hypothetical ty trade

[Coltivated]

I love ty don't get me wrong. But let's say dorsett turns out to be a stud. Moncrief progresses and carter is a great to decent number 2. Tod Gurley sits a couple games and comes on strong. Straight up player for player what did you think

[ColtsLegacy]

NO!

[akcolt]

Really the Rams trade the 10th pick in the draft. A player on a rookie contract for a player that is about to get paid. Stick to Madden is what I think.

[Bravo]

Quit with the freaking T.Y. Trades! For real!!!!???

Got to be kidding me....

[ProblChld32]

I love ty don't get me wrong. But let's say dorsett turns out to be a stud. Moncrief progresses and carter is a great to decent number 2. Tod Gurley sits a couple games and comes on strong. Straight up player for player what did you think

 

RB have very short Career's so no absolutely not. TY is much more of a Dynamic player. 

[Coltivated]

Your right i guess when we have stud wr's sitting on the bench kenny britt will lead the rams to the playoffs

[Coltivated]

Luck can make wr's better more so than he can a rb. Much like Peyton did

[BOTT]

No

[BProland85]

Luck can make wr's better more so than he can a rb. Much like Peyton did

I agree with you there but I feel that grigson wants to have Hilton, Moncrief, and Dorsett for the future at WR. One of our TEs are expendable though. If we could get good value for Allen or Fleener I'd be in support of trading one of them.

[NBColtsFanatic]

Stop with these TY trades. He is an extraordinary player and a great teammate. To see fans makiny trades involving him is questionable. If he leaves next year so be it; he will do what is best for him and good luck to him, if he stays, even better. We have one whole year basically to think about this.

[csmopar]

Quit with the freaking T.Y. Trades! For real!!!!???

Got to be kidding me....

My thoughts exactly........guess we need some deflate gate type drama to distract people on here so the dumb posts stop.....

[COLTS449]

Again no. The idea is to have an unstoppable receiving corps.

[TKnight24]

I love ty don't get me wrong. But let's say dorsett turns out to be a stud. Moncrief progresses and carter is a great to decent number 2. Tod Gurley sits a couple games and comes on strong. Straight up player for player what did you think

See that Red X at the top right of your computer screen? Click it, log out your computer, then throw your computer in your nearest body of water and never browse this site again

Thank You

Trade Hilton? You must be losing it

[tvturner]

Enough with these posts

[aaron11]

 TY is much more of a Dynamic player. 

not really.

 

trade has zero chance of happening though.

[DougDew]

While I think that trading a player in the last year of their contract is usually a good move, there is so much uncertainty with the WR position that I can't even speculate on "what ifs" at this point.

[bestQBever]

why don't we draft a QB next year so we can trade Luck so we don't have to pay him the money he deserves?

[Gavin]

No trade involving TY. Don't like it

[jskinnz]

I love ty don't get me wrong. But let's say dorsett turns out to be a stud. Moncrief progresses and carter is a great to decent number 2. Tod Gurley sits a couple games and comes on strong. Straight up player for player what did you think

 

Bad

 

Your right i guess when we have stud wr's sitting on the bench kenny britt will lead the rams to the playoffs

 

Worse

 

Luck can make wr's better more so than he can a rb. Much like Peyton did

 

Worst

 

There is no chance this happens.

[jseg18]

To be honest from all the speedsters, like Desean Jackson, Mike Wallace type, Ty Hilton is a better overall player. He can run the whole route tree, and makes some jump ball plays like the one against Texans.

[Luck_Is_Skilled]

NO! And I didnt even read the OP.

 

Why do people want to dump T.Y. just because we have Dorsett? Why cant we just have a buffet of weapons for Andrew to feast on defenses with? I dont get it, at all.

[Ja'Crispy]

NO! And I didnt even read the OP.

Why do people want to dump T.Y. just because we have Dorsett? Why cant we just have a buffet of weapons for Andrew to feast on defenses with? I dont get it, at all.

Welcome to the Colts Forum. Tis a silly place.

[CanuckColt]

Every player has their price, even Hilton. 

But Grigson won't trade him unless Rozensleaze demands ridiculous money from the Colts.

[ProblChld32]

not really.

 

trade has zero chance of happening though.

 

So you mean to tell me that you don't think that TY Hilton is a more Dynamic player than Gurley? Gurley is unproven in the NFL. there arent really much Dynamic Backs these days. IMO the only three Dynamic RB's in the NFL are Adrian Peterson, Shady McCoy and Jamall Charles. Other than that. everyone else is pretty much serviceable or above average.

