It's a tough call. You have Stats, MVP's, SB MVP's, overall wins, of course SB wins too, Clutch factor too. I think it's between Montana, Brady, Unitas, Elway, and Peyton as far as greatest ever. Of course with Unitas I factor in NFL Championships because he played a lot of his career before the SB era. Having said all of that, if I had to choose 1 QB in a Draft it would be Peyton because he can win with any Coach as proven.
All this is great analysis. It isn't actally responsive to anything I said and assumes that I meant more than what I actually said, but okay...I certainly don't get why you are getting personal with me.
Peyton, in my mind, is the best QB ever. He might not get the GOAT status because he didn't have the fortune of playing with some of the greatest teams of all-time, but you can't tell me he wouldn't have won a boatload of Superbowls if he had played with the Steelers of the 70s, 49ers of the 80s, Cowboys of the 90s, or Patriots of the 00s.
Peyton would be my QB if I could choose ANY player in history.