Do you remember the playoff game vs the KC chiefs? Where luck grabbed a loose fumble and took it in for a TD? Is that the kind of superstar you're talking about? I think the reason it is an unpopular scenario is because it is a wrong scenario. I don't see someone like Scott Tolzian doing something like that. So that minimal difference would probably be the fact that Luck is a superstar and Tolzian is not.
With Peyton you at one time saw an offense running on all cylinders. They were a well oiled machine and feared by all in the NFL other than maybe 3 teams. Hopefully we can see the current offense get into that kind of thing. I have no doubt Andrew would look spectacular.
NannyMcafee replied to WoolMagnet's topic in NFL General
I understand the back up aspect, but from my understanding Steve young was never truly a back up. He was never drafted to BE the back up. More of my point was aimed towards having two back to back good to great QBs for your team.