[mattceinicram]

I wouldn't be shocked if TY gets the franchise tag.

[pgt_rob]

I like the sound of having a 2nd TY Hilton to help burn the opposing secondary. I think with having TY Hilton and Dorsett, there will be so much speed on the field for the tough teams to keep up.

[jskinnz]

Every player has their price, even Hilton. 

But Grigson won't trade him unless Rozensleaze demands ridiculous money from the Colts.

 

Yeah, that is not the way it will work.

[Malakai432]

not really.

 

trade has zero chance of happening though.

 

TY is a MUCH more dynamic NFL player considering TG has never played in the NFL. 

 

People seem to think Gurley and his torn ACL will be the next best thing since sliced bread.  I don't see it.   

[ColtsLegacy]

So you mean to tell me that you don't think that TY Hilton is a more Dynamic player than Gurley? Gurley is unproven in the NFL. there arent really much Dynamic Backs these days. IMO the only three Dynamic RB's in the NFL are Adrian Peterson, Shady McCoy and Jamall Charles. Other than that. everyone else is pretty much serviceable or above average.

Do you even Marshawn Lynch and Le'Veon Bell?

And to say "everyone else is pretty much serviceable or above average" is hyperbolic nonsense.

[ProblChld32]

Do you even Marshawn Lynch and Le'Veon Bell?

And to say "everyone else is pretty much serviceable or above average" is hyperbolic nonsense.

 

Forgot about those Two, How exactly is my statement hyperbolic nonsense? Are those guys not considered Elite? is every starting RB in the NFL an Elite back? No they aren't everyone else false under the category of serviceable or above average. 

[ColtsLegacy]

Forgot about those Two, How exactly is my statement hyperbolic nonsense? Are those guys not considered Elite? is every starting RB in the NFL an Elite back? No they aren't everyone else false under the category of serviceable or above average.

Nonsense. Matt Forte, Eddie Lacy, Frank Gore, Arian Foster, DeMarco Murray, etc. are more than just "above average" guys.

[Dark Superman]

SMH at all these Colts fans who would even think about the possibility of Hilton leaving Imdianapolis. The thought of it makes me sick to my stomach.

[Dark Superman]

TY is a MUCH more dynamic NFL player considering TG has never played in the NFL. 

 

People seem to think Gurley and his torn ACL will be the next best thing since sliced bread.  I don't see it.

I wouldn't trade Hilton for ANY RB period.

[Dark Superman]

I like the sound of having a 2nd TY Hilton to help burn the opposing secondary. I think with having TY Hilton and Dorsett, there will be so much speed on the field for the tough teams to keep up.

And having Luck and the set of legs he has also helps extend plays. Teams are going to have a crazy time covering the speed of all these guys.

[ProblChld32]

Nonsense. Matt Forte, Eddie Lacy, Frank Gore, Arian Foster, DeMarco Murray, etc. are more than just "above average" guys.

Frank Gore, Forte and Maybe possibly Murray i will put in the category of Elite. Foster imo is above average i dont consider him Elite. Lacy too early to crown him Elite he only has 2 seasons in the back . 

[ColtsLegacy]

Frank Gore, Forte and Maybe possibly Murray i will put in the category of Elite. Foster imo is above average i dont consider him Elite. Lacy too early to crown him Elite he only has 2 seasons in the back . 

 

I'm not evening saying they're all necessarily "elite", but they're certainly better than "above average".

[Surge89]

Frank Gore, Forte and Maybe possibly Murray i will put in the category of Elite. Foster imo is above average i dont consider him Elite. Lacy too early to crown him Elite he only has 2 seasons in the back .

I think you have missed the point. Those players arent "just serviceable"

[GoColts8818]

Luck can make wr's better more so than he can a rb. Much like Peyton did

If this was true the Colts would not have made sure they kept two future Hall of Fame of WRs for much of Peyton's career in Marvin and Reggie.  Yes a great QB can make WRs look better than they are but there is a limit on that. 

[aaron11]

TY is a MUCH more dynamic NFL player considering TG has never played in the NFL. 

 

 

its unfair to hold  that against him.  he could also come out and be the next walter peyton.  gurley had a better college career than ty did as well.  how do you know that wont translate to the next level for him?  you can say " i dont see it"  all you want but i can counter by saying " i do see it"

 

he wouldnt be the only guy to recover from a college acl tear

[Deadpool]

      

 

 

that is the funniest thing i have heard so far this year.