Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Pombi9

Vick pins his struggles on Eagles O-line coach Mudd's hiring [Merge]

23 posts in this topic

Mudd preferred smaller, faster O-linemen.  While those guys are faster and better at pass protection, you generally lose some run blocking ability.  However, when you have a QB like Vick who might hold on to the ball for too long, your smaller O-linemen will be beat by bigger D-linemen.  I think Mudd's coaching philosophy is outdated.  However, Mudd is not the only one who caused problems in Philly.  They didn't give McCoy the ball nearly enough this season and signing all those free agents a while back really hurt them.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
some things you just don't say publicly   :facepalm:

 

Yep.  But not many people would have confused Vick for a real leader.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mudd preferred smaller, faster O-linemen.  While those guys are faster and better at pass protection, you generally lose some run blocking ability.  However, when you have a QB like Vick who might hold on to the ball for too long, your smaller O-linemen will be beat by bigger D-linemen.  I think Mudd's coaching philosophy is outdated.  However, Mudd is not the only one who caused problems in Philly.  They didn't give McCoy the ball nearly enough this season and signing all those free agents a while back really hurt them.

agreed

 

 

It has hurt Indy's run game even today

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you kidding me? Sounds like the same problem most employers have in the US...people want to create jobs where they dont have to do a job.

Vick was given the opportunity to take on more work, more responsibility or to become THE leader by also making the line/blocking calls. But basically said that did not work! Why? Because it requires more work, more effort, more time and most of all standing on the edge of the cliff and not fearing to make a mistake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Are you kidding me? Sounds like the same problem most employers have in the US...people want to create jobs where they dont have to do a job.

Vick was given the opportunity to take on more work, more responsibility or to become THE leader by also making the line/blocking calls. But basically said that did not work! Why? Because it requires more work, more effort, more time and most of all standing on the edge of the cliff and not fearing to make a mistake.

Please don't be one of the ones that complains about the Colts o-line because it's kind of contradictory to say that then state what you just did. If you have looked at any Philly games, you can kind of feel Vick on the O-Line. They have been getting abused by defenses all year. They have been rotated in and out because of protection issues. They are bad..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wish I could read the entire transcript. It sounds like he's saying the team struggled to adjust to a completely new blocking scheme, and that's not far-fetched. Many predicted it at the time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wouldn't say he had a poor season, He is injured to much though. Time for Philly to move on I think based on draft position they will have and Vicks age(32). I dont think Vick bemoaned(I think Rosenthal needs to go back and take a look at a dictionary) anyone, He did not give Mudd a ringing endorsement but thats sure as heck not bemoaning him

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well.....for comparison's sake...

 

Peyton Manning, who is as stationary an NFL QB as there is....but can read a defense better than the defense can read itself....excelled behind a Howard Mudd line.

 

On the other hand, Vick....who until RGIII came along was the most dangerously mobile QB in the NFL, but evidently can't read a defense to save his soul.....failed miserably behind Mudd's line.

 

To be fair....the Eagles lost LT Jason Peters, RT Todd Herrimans and C Jason Kelce for all or most of the season. But for Manning's final 5 years as a Colt we had only Jeff Saturday who could be considered anything close to Pro Bowl caliber, and our O-line was often in every bit the disarray Philly's is now.

 

So somewhere in the discussion....Vick's own inability in key areas of QB play should also be noted.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well.....for comparison's sake...

 

Peyton Manning, who is as stationary an NFL QB as there is....but can read a defense better than the defense can read itself....excelled behind a Howard Mudd line.

 

Manning showed that he can excel despite not having a quality offensive line, especially after 2007. I wouldn't put that kind of burden on any other quarterback in the league. And even with Manning, his yards/attempt declined to a pre-prime 6.8, with 17 interceptions. Not all on the line; the receiver corps was decimated as well, but the line play did affect Manning. Of course, there's no one better than Manning at reading a defense pre-snap and adjusting to get something out of the play. Again, I wouldn't put that burden or expectation on any other quarterback.

 

You're right that Vick isn't good at reading defenses and adjusting, but I wouldn't compare him to Manning. I do believe that Howard Mudd's philosophies have grown stale, and I think part of the deterioration of the Colts' line play can be traced back to him. Contrary to popular belief, the Colts didn't always have a bad line. It's been five years now, but before that, the line was reliable and helped produce 1,000 yard rushers year after year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Manning showed that he can excel despite not having a quality offensive line, especially after 2007. I wouldn't put that kind of burden on any other quarterback in the league. And even with Manning, his yards/attempt declined to a pre-prime 6.8, with 17 interceptions. Not all on the line; the receiver corps was decimated as well, but the line play did affect Manning. Of course, there's no one better than Manning at reading a defense pre-snap and adjusting to get something out of the play. Again, I wouldn't put that burden or expectation on any other quarterback.

