83 replies to this topic

[BProland85]

Who would your choice be?

 

For me its between JJ Watt and Patrick Peterson.(If only we could give a team money from our cap to just purchase a great player of theirs!)

 

Both are huge areas of need, Peterson probably being more of a need though. But having a guy with a non stop motor is great to have.

 

My pick is JJ Watt because Pagano can always coach up someone less talented at DB.

[jbaron04]

Ap

[FalseStart]

Joe Thomas

[ColtJ82]

Tough question.....I would probably go with JJ Watt, but would have to strongly consider Vince Wilfork (mainly because we have never had a dominant player in the middle of the d-line)

[TKnight85]

Any Player? Hmmmm

I'd take Earl Thomas. Gotta go with the Texas Longhorns

[Dustin]

Joe Thomas.

[TKnight85]

This should be an interesting Thread

[ALuck>RG3]

Ndarnokung suh or aj green

[Gavin]

a healthy Carl Nicks

[Coltswarriors]

Adrian Peterson.

 

No question.

[NewColtsFan]

-- JJ Watt

-- Joe Thomas

-- Patrick Peterson

-- Aldon Smith

-- Calvin Johnson

 

 

Whoops.....  that appears to be more than 1...    demerit for me!   

[CardiacColts]

Adrian Peterson.
 
No question.

I couldn't agree more. Although it is tempting to think D, All Day would give us an unstoppable offense. Defenses can be solidified with average players and great coaching. Offenses however, need talent and explosive playmaking. AP would give us an unstoppable, 2 dimensional offense. Until this year, teams in the superbowl in recent history have had subpar defenses and stellar offenses. Heck, even with this years 2 teams the defenses held them in games but explosive offenses took them all the way. AP all day... 'Nuff said!

[Playoffs2013]

Richard Sherman

[Playoffs2013]

Or Ngata

[Dustin]

Richard Sherman

 

Why him over Revis or Lardarius Webb?

[Playoffs2013]

Why him over Revis or Lardarius Webb?

Younger, and less injuries

[Colts20593]

Calvin Johnson

[Dustin]

Younger, and less injuries

 

Joe Haden?

[21isSuperman]

Without question, a healthy Revis

[Playoffs2013]

Joe Haden?

more swagger

[Dustin]

more swagger

 

Fair enough.

[Dustin]

Without question, a healthy Revis

 

Yep I agree with this. I'm changing my answer.

[PatMcAfeeFan]

A healthy Darren Sproles or Megatron.

[GoColts8818]

Megatron or Larry Fitzgerald.  Think about a system in which Reggie Wayne is our second best WR?  We can still fix the line and defense in other areas.  Getting a guy like Megatron or Larry Fitzgerald wouldn't be possible any other way than a wish  

[Junior]

Calvin Johnson, AJ Green or JJ Wattt would immensely help us.

[Nobody]

Why him over Revis or Lardarius Webb?

Because he's better...

[pacolts56]

 

Calvin Johnson

Yep, Calvin Johnson....with the added bonus that it would eliminate "we should sign free agent WR (insert name)" and "we need a tall WR" Forum threads for the next 5-6 years.

I think.

[Dustin]

Because he's better...

 

He is in no way better than Revis. Webb is debatable.

[tydontlie]

He is in no way better than Revis. Webb is debatable.

Agreed. He is not better than Revis.

 

But my pick would be Calvin Johnson..the guy is just UNSTOPABLE!! (AP is a well)

[TKnight85]

I'd take Richard Sherman over Webb & Revis as well. Sherman is MUCH more Physical in both the Run & Pass Game. Add him with Vontae, we got ourselves some Tackling CB's

[Dustin]

I'd take Richard Sherman over Webb & Revis as well. Sherman is MUCH more Physical in both the Run & Pass Game. Add him with Vontae, we got ourselves some Tackling CB's

 

How is Sherman more physical than Revis? Revis jams receivers at the line better than anyone in the league by a mile. Sherman doesn't compare to Revis at any level. Revis doesn't even have safety help 75% of the time.

[TKnight85]

How is Sherman more physical than Revis? Revis jams receivers at the line better than anyone in the league by a mile. Sherman doesn't compare to Revis at any level. Revis doesn't even have safety help 75% of the time.

Revis also doesn't make certain Tackles in the Run Game. Him & Cromartie be afraid of Contact when it comes to RB's

[Truckin Sanders]

JJ Watt or Joe Thomas. Going with Watt so he wouldn't terrorize us the next decade

[tydontlie]

Revis also doesn't make certain Tackles in the Run Game. Him & Cromartie be afraid of Contact when it comes to RB's

I disagree. Revis is the most physical corner out there! not to mention prob the strongest also. He is a COMPLETE corner in the run and pass game. Cromartie on the other hand is different.

[Dustin]

Revis also doesn't make certain Tackles in the Run Game. Him & Cromartie be afraid of Contact when it comes to RB's

 

I can honestly say that I have no idea what you are talking about. Revis tackles as good as any other CB in the league. I've never seen him get run over or avoid making a tackle from the games I've seen; and I've seen a lot of Jets games over the years.

[Superman]

Offense: Calvin Johnson

Defense: JJ Watt / Patrick Willis (tie)

[ReMeDy]

Offense: Andre Johnson

Defense: Vince Wilfork

Honorable Mention: Leon Sandcastle

[Dustin]

New List:

 

Offense: Adrian Peterson or Joe Thomas

 

Defense: JJ Watt or Darrell Revis

[krunk]

Uhhhhhhhh I would be drafting this young man. Rhodes>>>>Banks

Very Smooth! Just as physical as Vontae

[sb2001]

Revis.