Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Jules

So, is it over for Alex Smith in SF?

136 posts in this topic

If you get the same passing production out of two guys but one is younger, has a stronger arm, and is more of a threat on the run then why wouldn't you switch to that guy? Smith was having a solid season but he's just as dependent on the defense and run game and has a good deal less upside.

I'm not going production, I'm going on what I'm seeing during the game. Upside is like potential energy. If it isn't put into motion, then it just stays stored. Jemarcus Russell had upside; Ryan Leaf had upside; Jimmy Clausen had upside. That's the crazy things about sports; you are drafted on maybes.

But truthfully, CK has been doing the thing that you said Smith does the last 3 games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not as impressed with this SF team like I used to be. I am not sure what it is and I can't quite put my finger on it.

But, something seems more off to me lately......

Guess we will see when they go to NE but I would favor NE at home in a night game. This is where Kaep is gonna have to prove himself and since NE already lost to two NFC teams this season I don't love the odds they go 1-3 vs. the NFC this year either.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But Smith can't run like that...lol

Yep. That right there is exactly why you go with Kaep.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not as impressed with this SF team like I used to be. I am not sure what it is and I can't quite put my finger on it.

But, something seems more off to me lately......

Guess we will see when they go to NE but I would favor NE at home in a night game. This is where Kaep is gonna have to prove himself and since NE already lost to two NFC teams this season I don't love the odds they go 1-3 vs. the NFC this year either.

Yeah, if they lose in New England, they have to win in Seattle to secure the NFC West and the way that Seattle is playing now, that will be tough to do. *peeking over at Seattle's score and smh*

It will be interesting seeing the rest of the season play out. The NFC is too close to call. If the 49ers don't win the NFC West, they might not make the playoff.

Both the Giants and Bears sit at 8-5 with the Giants winning over SF but SF beating the Bears. The Seahawks still have a chance to win the NFC West if they win out (and they have the schedule to do it.). If Seattle somehow wins the NFC East, that will leave 49ers looking at a tight playoff spot that will point to the NFC East battle. The NFC is crazy..lol

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep. That right there is exactly why you go with Kaep.

People forget this play in the playoffs...

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

People forget this play in the playoffs...

{video above snipped}

Exactly what I was thinking when I read it!

Now, they'll need to draft Kaep's backup, because they can't afford to pay Smith 8.5 million to hold the clipboard. And folks saw what Ngata did to RGIII today.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i think at this point , coach has made decision & thats it, its a shame, smith had this team winning more covincibly to me , did well in a shootout last year in playoffs, & has experience in playoff

he abided by the rules and reported dizziness leading to the concussion test & sit down and thats how lost a job, if didnt report issue and no one noticed would coach have made that change even if had 1 off game

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

People forget this play in the playoffs...

I remember that play, also that game very well. Sadly, most of the fans on the 49ers site forgot that Alex Smith carried the team on his back to beat the Saint. Come to think about it, Alex Smith played under Urban Meyer's spread. He can run a little zone read. lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

he abided by the rules and reported dizziness leading to the concussion test & sit down and thats how lost a job, if didnt report issue and no one noticed would coach have made that change even if had 1 off game

I actually think Harbaugh set concussion reporting back a few years with this move, no matter what the motive might have been. If Alex Smith didn't report anything, he would still be playing but now the league sees that and don't want to put themselves in that same situation.

And no matter how people will try to spin it, using athleticism, upside, blah blah blah, the 49ers were 6-2 when he left. If anyone has been looking at the games, they would know that CK has basically been pulling a Alex Smith (with more turnovers..lol). Bears game, I give him that, even though they held the offense to practically nothing. The Saints game, the 2 pick 6s and the constant pressure on Brees in the pocket is the reason for that win, and not offense. Rams game.....*shrugs*.. And this last game, other than the zone read touchdown, the best thing that CK did was hand off the ball to Gore and the occasional dump off. Like I stated earlier, potential energy is just that. If this is indeed how he plays, then I believe that it had to do more with opening up cap space by dumping Smith.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually think Harbaugh set concussion reporting back a few years with this move, no matter what the motive might have been. If Alex Smith didn't report anything, he would still be playing but now the league sees that and don't want to put themselves in that same situation.

And no matter how people will try to spin it, using athleticism, upside, blah blah blah, the 49ers were 6-2 when he left. If anyone has been looking at the games, they would know that CK has basically been pulling a Alex Smith (with more turnovers..lol). Bears game, I give him that, even though they held the offense to practically nothing. The Saints game, the 2 pick 6s and the constant pressure on Brees in the pocket is the reason for that win, and not offense. Rams game.....*shrugs*.. And this last game, other than the zone read touchdown, the best thing that CK did was hand off the ball to Gore and the occasional dump off. Like I stated earlier, potential energy is just that. If this is indeed how he plays, then I believe that it had to do more with opening up cap space by dumping Smith.