 

You're right that Vick isn't good at reading defenses and adjusting, but I wouldn't compare him to Manning. I do believe that Howard Mudd's philosophies have grown stale, and I think part of the deterioration of the Colts' line play can be traced back to him. Contrary to popular belief, the Colts didn't always have a bad line. It's been five years now, but before that, the line was reliable and helped produce 1,000 yard rushers year after year.

Those are fair points....and pre-2007 Mudd's system and better talent produced well for us. But IMO, Vick parked too much of the blame at Mudd's doorstep considering the total mess that the Eagles are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe the problem with Mudd is that he expected the same from his new quarterback as he did from his previous quarterback. If that is the case it is on Mudd. I highly doubt Howard would expect Vick to be in Peyton's ball park when it comes to protections/packages/calls/assignments, so to me I doubt the issue is much Mudd's fault.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

no way vick is an eagle next year, but he could still be wearing green on his next team

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Those are fair points....and pre-2007 Mudd's system and better talent produced well for us. But IMO, Vick parked too much of the blame at Mudd's doorstep considering the total mess that the Eagles are.

Agreed. I didn't get the impression that he was blaming it all on Mudd, which is why I wanted to see the transcript. But either way, as someone else said, these thoughts are better left in your head.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
no way vick is an eagle next year, but he could still be wearing green on his next team

 

Jets?!

 

Oh God, please make it happen!!!!

 

lol

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jets?!

 

Oh God, please make it happen!!!!

 

lol

 

yep jets haha

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah Vick is just kind of a terrible QB, regardless of what OL he plays behind. I do agree though the Eagles OL and the Colts OL easily do battle as some of the worst.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That O-line is bad but he has to take into count all the mistakes he made. All that stupid running around when he should just throw it.

 

 

 

This isn't about the O-line, go back to when he was a Falcon. I should know, I had to watch him quite a lot. Look at all the coaching changes they made for him and still the same results. The Falcons would look like a real team one week and get pounded the next week. I remember when they would make the playoffs with him it was always "Michael Vick is going to prove everyone wrong this time!" and did he ever do that? Well give him credit to the gave they won against Green Bay, I have no clue what happened to the Packers at home that year, but all the other playoff games? Yeah, that's right, loses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Michael Vick is getting a little vocal now that he's about to play his last game as an Eagle.  He blame the offensive line and, in particular, the changing of coaches from Castillo to Howard Mudd as the main culprit.  Let's see if a team without Howrd Mudd decides to test that theory next year.

 

http://aol.sportingnews.com/nfl/story/2012-12-28/eagles-vs-giants-michael-vick-nfl-week-17-andy-reid-juan-castillo-howard-mudd

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Popular Now

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hmm just looked.  Didn't know they where getting signing bonuses that big.     However I would say that UDFA's are meat for the grinder.
    • You're welcome
    • I agree . . . probably doesn't help that his own team's fans are booing him.     Guy is in a terrible position because he can't win.  See an ordinary field player could go out there, play really well and show people "See I was worth the pick!!".  A lot of good players have been fueled by that.  JJ Watt still mentioned being fueled by boos on his draft day.  On offense or defense you can do that at any position.     At kicker. . . he could hit every field goal and it wouldn't matter.  Shoot he could set the NFL record for the longest successful field goal and it still wouldn't matter.  Everyone is still going to say he wasn't worth a 2nd round pick.  There is nothing he can do to win.   
    • Not "literally". Actually the 4th round draft picks have been getting signing bonuses of half a million dollars.   4 year 3 million $$ contracts.   Not too shabby.    Even 7th rounders are getting $2.5 million dollar salarys with almost $100 thousand signing bonuses.  
    • This is the Chargers response to that-   Our contract discussions and offers to the representatives of Joey Bosa have been both fair and structurally consistent with the contracts of every other Chargers player.   Our offer included:   • An initial signing bonus payment that is larger than any player in the League has received in the last two drafts.   • More money in this calendar year than every player in this year’s draft except one (QB Carson Wentz).   • The largest payment and the highest percentage of signing bonus received in the first calendar year of any Chargers’ first-round selection since the inception of the current Collective Bargaining Agreement (2011).   We gave Joey’s representatives our best offer last night, which was rejected today. The offer that we extended was for Joey to contribute during all 16 games and beyond. Joey’s ability to contribute for an entire rookie season has now been jeopardized by the valuable time he has missed with his coaches and his teammates. Since Joey will not report at this time, his ability to produce not just early in the season, but throughout the entire season, has been negatively impacted.   As a result, we will restructure our offer since Joey will be unable to contribute for the full 16 game season without the adequate time on the practice field, in the classroom, and in preseason games.   So even if Joey signs somewhere down the road, the Chargers are already reducing the amount of guaranteed money Bosa can get due to not being able tocontribute on the field for a full 16 game season.  It is going to get very ugly.
  • Welcome New Members

  • Members

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.