Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

House

Breaking New: Saints bounty suspensions have been Vacated.

46 posts in this topic

At the end of the day Goodell screwed it up by not releasing any real concrete evidence but insisting that he had some

At the end of the day...The Saints were guilty to all who read the evidence...

many fans simply wont..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At the end of the day Goodell screwed it up by not releasing any real concrete evidence but insisting that he had some

Maybe he's holding it because of an active defamation suit filed by Vilma. Makes them get the evidence via discovery, not CNN / ESPN.

Paul Tagliabue got it all, and says between 22-27 Saints defenders participated, but Not (in any serious degree) Scott Fujita.

Going to be hard for Vilma to win, he has to prove-

  1. Someone made a statement;
  2. that statement was published;
  3. the statement caused you injury;
  4. the statement was false; and
  5. the statement did not fall into a privileged category.

Goodell already has a second party backing up what his original statement was. RE: #4. Only difference was Goodell wanted to suspend / fine a few of the alleged, whereas the seconding party does not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The comment and link weren't the same point.

The link was released today stating that they would go after "the next" qb which was Peyton. I posted that in response to your saying " They didn't go after Peyton in the super bowl. Wouldn't you think that would have been the case."

The fact that the nature of the bounty program needs spelled out every time it's brought up is why the notion that the Saints weren't doing anything is being propagated.

I'm sure the NFL is wrong as well, but there was indeed a bounty program. It's not my opinion.

Saints coaches swore on the record that there WAS a bounty programs as far back at 2010..

Tagliabue just commuted the sentences for the guilty

Tagliabue said the Saints were guilty as sin...he just blamed the coaches and not the players.

Read what he said

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Saints coaches swore on the record that there WAS a bounty programs as far back at 2010..

At first, all the coached denied, through gritted teeth. Only later did they fess up.

Tagliabue just commuted the sentences for the guilty

True, but he also stated they participated in activity that was indeed conduct detrimental...

Tagliabue said the Saints were guilty as sin...he just blamed the coaches and not the players.

Nah, not really. He really does blame all, but only allows coaches/FO punishments. He eliminates player sentences, but doesn't condone their actions in doing so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OKay, if I'm way off base here just tell me.

 

Basically, Gregg Williams & Sean Payton admitted some level of guilt in either the participation in or turning a blind eye to the creation of a bounty system, but NFL Commissioner wasn't able to prove that players like Jonathan Vilma, Scott Fujita, & Anthony Hargrove directly put money in or took my out of the actual bounty ledger correct?

 

Is that the lay of the land in a nutshell? 

 
 
 
 
 
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OKay, if I'm way off base here just tell me.

 

Basically, Gregg Williams & Sean Payton admitted some level of guilt in either the participation in or turning a blind eye to the creation of a bounty system, but NFL Commissioner wasn't able to prove that players like Jonathan Vilma, Scott Fujita, & Anthony Hargrove directly put money in or took my out of the actual bounty ledger correct?

 

Is that the lay of the land in a nutshell? 

 

How about adding in sponsoring it, and not ceasing it when the league found out and asked them stop? And destroying evidence about it so league couldn't tell if they had cleaned up their act or not?

 

And I am pretty certain they have some physical evidence, and evidence of other evidence being and/or having been destroyed.  That which remains has not been let out publicly AFAIK, but was reviewed by Paul Tagliabue.  He is the one saying that (remaining) evidence shows between 22 - 27 Saints defensive players could have been punished by Goodell.  I don't think any of us will see any of this evidence in the public domain, especially while Jonathan Vilma has an active defamation lawsuit in the court system.  And maybe ever.  They just want to wrap this up and it all to go away and not happen again.

 

And my take on it?  Possibly, if Goodell would have punished all 22 or so players their evidence shows participated, and with the same amount in fines / suspension days, Tagliabue may not have overturned those either and just let the courts handle it.  He pretty much said Yes, the players did it, it's definitely "conduct detrimental to the league".  But he feels Goodell's singling a few out and vast disparity in punishment was improper, and thus vacated those punishments.
 
And Tagliabue's rendering has also strengthened Goodell's position against Vilma's defamation case.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • We just disagree and I'm completely mind boggled there's so much interest for taking a rb at #15. It's like I'm in the twilight zone. 
    •   Riight now he's being projected as an early to mid 2nd round prospect. 
    •   Fumbling is an easy fix and he got in trouble as a teen, who hasn't. Williams off the field issues are well documented and actually he can pass block. Go watch tape   As for taco and Barnett, I've seen them mocked to the jets and saints respectively a number of times and that's before the combine and pro day when their stock will rise
    • I actually like Tyus Bowser quite a bit!
    • Doesn't matter if he's "never had to stand up". He would fit he is a beast.  I'm not the biggest Takk fan, but he is NOT a reach and you'll agree after the combine. You don't know if the Saints will take Barnett. Williams is impressive to everyone else. And I'm sure Taco will be there at #15 also, have not heard of him going in the top 10 yet. And even if we did get a DL through free agency, we are building through the draft. Getting a new #1 corner is very much needed also. All of those players/positions I named are better value AND a better need.    Also so funny how you only notice Tims flaws, when Cook has been in trouble more than he has. And also can't block and fumbles a lot.    We're not drafting a RB in the 1st round. 
  • Members

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.