Oh I agree plus last weeks games rookie mental errors with the backwards overthrown lateral near own endzone & other team gets TD & also the going back 7 yards intro the endzone and throwing to take a saftey

thats all u need mental rookie errors in playoffs

8 million next year is alot of cap space die smith, but why chance a season for it & a SB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh I agree plus last weeks games rookie mental errors with the backwards overthrown lateral near own endzone & other team gets TD & also the going back 7 yards intro the endzone and throwing to take a saftey

thats all u need mental rookie errors in playoffs

8 million next year is alot of cap space die smith, but why chance a season for it & a SB

Another thing I think it boils down to is Kaepernick is his guy. That's is who he drafted so he is putting all his chips into Kaepernick's basket.

It's not like any other situation in football and the term upside.

Luck > Painter

RG3 > RG3&Out..lol

Weeden > McCoy (considering what he has, he is heads and shoulders better than McCoy)

And this is all seen on the field. Not practice or what we believe but tangible evidence. WIth Smith and CK, not as much. And it's not a knock on Kaepernick. I like the dude but I haven't seen much to say he warranted taking Smith's starting position. And without using upside or potential (because those are yet to be seen), how did Smith lose his job?

But then we get to the 49ers

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another thing I think it boils down to is Kaepernick is his guy. That's is who he drafted so he is putting all his chips into Kaepernick's basket.

It's not like any other situation in football and the term upside.

Luck > Painter

RG3 > RG3&Out..lol

Weeden > McCoy (considering what he has, he is heads and shoulders better than McCoy)

And this is all seen on the field. Not practice or what we believe but tangible evidence. WIth Smith and CK, not as much. And it's not a knock on Kaepernick. I like the dude but I haven't seen much to say he warranted taking Smith's starting position. And without using upside or potential (because those are yet to be seen), how did Smith lose his job?

But then we get to the 49ers

absoluetely , he didnt get Peyton , == SSuperbowl , as he * PM well they each wanted offensive control to certain degrees lets face it sso would be head butting

Kappy he can say is his pick & he made the team work, while he inheited smith but making a bad smith work to waas great for his rep BTW

anyway off to Dr, have great morning

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

absoluetely , he didnt get Peyton , == SSuperbowl , as he * PM well they each wanted offensive control to certain degrees lets face it sso would be head butting

Kappy he can say is his pick & he made the team work, while he inheited smith but making a bad smith work to waas great for his rep BTW

anyway off to Dr, have great morning

Exactly...

And you have a great morning also!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't love the odds they go 1-3 vs. the NFC this year either.

who would have loved the odds the colts go 3-1 against the nfc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yeah, my wife would agree with you. She wants to move to Gulf Shores Alabama. We vacation there from time to time. 
    • I am not sure Whitner would be beaten out by Geathers... Whitner has a solid career of playing at a high level.. Geathers has been a fill in and for me was our biggest single question mark in the secondary this year;  We'd be MUCH improved with Whitner on board and let the best player start.  I wouldn't count Whitner out on that battle.  
    • Fact: Castonzo was lousy last year by his own admission.   Fact: We have a rookie Center who hasn't had a single live practice yet.  How often do people talk about the reality that you can't really learn much from OTA's and No Pad Practices?  Fact: We had Reitz last year as well as Mewhort (one of my favorite players) but the line was still lousy anyway. Fact: Thornton has not performed to date and is injury prone.  And to even mention Harrison's name PROVES we are in deep trouble if he EVER sees the field again as a starter on the O Line because he was by far the worst player on our team who saw action last year on the O-Line.     Look, everyone could play amazingly and we could have the best line in NFL history.  But history suggests if 4 of the 5 starters come back from last year's terrible performing bunch AND the fifth is a rookie who hasn't played a down or even had a padded practice yet, it is hard to suggest we are improved over last year.  There is no evidence let alone proof.  You guys are all hoping these guys outperform what they did last year.  That's fine, but it means nothing until and unless they do it.  Insanity is doing the same thing and expecting different results.   This is closer to that than a major upgrade to our O-Line.  I would have expected 3 new superior starters at C, RG and RT as compared to who started last year with a solid back up option at LT if Castonzo fails again this year.  THAT would be clear cut improvement.     Of course we all want the O-Line to play better.  I hope that Clark impresses and moves into a starting spot alongside Kelly who also impresses and kicks but.  THAT would be a start.  I also know a lot about Reitz.  He went to my high school and I am a fan.  But he's getting older and until recently was seen as depth, not starting level talent.  Reading about Kelly and all the accolades leaves me asking "based on what?" We'll learn a little during training camp and Pre-Season, but the truth will really only come in live action against Detroit.  It's just as legit to question whether we've improved as it is to say we have in fact already done so.  Let's have some hard evidence before saying "problem solved." 
  • Welcome New Members

  • Members

    • Cynjin

      Cynjin 1,462

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • 100GFB

      100GFB 467

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • HungarianColtsFan

      HungarianColtsFan 1,411

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • bravo4460

      bravo4460 981

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Buck Showalter

      Buck Showalter 2,047

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • GoColtsWin

      GoColtsWin 82

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Colts_Fan12

      Colts_Fan12 2,117

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • JPFolks

      JPFolks 335

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • bradgt04

      bradgt04 35

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Crofan

      Crofan 28

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.