One of the things I found interesting with the case and I said this as the draft was taking place. The bouncers from the bar and the owner had vastly different stories than the Girl and her friends.
Second, the owner of the bar in question, Fat Daddy's, has also spoken out. Yahoo! Sports' Jason Cole reports that the bar owner said the woman involved "repeatedly" hit Brantley in the chest and arms, while a security guard present also said she punched him in the mouth. The GPD incident report says the woman pushed Brantley, who then retaliated with a punch.
However, the security guard added that the woman was never knocked unconscious and Brantley did not punch her, only pushed her away.
Brantley has maintained from the start that he acted solely in a reactionary manner, pushing the woman away. The GPD report from the incident indicates that two witnesses identified Brantley as punching the woman.