Not silly . As much as I can't stand Brady he out did 18 IMO given a running game & defense that performs at a high level 12 can equal 18 as a Colt I don't care about the stats 18 had lots of great regular season stats but in the playoffs not so great .
Luck can go further just give him the same weapons Manning had a Faulk or a James would be nice . The Broncos Defense with Peyton Manning in his prime would have been a dynasty &
As far as I recall Peyton Manning had 1 season better at this point in his career & I believe Luck got further in the playoffs in there first 5 seasons IMO judging 16 seasons versus 5 seems a bit premature ..
I have from day 1 believed by the end of Andrew Lucks Colts career he will equal Peyton Manning & could very well pass him , When 18 was in Knoxville I felt he was the real deal & he was , watching 12 at Stanford I felt the same way it was awesome both times to get a once in a life time QB , The Colts have gotten 2 bites at the apple maybe this time those in the front office can learn from the mistakes of the past ..