Posted

Im usually not in favor of spread offense QBs but I think RG3 will be a good one. I just think its going to take more time for him. Of course Cam came in this year and blew the league up so maybe Griffin can do the same.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • NewColtsFan
      With the Next Pick drops Tonight!

      By NewColtsFan · Posted

      You think the Ed Dodds you see in edited clips here is the same as the Ed Dodds who interviews with teams?   I don’t know you or anyone would think that?      He’s very much respected around the NFL which is why multiple teams ask to interview with them most every year. 
    • csmopar
      With the Next Pick drops Tonight!

      By csmopar · Posted

      I was too hahaha  Why’s that
    • stitches
      Year 25! Dr. T's Annual Colt's Draft Contest for 2024

      By stitches · Posted

      Round 1 - #15 A. Xavier Worthy, WR, Texas B. Brian Thomas, WR, LSU C. Brock Bowers, TE, Georgia   Round 2 - #46  A. Edgerrin Cooper, LB, Texas A&M B. Marshall Kneeland, DE, Western Michigan C. Jaden Hicks, S, Washington State   Round 3 - #82 A. Troy Franklin, WR, Oregon B. Darius Robinson, DE/DT, Missouri C. Ben Sinnott, TE, Kansas State   Round 4 - #117 A. Jalyx Hunt, DE, Houston Christian B. Mason McCormick, OG, South Dakota State C. Malik Washington, WR, Virginia   Round 5 - #151 A. Beaux Limmer, OC, Arkansas B. Tanor Bortolini, OC, Wisconsin C. Isaac Guerendo, RB, Louisville   Round 6 - #191 A. Decamerion Richardson, CB, Mississippi State B. Qwan'tez Stiggers, CB, Toronto C. Nick Gargiulo, OC, South Carolina   Round 7 - #234 A. Millard Bradford, SS, TCU B. Mark Perry, FS, TCU C. Dalton Tucker, OG, Marshall   BONUS: Will the Colts trade the #15 pick this year?  A: Yes, they will trade back.  
    • stitches
      Colts have the 15th pick in the draft. (MERGE)

      By stitches · Posted

      Yeah... Richardson needs players who can separate and who can get open deep. IMO "give the inaccurate QB a contested catch receiver with large catch radius" is one of the tropes that hasn't proven to work well. Contested catches have about 50-55% success rate even with the best of contested catch receivers and with relatively accurate QBs... now if you think AR's accuracy is not good, drop that rate even more. The best way to give a relatively inaccurate QB better chance to complete passes is to give him a WR who separates and and who is open so the QB would have more of a margin for error to throw the ball a little behind or ahead or a little higher or lower than ideal. (we are not talking about uncatchable balls here... those will be uncatchable for anyone really). In that regard, one thing I would agree about is - we need WRs who have good hands and have good ball skills.   And this is ignoring that AR has indeed been pretty good with his accuracy on passes at intermediate and long range. His biggest problem coming into the league was the short stuff and he was already showing improvements in that deparment before he got injured.    And Worthy is the WR who created the most separation from anybody in this draft :   
    • Stephen
      Colts have the 15th pick in the draft. (MERGE)

      By Stephen · Posted

      Richardson  accuracy  on deep balls is his strength.  Hence why you pair an elite deep threat in worthy.

  • Members

    • Kirie89

      Kirie89 6

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • stitches

      stitches 19,241

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Dark Superman

      Dark Superman 1,778

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • pgt_rob

      pgt_rob 1,041

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Nate!

      Nate! 588

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Behle

      Behle 102

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...