Yes it was. Been a fan since 1984 and I will say my 3 worst moments was losing to Pitt in the 05 Playoffs in Indy, losing to Pitt in the 95 Title Game(Harbaugh's run), and losing to the Saints in the 09 SB. Not going for the undefeated season in 09 is right in there with those moments.
I honestly like the Colts chances on Sunday. The offense finally seems like they're all on the same page with Chud's system, & we're getting Moncrief back. That's huge. And I expect that the o-line will continue to improve as well, I'm hoping they get a little better each week moving forward. As far as D goes, they're still giving up a lot of points, but at least now they are making some plays & forcing a turnover occasionally, which they weren't doing at all the first few weeks.