Those teams have very very good defenses...and running games. They basically have a philosophy of football and are just trying to get better in other areas. They both play smash mouth defense and run it down your throat offense. Now if the qb play improves (and they have both addressed wr and qbs) they will continue to get better. Basically they HAVE AN IDENTITY. We don't. Not yet....hopefully we will. We did with Peyton and hopefully we will carve out something this year but we don't know ourselves yet. That in and of itself I think gives those two teams an edge. Besides Jacksonville swept us and Cleveland beat us and yes I think we can be better than them but I'm not going to give us an edge until we see our team getting things done on the field.
Those teams have run-heavy offenses because they suck at quarterback, and have for so long. Not taking anything away from MJD, as he's obviously a guy you'd give touches to, but I don't think they want him running the ball 343 times. And their defenses are good, but not because they have a lot of talent. Maybe I'm underselling them, but I think we're better at end and safety than both of those teams, and by a long shot. Maybe they have a linebacker or a corner I'd covet, but I don't think their defenses are stocked with good players.
Miami and Minnesota just look lost...no identity..to me. Rams...no real identity yet either..so I still think we are at the bottom of the pack...we still need things to go very right..and we drafted the best man for the job...just have to make it happen.
Miami is a mess, but they DO have good players. The question is whether management can get out of it's own way. And the Rams, I think, are less talented than us, but have a proven coach (I'm not a big Fisher fan, but he's done some things), and some promising youngsters. Plus they just signed Finnegan, and drafted two highly rated corners.
I agree we can work around Mathis or Freeney but I would be scared without a pass rush...just never seen us generate one without them...so it would hurt.
I definitely don't want to see it happen, but I think the staff could handle it much better than we would have under the previous regime. Those two guys have the rare ability to beat blockers multiple times each game, making it necessary to be double-teamed. Can't just "next man up" when your scheme relies on them to do what they do, considering most players aren't nearly as talented. The new scheme can design a pass rush that will influence the offense, with or without elite pass rushers. Suggs isn't as good a pass rusher as either of our guys, but has 25 sacks in the last two seasons.
I don't know about the Freeney thing. I have mixed feelings but they honestly must think they can make it work. Thats a lot of money but then again we already will have the most cap space next year as it is so perhaps they think it is worth it for competitive reasons and to put butts in the seats. I really don't care either way. Personally everyone here knows I would have handled things differently and Freeney a long with those other injured vets would have been the cap casualties instead of Peyton. That said I wouldn't be mad if they saved that money to find younger talent and sign people next year and just bite the bullett this year but I also understand in giving him a chance to prove himself or make this defense still better. I am just resigned to it now...that they believe in Dwight and what he can bring so I will just have to trust them...like I am that letting Peyton go is ok.
I have real doubts but I think keeping Dwight isn't as bad as letting Peyton walk.
I'm not one that thinks we should push Freeney out the door. I'm actually getting more and more excited about seeing him in the new defense. But I think it would be prudent to do something with his contract before the season starts. Not because of cap space, now or later, but because of real dollars. We could extend him this offseason, and if he doesn't work out, release him next offseason, and basically spend the same amount of money as we're going to, including his signing bonus. It's just the smart move, I think.